Based on 126 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3734 NY 104, Williamson, NY 14589
Phone: (315) 904-2022
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 3–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
R H
Awesome. Stopped in this week for the meatball sub, my husband had the Marina Sauce with spaghetti. The homemade bread was hot out of the oven with seasoned whipped butter on the side. The home made dressings were fabulous ( Peppercorn, Ranch). The food was served hot and delicious. Prices were super good for lunch. Will be back.
… more
Matt Ruffell
Great Italian dishes. The red sauce is pork based with just the right amount of garlic and spices. The Alfredo and Blush sauce are both great. The pasta is cooked perfectly. The tripe appetizer is excellent. Good portions and decent prices. The food quality is surprisingly good for a small unremarkable location.
… more
bob hewitt
All you would ever expect for authentic Italian cuisine! Our waitress was working by herself, and did a fantastic job of taking care of all of her patrons! Will be back! 🙂
… more
Nathan Bantle
Even though this doesn’t look like 5 star experience on the inside the food is an easy 5 star. Simple and excellent menus selection. Incredible portion sizes. Food was incredible and the free garlic butter and fresh bread was phenomenal. The kids menu is a great price and also massive. My 10 year old was stuffed which rarely ever happens. Will definitely return!
… more
Annette Lauricella
This place was a wonderful discovery during our stay in Sodus NY. The service was wonderful, the food was excellent, the portions are generous and prices and reasonable. The bread is delicious and served warm. You can bring your own wine for a $5 uncorking fee since they do not serve beer or wine. They happily provide wine glasses, which makes it very nice. We would recommend this place to everyone. Definitely did not disappoint. Thank you staff for a great experience.
… more
Karen Zenkel
We went on a Friday night. Didn’t have a reservation, but we were seated within 15 minutes. The waitress apologized for wait. The food was amazing and the service was great. As we were leaving, we said that we would be back and the waitress thanked us again for our patience.
… more
Catch 22
I absolutely love dining at Peppinos! Peppinos Italian Eatery is located in Williamson, NY and serves authentic Italian cuisine and other delectable dishes to enjoy. The building itself is remarkably clean and the vibe is very cozy and chill. They have a very nice menu with lots to choose from ranging from bread to main courses and desserts. The kid’s menu has some pretty good choices for the youngsters too! They serve a variety of drinks including Soda, lemonade and even Wine for the older kids. My dining experience from the time I walked in the door to the time I left was wonderful. We were seated and served by Jessica and she delivered exceptional service and she was very nice and fun to talk to and knew the menu very well. Jessica was actually a highlight of my trip and I’d go back just to see her again. And to eat the delicious Italian food of course. 5 stars!
… more
Colleen Formicola
Service is really good. Very small on the inside. It still has stark white walls from the previous owner. Nothing about the decor suggests it’s an Italian restaurant, no updates or improvements. We ordered the shrimp scampi and fish fry. Our bill was $59.83 they automatically add a service charge if you don’t pay cash! I hate being nickeled and dimed! Definitely a little over priced for a small town. The food was just OK. Definitely not worth the price. Staff was friendly and attentive.
… more
Mary Ann Oakley
My husband and I went to dinner there last night for his birthday. We definitely enjoyed it. The bread and garlic butter were put on our table when we sat. Great way to start. The salad was very fresh with more than the usual lettuce, cucumber and tomatoes. My husband had the ribeye steak. It was cooked a perfect med-rare and seasoned wonderfully. I had the chicken picatta and liked it alot. The chicken was tender and the pasta had a nice al dente texture.
… more
Heather Hillyard
Food was amazing!! This was the best chicken marsala I have ever had, and I’ve tried it at all the restaurants. My daughter had chicken French which was delicious. I cat wait to go back.
… more
… View more