No-frills counter serve offering Neapolitan- & Sicilian-style pies, pasta, cheeseburgers & salads. Based on 443 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
206 Campbelltown Rd, Palmyra, PA 17078
Phone: (717) 838-0181
Website: http://bartolospizzapalmyrapa.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alan Metcalf
This is a great place to pick-up good, quality pizza. The pie itself has a sweet sauce setting it apart from other pizzas in the area. Service is quick & consistent. Prices are on par with other pizza shops in the area, they actually tend to be just a bit less expensive. You can order, have it ready quick, get in & out fast and be home to enjoy. Highly recommend.
… more
Eric Brown
Theee best pizza bar none. Crust, sauce and cheese is better than any other pizza shop for miles around. Always friendly and always fresh!! I have 3 pizza shops nearby but travel twice as far to eat Bartolo’s !!
… more
Mackenzie Lafferty
Outstanding pizza! Definitely my favorite by far. I live close by and have been going here for years and no other pizzeria has ever topped it. Perfect, cozy atmosphere that exemplifies little Italy with excellent service!
… more
Beth Logsdon
Reminds my of the shop I worked at back home. Pizza was good and greasy. I do prefer a crispier crust but it was good none the less! It got a thumbs up from my youngest who is something of a connoisseur when it comes to pizza. Great place to eat when you’re in town for a hockey tournament!
… more
Sammy Sellers
Small town pizza shop that checks all the boxes! Now my opinion might be bias but they have the best pizza in the area because of their sauce! Bread is perfect, crispy exterior while light and fluffy inside!
… more
Karen Demmy
We eat here quite often and it’s the best pizza around……but the restaurant itself is always in bad need of a good cleaning.
… more
Nathan George
A simple yet sublime eatery. The subs are baked fresh and the bread is easily the best I have ever tasted for a sandwich. I know mayo may not be everyone’s favorite but Bartolos Mayo really adds layers to their sandwich flavor. The pizza is also wonderful, similar to NY style. I would come from out of state to eat at this place.
… more
Deb Nestico
We are customers for life! Best pizza/food, and they are always so friendly. Highly recommend!!
… more
Craig Good
I loved going here as a kid! They had great pizza and great service. Coming back as an adult 20 years later is a bit different. The food was fine, it was as expected compared to other pizza restaurants in the area. The restaurant is a bit rough, but the service was on point.
… more
Mark Flocken
Great place to grab lunch or dinner . Dine-in or take out .
… more
… View more