Traditional pizzas & pastas join calzones & subs in a country-cafe setting with table service. Based on 901 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
Address:
1150 River Rd, Calabash, NC 28467
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
B Smith
A Cabalish favorite for many years. It looks to me like several generations of the same family are currently there. Everything I’ve had there has been really good. Their salad is freshly made and has lots of mozzarella cheese on top. Waitress, Louise number 24 was so attentive and nice. She kept my drink filled and I never had to ask. The pizza was delicious. The restaurant was busy and the staff were all attentive and quickly waiting on their customers. From where I was sitting , I could see into the kitchen. The kitchen was clean, neat and everyone was neatly dressed., If you have not been here and are nest y be sure to go, I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.
… more
Chad Conrad
Pizza was delicious and the service was great! First time I have seen mustard oil could see it being good on a sub. Portions very generous the antipasta salad could be shared by 3
… more
Amber Jones
Amazing pizza place to eat! Servers go above an beyond- like Jeanna- she’s a doll! Thank you! Great food, excellent service! Family friendly, and the white sauce calzone is amazing! Thank you for such a nice dining experience!
… more
Joe Hiltabidel
Holy smokes… I love pizza, it’s my favorite food on earth, always has been, and I’m almost 50 as of this writing. The pizza here is great, fantastic… But the CHEESE BREAD??? It is unbelievable. The crust is perfection, the cheese is delicious, the sauce on the side is awesome. I do not go nuts for cheese bread, it’s ok – but this cheese bread is different and I highly recommend you try this restaurant and do not leave without trying fresh, hot, cheese bread. Seriously.
… more
Paul J. Manning
Had pizza and chicken fingers from Tony’s and it was very good. The chicken fingers in particular were made really well. Super place for pizza in this area and I recommend it.
… more
Jessica Plessinger
The food was great, and our server was nice! I had the Chicken Alfredo (it was a very large serving) and my guest had the baked ziti. Would recommend both. The prices are reasonable and the food didn’t take long to be made. Would definitely come here again!! 4 stars just because the cleanliness could improve.
… more
Monica Murgatroyd
Tony’s Pizza is the most authentic NY Pizza in the area. Absolutely fantastic! The restaurant is quaint and intimate. The staff are wonderful! Great place for take out and to sit in. Enjoy!
… more
A Jones
The pizza was good, the cheese bread was very good and the meatballs and sauce were amazing. My wife had not been here for 20 years since she was a kid so the visit was mostly for nostalgia but we will be back for sure.
… more
Bryan Grice
Work in the area and decided to try it out, big mistake. Waitress was really nice and helpful. I ordered the lunch special lasagna. The food took so long to come out I had to change my order to go. Then when the food came out the toast was burnt and the serving of the lasagna was the size of a golf ball. The lasagna consisted of 90% cheese 5% noodle and 5% sauce. I am very disappointed in the food quality. I never do review but this was so bad I had to. Can’t believe I paid money for that.
… more
Harry Freeman
Staff was nice, waiter was friendly, pizza’s were very good and bacon was real bacon and smokey.
… more
… View more