Based on 219 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
71 Broadway, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407
Phone: (201) 797-0068
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Giana Williams
Tried this place for the first time and it’ll be the last. From the beginning the woman who answered the phone to take my order was rude! She charged me $25 for a large pizza and a 2 liter sprite!! Which is insane. I asked for a medium instead and she claimed they dont have mediums. When i walked in the atmosphere was extremely intense, noone welcomed you. I saw all kinds of sizes of pizza boxes. Small medium and large. When i asked about all these other sizes she says they only “sell large and jumbo” and when i looked at the size of my supposedly large box it looked like a SMALL. I was extremely confused. To make matters worse the pizza was SALTY and the tray of raviolis i asked for were tasteless and they only gave me 4!! I dont know if they were having a bad day but they have nasty attitudes especially the cashier!! She’s MISERABLE!! Regardless i wouldn’t recommend this place, even if they had better customer service the pizza was salty and the pies are miniature!
… more
Danielle Vespia
I messed up! I called and ordered from the wrong Stefanos (called the one in Elmwood Park). After my daughter reemed me a new one Bec she was at the Peq one waiting for our pick up . I called the Elmwood Park store back to pay for my mistake , letting them know we couldn’t make it and I apologized and wanted to pay for our food regardless.
… more
Sage Mathew
First time at this pizzeria. They were about to close in another 1 hour when I came in for a few slices. The pizza was okay. The mozzerala cheese didn’t taste as traditional as I would have liked and the tomato sauce was a tad bit too acidic for my tastes. It was still a decent pizza though. It was better than any assembly line pizza place.
… more
Bike Life NJ
RIP to Stefano’s Pizza been going there for years went the other day and was so disappointed..,it was sold and now it’s a chicken spot like the ones in Paterson… I’m from Paterson and would drive to Stefano’s just for real Italian pizza for excellent price
… more
Yvonne Aguia
Wow!!!
… more
Yerlyn Maria Abarca Lopez
1st time eating here and I must say, super delicious pizza. Perfect amount of sauce, cheese and toppings. The crust is just the right amount of crispy. I hope theyre that good all the time.
… more
Robert Znak
Wanted to try a new place. Ordered a margarita with soda and mac and cheese bites. Ordered thru the slice app. Once i got the message that they left it at my door i come out to see my sodas and mac and cheese bites and no pizza. I called them to see if there was a drop off mistake or they forgot it but no. They just didn’t have the pizza. I got no call, no text, no info that didn’t have have that pizza or even a different pizza because all of the standard specialtys cost the same. Just the fact that the lady from slice said they just don’t have that one and that was my explanation started this review, literally the ingredients for almost every pizza other than some basil. Maybe there good, but at this point I will never know. The mac and cheese bites we’re also cold. They refunded after i called, i checked, definitely after i called.
… more
Enmanuel Gil
From the moment you walk in everyone is greeting you and friendly! The waitress was friendly and fast, we got sat down right away and our order taken in a perfect time. The food was amazing and a big portion so we took some home. Definitely a place I would visit again
… more
Gabriel Argudo Jr
Stefano’s pizza was excellent. It was hot and the crust was soft. I give it a 9
… more
Koran Lawson
The worst grilled chicken salad I ever had. Chicken wasn’t edible.
… more
… View more