DeLullo’s Trattoria, in Cicero, IN, is the area’s leading restaurant serving Cicero, Atlanta, Arcadia, Tipton, Noblesville and surrounding areas since 2012. We offer pasta, pizza, farm-to-table food, fresh sea scallops, a full bar, liquor, wine, weekend and chef’s specials, carryout, catering and much more. For your next meal, visit DeLullo’s Trattoria in Cicero.
Based on 365 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
230 W Jackson St, Cicero, IN 46034
Phone: (317) 420-0074
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Katie Cordell
Ordered for the first time, and got take out. Cheese pizza was okay, good breadsticks but shocked by this “entree” salad that cost $6. So unappetizing and small, we didn’t even bother eating it.
… more
Thomas Brackett III
Nice little family-owned Italian place. It’s always great to have a go-to Italian restaurant other than Olive Garden. Food is good, nothing super crazy. Service is great and quick. One of the best spots in Cicero to stop at for a weekend date.
… more
E dawg
Dined outside in a large group of 10. Very good food at reasonable prices. Wait staff very attentive and efficient. Not crowded for a Saturday night but it should be.
… more
charles dale
First time visiting. We really enjoyed eating on the back deck. Cocktails and appetizers were very good as was our dinners. Staff was really friendly. Came from indy was a little bit of a trip but worth it.
… more
Kris Deutsch
All of our dinners were fantastic! Fairly priced, casual yet nice, above-and-beyond service, and (expected) large Italian portions. Will be back!
… more
Jennifer Egan
Everything was so delicious, service was great, the prices were great, large portions and a very nice atmosphere. I regret not trying DeLullo’s sooner as I’ve wanted to since they opened.
… more
Adrienne Rogers
Great time celebrating a birthday with friends today! Food was amazing. Don’t forget to make a reservation. Fills up fast. Highly recommend it.
… more
Gary Hansel
absolute favorite, food is always tasty and served as ordered. staff is attentive and very friendly. have never had a bad meal EVER. we go year around and have enjoyed every visit. Will continue to make DeLullo’s the go to spot.
… more
Dan Y
Oh my goodness, first time at DeLullo’s this week. Went on a Friday evening, about 530 pm and ate indoors. Service was quick, portions were huge, and very delicious! We had the bread sticks, covered in parmesan cheese, lasagna (oh my gosh!!!) and the pesto ravioli. All were fresh, piping hot and absolutely delicious. The hot, mulled cider with a bourbon splash was also very satisfying. Kayla was our server and, even though she said she was new, she did an outstanding job making sure we were happy. Price point was a little above average, but with the quantity of did we had, c was well worth it! Give it a try, you’ll be glad you did.
… more
Jason Ricketts
My father raves about this place but I wasn’t very impressed. The table they sat us at was cramped in a corner. The food was ok but way overpriced for what I had. I ordered the baked pasta and was disappointed. It was multicolored rotini that you can buy in any store. A little cheese in the center of the pile that was barely melted. Topped with a watery marinara sauce. Nothing about the dish seemed baked to me. Just a pasta dish slapped together. For the quality of the food it should have been half the price. My wife just got a basic chicken Alfredo which was less expensive and she was happy with. My dad had the veal special which he said was good but only ate half of and declined to take it home. Couldn’t have been that good. I feel like we could have gotten similar quality for much less price at Olive Garden. The service was well done though. If I go back I would try something simpler and lower cost like a sandwich or pizza.
… more
… View more