Flowers fill a comfy patio at this family-owned eatery dishing pizza, pasta & Italian staples. Based on 458 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
Center Of Town, 4952 Lake Shore Dr, Bolton Landing, NY 12814
Phone: (518) 644-2041
Website: http://catesitaliangarden.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 12 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 2–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 2–9 PM |
| Monday | 2–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Laura Kavanaugh
We arrived at 4:01. Party of two, first customers of the evening. It took over an hour to get our food. It seemed as though the larger tables received all of the servers’ attention. When we got our food, it took about 10 minutes to flag down someone to ask them for some red sauce. The place smelled extremely musty. The decor was bizarre. Wish I had taken a photo of the strange picture that was hanging by my husband. It was of a chef that looked deranged. And on the very next wall there was the exact same creepy picture! The tossed salads we got were simply some mixed greens with a couple of cherry tomatoes and sliced canned black olives tossed in a very astringent and tart balsamic vinaigrette and they cost $13 each. My gluten free pasta was cooked well. Not mushy. But was quite blah tasting (which is why I was wanting the side of red sauce) My husband reported that the chicken Masala was good. Disappointed that they didn’t have gluten free bread available. My his brother reported the bread that he had was chewy and had possibly been microwaved. Took quite a while to get our to go boxes and check. They charged an almost 7% fee to use a credit card! When we asked another server where the notice of this charge is, she apologetically informed us it was on the menu. I am sure that we are not the only hungry, weary travelers who missed that little tidbit of information. Fortunately, we were able to have the credit card charged removed and were able to pay for our meal in cash which saved us $7. Overall a very disappointing first meal on our vacation in Bolton Landing.
… more
Rebecca Benzing
Very good. It’s easy to see why they are such a popular spot right on the main drag. We dined with 7 people on Saturday at 7 ish and though there was a small wait, which is to be expected, we were seated and fed rather quickly. Gnocchi was delicious and my son loved his meatball. Everyone in our party was rather pleased. I would go again for sure.
… more
Doreen Romeo
The food was fantastic!! As well as the drinks. The hostess was so friendly. Our waitress was so sweet! Definitely will return over the summer
… more
kuchifrito
Never been to Bolton Landing. Decided to stop by for some pizza and it didn’t disappoint. They were THAT close to a 5 star. The welcoming was absolutely remarkable. Location perfect and food was good. I definitely would recommend. Their tomato sauce is delicious. Would I go back? ABSOLUTELY!
… more
Zach Rieger
We got take out so I can only judge only on my experience with take out. The bartender was definitely stressed with all the orders coming in. BE AWARE if you get take out they add 15% gratuity the pizza definitely wasn’t the best but some of the other food looked great. Maybe just avoid getting take out from them. It looks like a great fine dining experience.
… more
Eric P Connolly
I went in with low expectations. My lasagna was a salt bomb with next to no tomato sauce. My wife’s chicken piccata was an oil based lemon sauce instead of a butter, lemon, parsley, chicken stock sauce. Literally the only things that were good was the bread, the free water with lemon, and the mixed vegetables on my wife’s plate. Our server was not friendly, didn’t ask us if we wanted our calf eaten food wrapped (answer would have been no), and didn’t even try to sell us dessert. Please go anywhere else. Oh, almost forgot they store extra boxes of wine in the main dining room. That’s a new one for me.
… more
Steve Hansen
We ordered the 17” square pizza instead of the 14” round, for just $3 more. The pizza was very good but was not square. It was 12” X 17” rectangular, so was 85 sq inches less than promised.
… more
Christopher Matte
Food was excellent. Wine was good. Was told 15 minute wait and took 30 but not a big deal, it was a beautiful night outside. Very nice location and our waitress was great.
… more
Alex Masiello
I had a double shot espresso. They charged me for two espressi. I paid over $13.00. The bartender put lemon in my espresso without asking. Very bad place, don’t go there. I pray to god that this place goes bankrupt soon and that the owner shall experience misery!
… more
Len L.
Very good pizza and apps. Good service which was fast and efficient. Tries to look like upscale but 3 stars because money grabbers charging patrons extra surcharge for using a credit card. Very cheesey!
… more
… View more