Based on 309 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
15 Market St, Westfield, NY 14787
Phone: (716) 326-3415
Hours
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chad Fagan
I wish we could rate Calarco’s more than 5 stars! When we arrived one of the owners came out to let us know we could sit on the restaurant side. It was quiet and the perfect kind of setting we needed after a long day of travel! The food was excellent. This is a family style restaurant that has been operated by the same family for 90+ years. The owners were kind, welcoming and all smiles. We’d love a chance to come by again!
… more
Coffee Now
A hidden treasure in Westfield, located off Main Street(Route 20). Fourth generation owned business, nice cozy atmosphere.
… more
Patrick Fuhrman
We were in Westeren New York for the day, antique shopping. Using Google Maps, we found this little Italian restaurant with some history to it, noted by the images on the wall and dated dacor. The steward was nice and suggested having their sauce with our meals. The sides came out quickly with salad and fresh dinner rolls, which were hot and steamy. But this is where things went south very fast. The almost twenty-five minute wait between our sides and the parmesan was tremendous; with little patrons to show for it. Thinking of the history in this establishment allowed us to then enjoy their family gravy with our meals.
… more
Uncle Dave Lewis
Nice restaurant for meeting friends to talk! Waitress was wonderful! Fish was some of the best we’ve had!!! Great flavor, and we had the choice of sweet potato fries, which we like.
… more
Kylan Connolly
I love an old town style Italian joint. I’ve been coming here for close to 20 years and the decor hasn’t changed (for the better). I really love the friendly atmosphere of Calarco’s and the food really matches up to the staff. I went recently with friends from out of town and we were extremely satisfied by both the portion size and the flavor of our entrees. I highly recommend the lasagna, but the veal cutlet is also incredible.
… more
Ed Smith
The Italian platter and lasagna dinners were very good. The side salad was fresh and had a nice variety of vegetables. They had a large number of customers on a Sunday night and ran out of ready to serve bread. The kitchen baked some fresh loaves and they were crispy and delicious, perfect for soaking up some of the pasta sauce.
… more
Stephanie Metzler
The coleslaw was like OMG awesome!!!!!!!!!!! Service is kind of in limbo but it was busy and it really took a while to get our fooooood
… more
Lou Dimovich
Our third time, exceptional homestyle cooking. I had the lasagna, as expected very good, wish portion was a little bigger. Their sauce is their trademark.
… more
Dangerous Winnie
I headed here with my teenage kiddo on a Monday night figuring it wouldn’t be too busy. It wasn’t exactly busy but there seemed to be only one waitress and we waited a long time for just about everything. I got their meatball float, which I just LOVED. I loved the flavor of the sauce and the size, texture and flavor of the meatballs. The bread that came with it was perfectly crispy and chewy. My son didn’t like his Chicken Alfredo at all. I had a bite and it had a strong taste that may have been wine? Not sure. I didn’t care for it either. We waited quite a while for the waitress to ever come back to give us the bill. When she asked if we needed a box we told her neither of us liked it. She offered to bring him something else but by then all we wanted was to leave.
… more
Jim Hubbard
I wouldn’t go back. Food is ehhhh. We did a sampler platter. I added a 6 dollar side salad..lol 4 pieces of iceberg lettuce, a grape tomato, and a slice of cucumber…
… more
… View more