Unassuming Italian eatery with limited seating offering pies, hoagies & pizza by the slice. Based on 136 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4512 Liberty Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15224
Phone: (412) 621-8960
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Flynn O’Brien
Was up there during little Italy days yesterday and today for pizza. It was fantastic. Glad to see there back at the original location after a fire 3yrs ago. They remodeled the whole inside and now have tables and a high counter to sit at and eat along with plenty of televisions, air conditioning and restrooms. And at some point they’ll be adding alcohol to there menu. I’ll definitely be back in the future.
… more
mcstivi
really nice staff and all, but like angelo’s up the street, this place is just mediocre, everything felt basic, simple, and just a little bland
… more
Natalie Deicas
Everything was delicious!! I order a Pizza burger not on the menu yet!! And it was amazing and the service was wonderful. Go go go support local businesses.
… more
Luh Ren
I wanted to try a new pizza place as I grew tired of the places I usually go , I decided to give these guys a shot because they are close to me and the photo reviews look delicious. Ordered a medium pepperoni pizza and chicken tenders and It was better than I hoped for plus the price was right in my budget. Had friends over and they were asking where I ordered from lol. I will definitely order from here again
… more
Doing it Hard
I started eating this pizza years ago when I was in college. I don’t spend the entire year in Pittsburgh anymore but I always make a point to have this pizza if I’m in town. In my opinion it is the finest pizza in the city of Pittsburgh! And over the past 20 years nothing has changed, the quality and ingredients are still top-notch. There’s no scrimping. Also it was great to see the staff sanitizing their Hands and following good cleaning protocols today! I highly recommend this merchant!
… more
Alexis A
Best pizza in Pittsburgh. Hands down. No contest. The dough here is incredible, the pizza barely even needs the toppings! We have had a medium pepperoni and buffalo chicken countless times and they never disappoint.
… more
ramona corner
I liked the food and had become a pretty regular customer. Most recently I observed one of the cooks digging in his teeth with his finger, lifted his hat and ran his hands through his hair and then put his hands directly in a big bin full of cheese! I can never go back, especially given the virus that we are all dealing with in one way or another. Restaurants should be taking more than the usual care to keep customers safe. Disappointed
… more
Karen J
I would have given 5 stars if they didn’t mess up the steak hogie. I said NO tomatoes! And add mayonnaise. The put tomatoes on it and Italian dressing. Totally disgusting, threw the hogie in the trash , waste of money. Pizza and fries on the other hand was amazing.
… more
Callie Munch
Okay, so… I hate leaving reviews for a restaurant I only tried once, I like to get another shot before I review but they aren’t getting my business again. I ordered through Postmates and the delivery was fine, no complaints there. I read reviews on here (pretty positive for the most part) before I ordered since I never had Pizza Italia before and I like trying new places. I wasn’t impressed at all. First of all, I had just one bite of the breadsticks and threw them away. Tasted/looked/smelt like the cheap ones you get at the grocery store. Was a total waste of money. The pizza was lame. Nothing special about it. An okay crust, okay sauce and bland cheese. There is like sooooo spices or anything to give it taste and the cheesy was just chewy, not melty.
… more
Brittney Rice
The girl at the register was the kindest person I’ve met yet in Pittsburgh! However the Greek Calzone stole the show and was above and beyond delicious! All of the flavors combine were just perfectly balanced. Definitely an all time favorite now!
… more
… View more