Thin-crust pizza, pasta & Italian mains, plus a lunch buffet, in a casual setting with a fireplace. Based on 463 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
16201 W National Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151
Phone: (262) 786-6699
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nathania Massie
We dined in-great food, great service. We had the gluten free chicken marsala, gluten free penne with marinara and combo plate and meatballs. (See pics) Updated interior with a cozy feel. The dining area has a fireplace in it-super cute! Outdoor seating available, nice bar and counter height tables. Entrance is wheelchair friendly. Would definitely recommend. BONUS: They have gluten-free pizza and also gluten free dinner options.
… more
Bekah Lyon
This is a quiet Italian place right on national avenue in New Berlin. They remodeled at some point in the last few years so it’s a nicer vibe on the inside for sure. Very cute silverware chandelier in the front entryway! On this trip my husband got his own pizza so he had leftovers for lunches…he liked the pizza. It wasn’t like the best he’s ever had, but it was good! I’m on keto to lose more than a few unwanted pounds so I bypassed the pizza and went with their blackened cod. Yes…it was $17. But it was SOOO GOOD. They give you two roughly 5 oz chunks of cod, so I was able to eat the one and take the other home. Even the next day reheating it in the microwave for a minute was all it needed and it was just as good day2. It’s a quiet place, has a small bar attached you can drink in while you wait and you get bread and butter at the table.
… more
Joe Welch
Really loved everything about it here. Great menu and waitress. Eggplant appetizer was the best ever. My Sicilian pork chops were delicious and the blackened cod my friend had was also amazing. I will be back
… more
Kristopher Woppert
Our first visit and we were very happy. Our server, Kathy, was very attentive, nice and genuine. The menu selections where of the usual Italian restaurants you’d find in the area. However, the food was outstanding. One of the best meatballs in the area. The texture, flavor and presentation was top notch. A wonderfully rich and tasty Marsala sauce for my beautiful wife was also a hit. They took us as a walk in and were very accommodating. Salads were very fresh and a large amount of dressing was provided. The old fashions were well done although made with Jero still very very good. We got there at the elderly seating time. Lol. But by 5:30 it was starting to fill up. Big dinning space but a small parking lot.
… more
Jeff Ircink
Online it’s advertised as all-you-can-eat fish fry – but not on the menu. Our server said you can get 3 additional pieces of fish in addition to the 3 you get with your original meal.
… more
Greg Mehlberg
Ordered a 3 Topping Pizza and Fettuccine Alfredo. Service was excellent. Light music playing in background. Very Relaxing. I am so full. Excellent Food. Will come back here if we can. Wait staff very outgoing and friendly.
… more
Bill
Our first time at Armeli’s, was a wonderful dinning experience. Our server was outstanding and the food was fantastic. We will definitely be back.
… more
Holly RH
The good: the bread, the bad, pretty much everything else. Dust on the banquette so thick you could write on it. Wait staff who are clueless about the customer experience. Pancetta in the carbonata as hard as a rock, sour tasting. Take a pass
… more
Suzanne Ragsdale
There were 3 people in our group and we all had a great experience. Food was very good. Had Lasagne and pasta. Will probably try the pizza next time.
… more
John Klose
A nice centrally located fireplace in dining room, fast and friendly service, and only request would be for chef/ owner to add a chocolate chip cookie sized pizza to menu for dessert and for birthday occasions!
… more
… View more