Trotter’s creates a dining experience and atmosphere unlike any other. You’ll be surrounded by friendly staff, making you feel like you’re in your very own Winner’s Circle. Enjoy fresh seafood and steaks among countless mouthwatering dishes. Trotter’s Steak and Seafood House also offers numerous beverages inspired by the races themselves. Sit next to our handcrafted, solid oak bar and enjoy a classic Mint Julep, the rum for the roses, or a chilled glass of Rose inspired by the garland of roses. We genuinely believe that it’s the smallest gestures that make the largest difference, and we want everyone to leave with new wonderful memories each and every time.
Based on 249 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1830 Oakland Ave, Indiana, PA 15701
Phone: (724) 471-2052
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Marie Montgomery
This place was a wonderful find. The place was beautiful. Sara was wonderful she was pleasant and a pleasure to talk to. Eric, the executive chef, came to our table to ask how the food was, and let me tell you, it was wonderful. Even a day later, I was still thinking about the taste of that steak. If you are not a local there, you may not know about it, but trust me, look them up. If you are in Indiana, you won’t be disappointed. My husband and I will return when we are back in the area
… more
Rennita L. Jardine- Brant
My husband and I found this wonderful gem of a place after getting our daughter settled into college. When I say absolutely amazing I mean it. From the greeting we received at the door from the owner to the conversations with him and other staff we felt at home away from home. The food was delicious appetizers to main course. Trotter’s is a MUST if your in Indiana,Pa and love great food and a welcoming atmosphere! : Crab cakes, Calamari- Lobster tails, Steak, Garlic Mashed Potatoes and fried zucchini.
… more
Lorenzo Schiavo
Fantastic family dinner here. I had the Salmon and it was perfectly cooked, slightly charred to perfection and a nice balance of seasoning and citrus. The wife had chicken Marsala, daughter had filet. Everyone enjoyed their meal immensely. Neil gave me a tour of the restaurant as well. Can’t wait to see this restaurant expand in all its glory.
… more
Jan Venturini
A rare find. I have not one complaint. This restaurant was exceptional! From the first step in door, the waitress was efficient and bubbly. We were on a quest for oysters and ate a dozen of the very fresh raw ones and 2 dozen oyster Rockefeller that melted in your mouth. Scallops were made to perfection. We ended the meal with the turtle creamy cheese cake. The executive chef took time to speak to us. He has a very doable business plan and I wish him all the best for the restaurants success. I will return.
… more
John Fordyce
Trotter’s was very good. A few of my friends have had some mixed reviews over the last few months but that’s when they were very new and just getting rolling. They did everything right tonight. All the meals were very good, the service was very good the apps ( fried oysters and oysters rock) were great. I think the value is fair for Indiana PA.. it’s probably on the higher spectrum of what we have here but that’s what to be expected from a non-chain – owner operated restaurant.
… more
JasonAmy Neidig
We stopped in here on our way home right after our daughter, Abby, placed 2nd at Keystone State Wrestling Championships. We were exhausted after a long weekend at the Arena, and were made to feel right at home by the owner and staff. They congratulated Abby and asked to take a picture with her, which made her feel special:) The food and service were excellent. Would definitely recommend stopping here if you’re in the area! Thank you again, Trotter’s, for an amazing dining experience:)
… more
Victoria Snellings
Husband and I just left. It was our first visit and we will be coming back! I got the surf and turf special. 100 out of 10 stars. Everything was cooked to perfection. The thing that blew me away the most was how incredible the lobster was, sweet, cooked to perfection, buttery and melted in my mouth, not chewy or rubbery at all. They also make a damn good dirty Martini. Definitely check this place out you will not be disappoint! Server’s and chef were super nice and professional. I can’t say enough good things about this place. This is the perfect place for date night, anniversaries, or just because the food and atmosphere is amazing.
… more
Gina Zakharin
Food was decent, not the BEST, but good. Have had some stuff from eat’npark taste better. The Waitress was rude…both times. Two different waitresses. Amazing atmosphere though aside from that!! Nice place to go maybe once a year for a special occasion to feel pampered. The snobby waitresses go along with the rich feel of the environment at least LOL
… more
Jennifer Pittore
My food was done perfect. Server was very knowledgeable about the menu and was very attentive. Nice wine offerings, plus a full bar. I had the scallops. Owner was present and made our group feel welcomed. Need to go back when weather is better to experience their rooftop bar.
… more
dan doyle
Decided to try Trotters breakfast buffet… what a disaster of an experience. The bacon was not cooked anywhere’s close to what pork is supposed to be cooked to. The fat was still white as if the put it on the grill then pulled right off.. I mentioned to a waitress the bacon was raw. All the items on the hot table was cold. Took a plate of food to table and all was cold. Went back for a next round and no bacon at all… told a lady I thought was the owner that there was no bacon.. they then brought out like 20 strips total of burnt bacon… see attached photo of both the uncooked and burnt bacon. Standing line and waitresses bumping into everyone as the location of the buffet is very cramped. The line of people had to move for anyone needing to use the restroom or the wait staff coming from the kitchen area…people were walking out complaining about there experience before even getting food.. Very very disappointing…My recommendation to the owners is shut down the buffet before it destroys your dinner reputation as well.
… more
… View more