Tony + Benny’s Menu – Central Valley, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Central Valley, NY

This new restaurant concept is based on our very own owners: Anthony & Biagio Scotto, who came over from Italy with family to Brooklyn to start a business. This upscale Brooklyn themed pizzeria features quality ingredients like 100% whole milk mozzarella, fresh sauce and homemade dough that we use to prepare everyone’s favorites!

Based on 67 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.1 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Tony + Benny's 10917

Address:
498 Red Apple Ct Ste FC10, Central Valley, NY 10917

Phone: (845) 928-3162

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 10 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–9 PM
Thursday 10 AM–9 PM
Friday 10 AM–9 PM
Saturday 10 AM–9 PM
Sunday 10 AM–9 PM
Monday 10 AM–9 PM

Menu

PIZZA
NEO – CHEESE
NEO – ONE TOPPING PLUS
NEO DELUXE
PAN PIZZA – CHEESE
PAN PIZZA – TWO TOPPING PLUS (One Topping Plus As Well)
STUFFED PIZZA
Xtra Cheese
Flatbread
Twice As Nice
STROMBOLI’S/Calzones
All Flavors
HOT SANDWICHES
PASTA & ITALIAN SPECIALTIES
Spaghetti
Spaghetti And Protein (Meat)
Pasta – Baked Ziti/Mac & Cheese
Baked Ziti/Mac & Cheese And Protien
MEAT LASAGNA
SIDE ORDERS
MEATBALLS
GARLIC STICK
SIDE ORDERS -Pasta/No Protein
SIDE ORDERS -Meat
CHICKEN WINGS Each At Least 3
Side Chicken Strips 3 On Side Salad
SALADS
SIDE SALADS (NON PROTEIN)
SIDE SALADS (PROTEIN/MEAT)
DINNER SALADS –( NO PROTEIN)
DINNER SALADS –(PROTEIN/MEAT)
DESSERTS
COOKIES
Chips
BEVERAGES
MED
LG
COFFEE
BOTTLED WATER
JUICE’S
BOTTLED TEAS / PUNCH/Soda
ICED TEA MED
ICED TEA LG
Monin Beverages Reg
Monin Beverages Large
Upcharge Large FTn On Value Meal
Upcharge To Monin Reg On Value Meal
Upcharge To Monin LG On Value Meal
Upcharge To Bottled Soda
Upcharge To Bottled Tea
Upcharge To Water
Upcharge To Coffee
Upcharge To Juice
Charge To Milk
Value meals
Stromboli
NEO SLICE
Pan
Create Your Own Meal
Whole Pie Deal

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Steve Le
Clearly overpriced! Bad customer service! Order Mozzarella stick- got charged for Wings! $28 for 12 pieces!

… more

Quadrae Smith
I will never ever eat from there again . Prices ridiculous $35 for chicken parm with noddles and a drink oh and mozzarella sticks that were cold . Customer service is bad as well. Very unacceptable know I wonder why I was the only person online.

… more

Deon Lim
Had the meat lovers pizza, quality is great and heated up before serving.

… more

PHAROS TOURS
Small salad for Big price$5:19

… more

Mariana Pinos
The pizza is pretty solid. A good meal after a long day of shopping. I had the bbq chicken pizza and it was delicious. The garlic knots were average but a good carb filler

… more

benjamin marrero
Way overpriced I ordered 3 mozzarella sticks and they charged it as 3 wings for $16.95 Told the cashier she said that is the correct price !

… more

Jorge Gonzalez
Eh, what can i say? “AUTHENTIC BROOKLYN PIZZA ” WHERE? THERE’S NOTHING AUTHENTIC, PIZZA IS EH FOR 5 REGULAR SLICE AND ALMOST 7 FOR TOPPINGS, WISHBIBCAN GIVE IT A 0 . BUT IT IS WHAT IT IS.

… more

ra rado
Worst pizza and spaghetti I ever eat. It is not even 1 star rating it is 0. Food not taste at all like it should be. And over priced! Never eat there again. Not recommended at all!

… more

Nicholas Burt
They say that even when pizza is bad, it’s still pretty good. They are lying and this place is the proof.

… more

Randal Paster
I ordered the chicken parmigiana sandwich, $8.00. Severely over-priced for the serving size. The ingredients, I would say, were better than average. The chicken was somewhat undercooked but I was starving and chose not to return it. The counter service was despicable.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions