Based on 32 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
18 Mckabe Rd, Colton, NY 13625
Phone: (315) 274-2014
Website: http://www.bakerssizzlinggrill.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bree
We got a large 16” pepperoni pizza, 1/2 dozen mild bone-in wings, 1/2dozen bbq wings, and an order of garlic knots. We were starving passing through Colton which is rare and saw this on google with all good reviews and went for it. But man were we disappointed… I will say that it’s pretty hard to mess up a pizza, and they did. I’m sorry but I’ve tried lots of pizza and I’m usually not picky but by the end of my slice I was about to gag. The wings were awful. The chewiest, fattiest weirdest tasting wings. We stomached the bbq wings since there was enough sauce to mask the cheap chicken taste. I’ve had better food from 7-11/Sunoco! The garlic knots were supposed to be no cheese and there was a layer of crusted stinky cheese on the bottom of them. They were not light airy garlic goodness. They were thick dense dry slabs of bread and somehow still raw. This place really reminded me why we don’t try new places and stick to what I know. My dog who eats anything, didn’t even want this food. My boyfriend ended up getting sick later on.. We just wanted some good food and this was EXTREMELY upsetting. I just don’t want someone else to go through what we did. Disregard all these good reviews people! Pizza is deceiving as it looks great but it is NOT
… more
Samantha Dugan
This is easily our favorite restaurant in the area. We order from here on an almost weekly basis, so much that I kind of wish they had a points system! Haha. The only complaint that I have is that they ever close! We regularly order their specials like beef tips, turkey dinner, and prime rib; and we regularly order pizza, burgers, wings, homemade Mac and cheese, and various appetizers! They make at least most things fresh and homemade! If you need some catering or a good family dinner then this is the place to go! They are good people and I feel more than welcome every time I walk in the door. Also, I’ve been able to speak directly to the owner on occasion and it’s so relieving to know we have someone that cares about the community here. Baker’s goes above and beyond to accommodate customers.
… more
Jenny Virnig
We were thrilled & looking forward to ordering when we received their menu in our post office box just before they opened – and we were not disappointed when we did!
… more
Brad Jenkins
I contacted Bakers Sizzling Grill via email with a request to deliver 10 dozen wings, four large pizza’s, poutine and side salads to a family gathering. They contacted me promptly to verify details and then quoted me a price. Communication and food delivery was all handled with professionalism. We tried five different flavors of wings and they were all very good and the pizza was praised by everyone. I am accustomed to Long Island / NYC pizza and wings and didn’t expect much, but was pleasantly surprised. Well done!
… more
Marta K-J
We order from here weekly. You can never go wrong on the pizza, or the specials. The salads are huge and often split in our household. My daughter also loves the mac and cheese. They are a take/out delivery only establishment and deliver within 15 miles which is amazing! Oh and if I didn’t mention their calzones yet, those are delicious as well!
… more
Tri Pe
Great fish fry!…but the hours are so limited. I often want to order between noon and 4 and they don’t open until 4. I think when you’re in a remote location where many customers have to travel, it would help to expand hours a bit.
… more
Emma Young
I’ve ordered from Bakers Sizzling Grill 2 times now. I’ve gotten the white pizza and a pepperoni. The pizza is always great…but both times we have ordered our food has been at least 45 minutes late. (or past the estimated delivery time) the pizza was still semi warm, good but not hot, fresh pizza.
… more
Cameron Vengenz
Always high quality food and excellent service. They take their time and call you if they’re running a little late. One of the best local pizza places in the North Country.
… more
Andrew King
We order out from Baker’s a fair bit, and while sometimes they’re a few minutes late, they’re service and food quality is WELL worth the wait. You guys have a permanent customer.
… more
Joelene Curry
Food is always good if I have an issue it might be the delivery time. But over all great. Friendly staff.
… more
… View more