Everyday pizzas, slices & pastas, plus hot subs & salads, turned out in a simple space with booths. Based on 230 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
871 Elizabeth Ave, Elizabeth, NJ 07201
Phone: (908) 289-5412
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bobby Bass
While working in the area, went to Elizabeth pizza for a pie. It’s probably been 25 years since I was here last, and I guess the old man owner from that time has passed. Restaurant was clean, worker was polite and even ran out with the 2 soda’s I forgot. Pizza was good, 5 stars !!!
… more
Bob Cook
We got the Stuffed pizza and a Cheesesteak pie and loved both. The order was prepped super fast and delivered quickly and we especially loved the crust on both pizzas. A stuffed pizza was a unique experience for us and we loved it. The order came with a huge side of Red Sauce to dip and the size was great for the price.
… more
Robert Serafin
I had a large pepperoni & mushroom pizza delivered, it took about 45 mins due to Friday night call in. It was very Good . However the driver doesn’t carry much change, I did have a large bill. Total $20 > 8 decent sized slices. They offer hot & cold hoagies (sub) sandwiches, garlic knots & mozzarella sticks . Bathroom for customers only. Large seating area 9 tables X 4 person. Call ahead on weekends, busy
… more
Tobi Olmos
Been going here for the past several years and the quality of their pizza keeps improving
… more
Debbie Luque
I come 2 Elizabeth pizza with my youngest son the way they treated us was amazing the food was delicious n fresh the prices was reasonable n we just had such a great experience…. definitely with have another date night with my lil man…. Elizabeth Pizza I guys rock…..
… more
Steven
100 percent loves this place would recommend pizza is the best
… more
Diógenes
Came here to pick up some pizzas for my son’s birthday. The service was great, people were nice, and the pizzas were oh so good. All the kids liked the pizzas and, once they were gone, they wanted more. I tried a few slices myself and indeed, the pizza was delicious. Now you guys have a new client for life, looking forward to try out more of the food you sell. Thumbs up.
… more
Jason Pryor
Great pizza, may need to change their hour schedule for Sunday as it lists the closing at 10 p.m: but it’s 9:11 p.m. and no one answered the phone. So no ordering on Sunday after 9 p.m., would be helpful if this was posted!
… more
Tofiq Basam
7-29-18 I order large pizza and 12 wings.i asked them the wings to be well done and the pizza to be well done as well. After they deliver it to me I took it without looking and the delivery guy left. I opened it to eat, the pizza looked really bad and and messy, and then I open the wings I told them buffalo, and they send me the regular. It smell like bad oil. I called them to make it right but they said next time. The worst pizza and wings $37 dollar down the drain. I wish I could give them zero. If I could post a pics I would. I’m so mad
… more
Judith De Jesus
Elizabeth Pizzeria sucks. Ordered a meatball sandwich and chicken parmigiana sandwich for delivery. Meatball sandwich contained 3 meatballs because they ran out of meatballs Chicken parm contained diced up chicken and sauce. Will never go there again you shouldn’t either. Oh and I paid 27 dollars plus delivery
… more
… View more