Based on 439 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3984 Broadway, Grove City, OH 43123
Phone: (614) 875-2345
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gobot’s On the trail.
This is my second time back here placing a takeout order coming in on late Friday evening the store was chaotic busy. When picking up our order all of our order was ready but one item wasn’t done cashier was very confused and gave her my number she’s like our u sure you ordered here!! Yes we did I repeat my number many times couldn’t find my order gave her my name found it….. Meatball sub was a very big huge disappointment and let down it must have been sitting for awhile and by time we got home it was soggy I would not recommend getting it. Now the pizza was the best but the garlic bread we got was way overpowering tasting! Oreo cheesecake we got was very bland not appealing at all waste of money overall I definitely do recommend there pizza and there sauce
… more
Carielle Rankin
Tammy’s is consistently one of the best places to get pizza. They never disappoint! The inside seating area is a little small, but during warm months, there is plenty of outdoor seating as well.
… more
DarcyDoodle (DarcyDoodle)
It was really difficult ordering online so I had to call in my order Food is okay if you stick to basic, but they cant seem to get it 100% if you add or subtract items. This sub (pictured) with extra lettuce was actually the opposite with almost no lettuce or Italian deessing
… more
Fred Rohdes
Small dining area, but really great pizza, and salad. Our pizza had thin crust and was LOADED with pepperoni. Two thumbs way up. The salad was iced cold crisp. Perfect.
… more
Jacob Golick
Well, this is going to be a long one. I don’t write many bad reviews, so when I do I try my best to explain. Of the two pizza joints on broadway I heard this one was better, but that isn’t saying much. Pretty sure the pizza sauce is the base pizza sauce you can buy at GFS in the #10 cans. No added seasonings or anything. It’s a very sweet kind of like a tomato paste type “sauce”. We got the garlicy cheese pizza, breadsticks, and the works pizza(no green pepper). The sausage tasted like breakfast sausage. Maybe they need to meet up with the guys who make the Italian sausage at the Columbus Italian fest(that was really good). The pepperoni was good, it wasn’t the spicy kind, so kid friendly. The mushrooms on the pizza were canned I’m about 95% sure. The crust was all soft so it didn’t hold the toppings. The best thing we had were the garlic breadsticks. I really feel bad for Grove City not knowing what good pizza tastes like, you guys are truly missing out. Best thing I can say is try Little Italy in Groveport. They are about the closest thing to being as good a pizza as you can find in Chicago. I will say the service was really good. Friendly people and they seemed to be working hard. I noticed they made a few mistakes (it was super busy from the parade) with some customers, but they were quick to take care of the customer! Thanks and good luck!
… more
A Mccormick
Service:
… more
Lisa Rae
The young lady who waited on us was very helpful and down to earth. Nice atmosphere. They have tables outside. Would have eaten out there but too hot for us. The only thing I wish they had more of was options for crust. They only serve thin crust. My 2 daughters got 7′ pizza one with bacon other with pepperoni and I got sausage. All three were tasty.
… more
Nikki MomToOne
Long wait on the sub and each of us ate alone. My gluten free sub was amazing.
… more
Amber Dishman
Their pizza is delicious and you get a huge pizza for 18.00 that feeds my family of 4 with left overs and we can all eat!! The crust is thin but you still get some of that nice soft dough in the middle and a perfectly crisped bottom crust. Cheese is really flavor as is the pepperoni and their sausage is a MUST, and the sauce isn’t too sweet or too tart, its just right. Ask for extra cheese..you’re welcome . One of my family’s favorites!!
… more
Sue Mccann
Best pizza in Grove City, we have it 1-2 times a week! We love the original sausage they use and they don’t skimp on it either.
… more
… View more