Creative pizzas, classic pastas & other familiar eats served in a casual space with outdoor seating. Based on 353 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
569 NJ-23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Phone: (973) 616-6620
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ashley Guerino
I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PIZZA PLACE AGAIN. I placed an order, for a Large cheese pie & buffalo boneless wings. They give me 4 boneless wings & a barley cooked pizza!!!! HORRIBLE. I talked to the kid Brandon on the phone who ignored everything I said, I asked for the manager & the manage was sarcastic and RUDE. Telling me “we give 5 wings what do you want 50? Saying I been in business for 20+ years. HORRIBLE, terrible terrible. DO NOT GO THERE
… more
Laura Pflug
I have only had reheated slices of awesome pizza, rice balls, and one plain cannoli here, but I cannot wait to come back to get the full affect with dinner. Always good food and service. Outdoor and indoor dining. They do party events too in a section I have not seen yet.
… more
Chuck Mound
The Pizzeria is a very good looking location. It makes you want to stop for pizza and once inside you will crave a cannoli. Surprising when inside, you can see that they have so much to offer. Great looking specaility slices with all kinds of cannolis and other options. I can see all of this , but nobody took the time to provide any kind of welcome. So went about the business of the regular slice for the Pizza Hunters App. The slice was above average and looked great on the plate. I tasted a hint of garlic in the sauce which provided a very good after taste to the slice. I would go back again for the slice.
… more
Boyoung Choe
I have been since 2008 and they are so nice and very delicious Italian restaurant.
… more
kedi esirgeme kurumu
One of the rudest man i have ever seen. I think owner of this place. I do not recommend to anyone!
… more
Ricky Ferhatovic
We had a coupon he did not honor and charged us more.
… more
Brad Clinton
Been going here for many years. Definitely the best Italian in the area. Love all their chicken dishes. Everything is made fresh to order. They use a quality cutlet, not like some places with a paper thin and stringy cutlet. The gnocchi and the Rigatoni Stefano are awesome pasta dishes. Love that you can see the thinly sliced garlic throughout both dishes. My go to for anything Italian. Tried the Gelato and can’t eat ice cream any more.
… more
Jennifer MacDonald
Consistently excellent food! I have been a loyal customer for the past 19 years and I have always had delicious food here. The people who own it do an amazing job with preparing fresh, homemade food that is delicious, plated well, and consistently excellent. My family’s personal favorites are their plain and specialty pizzas, spinach and egg soup, slick chick sandwich, eggplant parmigiana sandwich, flounder Francese. I have had an event there with about 40 people in their private room and everything was handled well. I’ve eaten at the pizzeria and the restaurant. The decor is beautiful! They have delicious homemade cannolis in many flavors as well as gelato. I wish them continued success in their business.
… more
alba musibay
I had a family style rehearsal dinner here for 22 people. The food was delicious, and the service great. I highly recommend it. Thank you Stefano’s for a wonderful experience
… more
Yekaterina Snitkovskaia
Great tasting pizza and large variety of canolli
… more
… View more