Based on 66 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2666 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505
Phone: (814) 836-7600
Website: http://colonypizzaandcatering.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 1–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
M D
Thin and crispy, refreshing and balanced sauce, and the perfect ammount of cheese. Really outstanding and will probably be the only pizza I eat in Erie.
… more
Joshua Mabin
Eric (I’m assuming the owner) was extremely friendly from the time I picked up the phone to order a large order for a group of kids to when I arrived and he went above and beyond to make sure we not only had everything we needed but that we were well taken care of to get the food to our bus.
… more
Donna W
Sick and tired of small business crying about how expensive everything is,we the customers feel it too. Ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza, picked it up. Got home and realized it was just mushroom. The best part was when we called to bring it to their attention that Larry could have cared less. First he blamed it on VNET making their phone full of static,not the case as the order was clearly repeated over the phone. Then he put the blame on us saying that we should have known that $19.07 wasn’t enough for a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza. We don’t work there or own the business. What I do know Larry is that we will NEVER be back. One thing you’re forgetting. There are plenty of pizza shops in Erie. Just get it right for any future customers,can you do that Larry?? More than likely NO.
… more
Kayla Gentile
We were welcomed immediately when walking in (first time there). As much as I wanted 15 other things on the menu, especially the option to have white sauce which is MY THING….
… more
Jameson Zuber
Hoagies were absolutely delicious! Eric makes all his dough in-house, was super kind and charismatic, and he didn’t kick us out for being Bills fans! If you’re in town this is the place to go
… more
Thomas Joseph
This pizza shop screams Pittsburgh! Order a white pizza with pepperoni, you won’t regret it.
… more
Loring Prest
We moved to the east side of Erie (NW HCreek) last fall. We tried some local pizza places, but were disappointed. My neighbor said he drives across town to the west side to get pizzas, etc. from Colony. Today, we finally got a Colony pizza (the CBP). This is the best pizza I’ve had in a really long time! My wife described it as “perfect.” They make the pizza dough right there every day, and it was perfectly cooked. The BBQ sauce was delicious, as were the toppings. I know where I’m going to get my next pizza! Btw, the owner and his assistant were very friendly and helpful in helping me choose my pizza. He said he’s been in Erie 30 years. Go there, keep him in business, and we’ll all be happy!
… more
Jack M
Highly recommend. Went there the other day to grab a pizza and some cinnamon knots, they were fantastic. Best pizza in Erie!
… more
Lynn Gray
I’ve been searching for good pizza in Erie, and this is it. Has an authentic taste that reminds me of the pizza I used to get when I lived in a big city. I just tried it for the first time last night, and my husband and I finished our large cheese, pepperoni, onion and meatball pizza today. It’s even better the second day!
… more
Alysia Lunger
Tried the pizza for the first time yesterday n its by far my favorite in erie. I’m not a fan of overwhelming amounts of sauce on pizza and that is very hard to find but I found it here lol. The home made dough was delicious too. The Pepperoni on top had a little crisp too them and spice. Yummmmm all around.
… more
… View more