Based on 135 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
Address:
54 W Waterloo St, Canal Winchester, OH 43110
Phone: (614) 833-1221
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Shawn Tolbert
I had this once before but it was a while ago. We wanted something different so we used Door dash and had this delivered. Everything was super hot. So kudos to Doordash and Renaldi’s for keeping everything nice and hot. The pizza (all the way) was excellent and cooked to perfection. The crust is a medium build with nice fluffiness but some crunch to go with it. Sauce was great as well and all the toppings completed it. We also ordered an Italian Sub and it to was simply amazing. I highly recommend Renaldi’s Pizzeria. Please hit the the Like Button if this was helpful.
… more
Jodi Lewis
First time trying this pizzeria. Friendly staff, and quickly made for pick up. Ordered a simple pep pizza tonight, crust not think or thin, just perfect in my opinion – but kind of flavorless. Sauce was tasty though. Stringy cheese and spicy pepperoni. Will eat here again as an alternate to other pizza places around town.
… more
Monique Kielkopf
Since we moved to Canal 2 years ago, Renaldi’s is always our go to! It’s constantly great and the service is stellar. The house pizza is great, a little spicy. We usually add in the chef salad with Italian, amazing! Their subs are fantastic as well! You can’t go wrong!
… more
T Cray
Absolutely the best pizza around! The boy and I wanted to try a local pizza joint and we weren’t disappointed! We both loved it. We will be back!
… more
Kathleen Boynton
Pizza is the best. Haven’t tried anything else yet. Pricey but worth it. None of that $5 cardboard tomato soup pizza.
… more
GoBlu Rick
I would give a zero but it wouldn’t let me. The most disorganized food service I have EVER had the displeasure of ordering from. Last time we were told 35 minutes it was well over an hour. This time I was told 35-40 min. Arrived 40 min later and paid for my pizza. Waited for 15min and enjoyed conversation with a sheriff deputy whose pizza took over an hr, was then told by an employee they forgot to make my order. I will NEVER enter this DUMP again!!
… more
Ethan Hunter
Our experience went like this: driving home from spring break and looking for great pizza, googled this and saw great reviews by locals. Having worked at a pizza place owned by Italians myself I am a great judge of pizza.
… more
Candy R. “Candy cane” Jones
Ordered large half mushroom and half groundbeef,family liked it crust was pretty good nice business, will eat there again
… more
Alex S
The inside of this place is borderline health violation, but good lord the pizza is amazing. If you are in between Grape vine (I’ve always had super dry crust from them), Kingys (just overpriced donatos), or this place, I would give Renaldis a try. The spicy sauce is right on the money, crust is above average, and toppings/cheese are generous but not overdone.
… more
Jesse L
Great overall experience. Pizza is delivered on time, and the delivery girl is always friendly. They do an exceptional job loading up on toppings. Crust could use some flavor, but still an excellent choice for dinner!
… more
… View more