Based on 488 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
513 U.S. Rte 2, South Hero, VT 05486
Phone: (802) 372-5454
Website: http://www.mckeespubsvt.com/island/
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
william harlow
We ordered pizza. The pizza had way too much red sauce, and way too much cheese, making it very soggy. The other toppings we had on the pizza, mushrooms and onions, were fine. We ordered a tossed salad to have before the pizza, and that never made it to the table. We saw one pizza from another table being returned to the kitchen, which is what we should have done for a much needed re-do. The waitress was terrible. She claimed to know us from a previous visit, but we hadn’t been there before, this time. When she brought the check over, it was wrong, and it took her forever to return to our table to cash us out. We are new to the area, but pass this place by.
… more
Brandon Hatch
The place was dirty and ceilings were yellow. The food that I ordered was horrible. The bar tender was doing her normal job plus playing cook. This place attracts nothing but nasty people that smoke cigarettes outside the door. I would avoid this place at all cost.
… more
Edward Wright
Stopped for a pizza along the way. Loved it a lot. Friendly service and great food, very cool atmosphere too.
… more
John Young
The server was rarely seen. They were not terribly busy. One of us had to go to the server station to get more water. We chose one of the featured pizzas. It had very little flavor and slices fell apart as served. Seems like a nice place to hang out at the bar, but our experience was less than satisfactory.
… more
Wyatt&Taylor
First off they said it would take 15-20 min so I waited and went in after 20 minutes had gone by. Then as I get in there they dropped all of the food on the floor so they had to remake everything. I sat inside for about an hour and a half. I was furious. Then as they brought it out, I get in my car to open up my wings and turns out they weren’t what I ordered at all. The kind that none of my family will eat because none of us like that kind. Then I open up the poutine to find that the fry’s are soggy and falling apart. Would not recommend and definitely not going back.
… more
Elaine D
A delightful rustic ‘locals’ feel. Excellent food and service. Downside is location right on the state road, very noisy if you sit outside. Not easily wheelchair accessible. Drive has deep ruts. But I would come again as the feel is very casual and the food is great. Large gluten free section on the menu. Server was knowledgeable about the beers.
… more
Katherine “Kat Wilson” Wilson
First have to give credit to the one lady who is always there busting her a** and seems like she’s the only one servicing the whole restaurant.
… more
Joanne Sharer
I have trouble finding places to accomdate my food allergies. This place had many gluten free options. Gluten free buns, glutenfree pizza gluten free pasta. And I am not talking about 1 of each. They have several choices. The salads are spectacular. The burger is fresh and juicy (not greasy) I have nothing bad to say. Staff friendly. Good beer selectio . OH and my dog was welcomed!! Highly recommend
… more
Michael S
Nice place to eat if you’re visiting. The poutine was deliciuos and highly recommended. Our pizza was also delicious. The staff was very friendly with a comfortable atmosphere. A great place to stop and eat if you’re driving through.
… more
Tory Gaudette
I’ve only ordered a few times, pizzas and calzones.. the pizza, I didn’t care for the soggy crust. I specifically order toppings that will not contribute to a soggy crust. This evening I ordered a calzone.. the entire thing was under cooked and disgusting and soggy!
… more
… View more