Based on 126 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
265 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
Phone: (516) 588-6240
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–4 PM, 5–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–4 PM, 5–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–4 PM, 5–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–4 PM, 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–4 PM, 5–10 PM |
| Sunday | 3:30–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–4 PM, 5–10 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Thomas Chopard
This was my first visit. I can’t say enough on how good this place is. Drinks, Apps and Main courses were all above and beyond expectations. Make a reservation and get here early. We had clams on the half shell, crab cake, black sea bass and the stuffed lobster. I was so excited I forgot take the pictures before I started. It was that good.
… more
Patricia M
Drove to Bayville in Oyster Bay, Nassau County to visit Schultzy’s Seafood Restaurant for dinner 3months agp.
… more
K B
Such a cute little place with FANTASTIC food!! The halibut was delicious I would 100% order that again. The lobster bisque is a must have!! The seafood was fresh and the portions were perfectly sized. The staff was so accommodating and kind to us from the second we walked in!! Would give it a million stars if I could!!
… more
Rob Lawrence
The seared tuna special at Schultzy’s was incredible! The freshest and most perfect tuna I have had in the USA. My family and I lived in Japan for several years and had exceptional tuna of this quality fairly regularly. In the states not so much. The owners of Schultzy’s are very “hands-on” and it is evident in the spectacular oysters, shrimp, raw little necks, lobster and super delicious backed stuffed clams. This is not your typical suburban seafood place – it is world class. We went twice this week and will be back in a few days!
… more
zina korn
Had the most wonderful luncheon with 8 friends. We were given an oyster/clam shucking lesson, then enjoyed them
… more
Ryan Pollice
Amazing food…apps, dinner and dessert!
… more
Matthew Carrara
We waited an hour for our food. The lobster was over cooked, the food was for the most part underwhelming. The crispy rice tuna cakes were good, the lobster bisque was probably the most boring by far. We got up to leave and the food came out as we were standing up, of course, I wish we kept walking.
… more
Mark Dimont
Cozy and friendly spot in Bayville. Small menu curated well with some great seafood selections. We had oysters, the shrimp Po boy, and the clam chowder and all were superb. Service was informative and professional and just plain pleasant. Look forward to returning.
… more
LaurenNorris_NY_RealEstate
What an absolute gem!! Not only was the food incredibly delicious, the service was tops! The owner came to introduce himself to us & couldn’t have been more gracious! This spot should definitely be on your list if you are in the Bayville area or if u not it is certainly worth the trip!
… more
Philip Grillo
Came here during the winter and it was closed on a dreary Monday, ran into the owner…he told me “you’re going to really love the food here.” Took about 6 months to get here, and he was 100% correct!!! I wish I could give 10 stars!!! Amazing!
… more
… View more