Based on 355 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
227 Broad St Apartment 2, Waverly, NY 14892
Phone: (607) 565-2111
Website: https://m.facebook.com/CoachesPizza/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Amy Dixon
What a great little place we happened to stop into! Amazing pizza, a few of us in the party thought it was the best we ever had!! Good service and clean place. Highly recommend if you’re hungry and in town!! I want to go back again for more before we leave!!!!!
… more
Jackie Vajda
We just love Coaches Pizza! In fact sometimes we even get a sheet pizza and freeze it for quick kid lunches. In fact it’s the only pizza in the area that my kids love! Their speedie salad is my favorite and my husband loves their honey bbq wings!
… more
Micah Page (Metulburr)
This is my favorite wing and sheet pizza place. The wings are large size and great every single time. The pizza is not too saucy and had a great flavor. I would prefer to drive down from Elmira and get this as opposed to nearby Pudgies, dominoes, Pizza Hut, etc.
… more
J L
Ordered pizza and garlic knots to go. Staff was friendly, wait wasn’t long, prices were on the high end but ok. Tried the garlic knots first and they were glutinous goodness, tasty, and soft. Dipping sauce tasted like a simple jarred sauce. Pizza was ok, a little greasy and was obviously a prepared crust. Low stars are due to the appearance and price of a fresh made pizza joint that is putting out cookie cutter pies like Papa John’s. Ok for a road trip, not a great place for quality pizza.
… more
Travis Foster
Wish they would leave it in the oven another minute but it’s in my top 2 pizza places in the valley. Would be nice if they had peppers and parm cheese to go!
… more
Chris Huffman
Amazing service and the best chicken wing pizza ive ever had and my fianceé agrees
… more
Becca McNamara
Went in for a quick slice of pizza. There were 4 different kinds to choose from, they all looked pretty good. Not fresh but not icky looking. Staff was kind from what I noticed. It was nice that I got asked if I wanted any ranch or BC on the side with my slice. My slice was pretty yummy (honey bbq chicken).
… more
Chef Paris
Friendly staff, Tasty slices. Definitely the best pizza Waverly has to offer! I’ll definitely be stoppin in more often, highly recommend their Honey BBQ Chicken Pie!
… more
Amy Grover
Time ⏲️ we got are pizza it was cold and it didn’t taste good and it took forever to get it
… more
Richard Schafer
Ordered Lg pie well done. Turned out well done on top. Bottom was just done. I don’t understand this 12 slices deal with places up here. I’m from Long Island. Land of 8 slice pizza. Also had 6 wings mild which were cooked good. Blue cheese was cheap and thin. Sorry Coach not returning. Wont deliver past 10 miles. No even with the offer of more money.
… more
… View more