Based on 211 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1583 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509
Phone: (845) 278-9632
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kim Glasford
It’s a great place for lunch. The staff is always friendly and helpful in making suggestions on what is good to eat. The slices are large, like the Westchester, Bronx, and NYC. Most times, I struggle to eat two slices. The chicken wings are amazing. Their fry fries are my go-to meal any day.
… more
Mike Marz55
We like to come here and enjoy some of the fine dishes they have. Fettuccine Alfredo, chicken marsala, meatball Parmigiana, to name a few. We live close by, so it’s always nice to have a great pizzeria and restaurant to go to and enjoy great slices and entrées, while watching sports on the tv and having some wine as well. The staff is very friendly and the service is as well. There is plenty of seating inside. While a lot of reviews here complain about the prices, it’s well worth it. Things are not cheap these days, especially during inflation, and they have a business to run and employees to pay. We will gladly pay for the delicious food they serve. We are repeat customers here and come often. Slices are big and will fill you up. The meatballs are delicious as well, on a hero or as an entrée.
… more
Glenn B_ _ _ _
Pizza here is always on point ! Been a regular for many many years while I use to live in the area. Have now been living in Florida for the past 10 years, however whenever I come back to NY to visit family I always make it a point to stop here for my NY pizza fix … and I’m always glad that I did. I’m now back in FL and already looking forward to coming back for my pizza.
… more
J OConnor
I only have gotten pizza to go from Sinapi’s. Their vegetable pizza is awesome. I think it’s called the Micheal Angelo. The people there are really nice too.
… more
Camille Thompson
Ordered a calzone with mushrooms and tomato sauce, one slice of plain pizza and a Sicilian slice. The calzone was grease and had almost no ricotta, though the mushrooms where good. The “tomato sauce” was so sweet it tasted like Campbell’s tomato soup. When I told the waitress she replied that others have said that and that marinara was available and this was when we where leaving. The pizza where terrible, no flavor and dough was raw and chewy. Will not be going back
… more
Dan Rosner
The food is incredible. Ok- not always the friendliest folks, and sometimes the service is slow. But the food is really amazing. That’s right. Five stars.
… more
Bryan Sachs
Want the closest NYC style pizza around. THIS IS THE PLACE!!!! Big slices so bring an appetite. Highly recommended!
… more
Thom4114
I’ve been going around to all the pizza places in the area… the recent price jump in pizza is ridiculous! Charging $4 for a plain slice.. The only saving grace when it comes to this place, is the size of the slice – it almost makes you feel not so violated… where they get you is topping pricing, I can not for the life of me see spending and extra $1.04 for mushrooms. The mushroom slice crust was pretty tasteless and so was the gravy. I did however enjoy the BBQ chicken slice – that crust was very tasty and the BBQ chicken was the best tasting around… enough to warrent a $6+ price tag? Idk. The days of pizza being an affordable lunch/dinner are over… the places that are charging such high prices for pizza, I don’t see making it through the up and coming recession. Also Sinapi’s customer service was a bit lack luster.
… more
Craigs List
Hey Simon!! For a new venture, you shouldn’t be SO RUDE!
… more
Liz Power
I only give positive reviews. Rob knows his customers and serves them well. Annmarie -great support staff takes care of business when ordering on phone or dining. Chicken parm to die for! Their pizza is a comfort food.
… more
… View more