Hometown Heroes Menu – West Islip, NY

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : West Islip, NY

Based on 287 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Hometown Heroes 11795

Address:
240 Higbie Ln, West Islip, NY 11795

Phone: (631) 482-1714

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 10 AM–7 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–7 PM
Thursday 10 AM–7 PM
Friday 10 AM–8 PM
Saturday 10 AM–7 PM
Sunday 10 AM–6 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

Appetizers
French Fries $5.49
Cheese Fries $8.49
Tater Tots
Loaded – Cheese sauce on top with bacon bits and chives		 $5.49
Waffle Fries
Seasoned waffle fries served with our homemade loaded sour cream dip

Loaded is – Cheese sauce, bacon, and chives

 $9.99
Mozzarella Sticks
7 Mozzarella sticks Served with marinara sauce		 $9.99
Chicken Tenders
Served with honey mustard dressing		 $12.99
Fried Mac & Cheese Bites
4 Homemade Fried Macaroni & Cheese Logs served with spicy ketchup		 $10.99
Macaroni And Cheese
Homemade macaroni and cheese		 $5.49
Buffalo Tenders
Tenders tossed in hot sauce and served with a side of blue cheese dressing		 $12.99
Cold Heroes
Italian With The Works
Salami, Pepperoni, Ham Cappy, Pepper Ham and provolone with the works (lettuce, tomato, onion, salt pepper, oregano, oil & vinegar		 $9.99
American With The Works
Ovengold Turkey, Deluxe Ham, Homemade Roast Beef and American Cheese with the *works
*lettuce, tomato, onion, salt, pepper, oregano, oil & vinegar		 $9.99
Tuna Salad Hero
Homemade tuna salad on a full or half hero.		 $8.99
Bella
Ovengold Turkey, lettuce, cucumbers & red onion with our loaded sour cream dip		 $10.99
Field 5
Ham, American Cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo		 $9.99
Good Sam
Thinly sliced turkey and ham topped with lettuce, tomato and mayo.		 $8.99
The Lion
Turkey, Bacon, Swiss, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo		 $9.99
Chicken Salad Hero
Homemade chicken salad on a full or half hero.		 $9.99
Chicken Cutlet Heroes
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken cutlet with buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing and melted mozzarella.		 $9.99
Chicken Cutlet Supreme
Chicken Cutlet, grilled ham with melted mozzarella cheese and coleslaw.		 $9.99
Chicken Parm
Chicken cutlet with melted mozzarella and our homemade marinara sauce.		 $9.99
Fursh
Chicken cutlet with melted cheddar with lettuce, tomato and mayo.		 $9.99
Heavy Hitter
Chicken Cutlet, macaroni and cheese, coleslaw and gravy		 $10.99
Instagram Mac Attack
This is the popular photo we put on instagram.
It’s a Mac Attack (Chicken cutlet, macaroni and cheese, and bacon) with Mozzarella, ranch, and hot sauce		 $10.99
Mac Attack
Chicken Cutlet, macaroni and topped with bacon		 $9.99
Mohawk
Chicken cutlet, pepper jack cheese, bacon and smokey BBQ sauce.		 $9.99
The Brando
Our Italian Hero* with melted Provolone, Chicken cutlet, with the works.
(works – lettuce, tomato, onion, salt, pepper, oregano & oil and vinegar)

*Italian Hero- Salami, pepperoni, ham cappy and pepper ham

 $10.99
The Goomba
Chicken Cutlet, mozzarella sticks, & marinara on Garlic Bread
(full hero only)		 $14.99
The Spicy Stark
If you like it HOT!!
Chicken Cutlet, Pepper Jack Cheese, Hot Sauce, Macaroni & Cheese topped with jalapeños.		 $10.99
Nor’easter
Chicken cutlet on a bed of melted mozzarella with crisp bacon smothered in sweet BBQ sauce.		 $9.99
Ranchero
Chicken cutlet, Swiss, lettuce, tomato and ranch.		 $9.99
Stallion
Chicken Cutlet tossed in Italian dressing, with red onion, avocado, lettuce & mayo		 $10.99
The Captain
Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, French Fires, melted Cheddar and homemade Russian dressing		 $15.99
Hot Heroes
Reuben Hero
Grilled corned beef and sauerkraut with melted Swiss and Russian dressing.		 $10.99
Maneater Hero
Hot roast beef, crisp bacon and melted mozzarella cheese topped with gravy and ranch dressing.		 $9.99
Superclub Hero
Roast beef, ham & turkey with crisp bacon and melted American cheese.		 $9.99
Manhattan Hero
Roast beef with melted mozzarella on garlic bread with your choice of sauce.		 $9.99
Turkey Manhattan Hero
Hot Turkey with melted mozzarella on garlic bread with your choice of sauce.		 $9.99
Philly Hero
Roast beef, sauteed onions and peppers with melted American.		 $9.99
Classic Hot Pastrami Hero
Grilled pastrami with melted Swiss and mustard.		 $10.99
Curveball Hero
Pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, homemade Russian and coleslaw.		 $10.99
Toast Of Broadway Hero
Hot roast beef, melted cheddar, sauteed onions, lettuce, tomato, smokey BBQ sauce and mayo.		 $9.99
Hashtag Hero
Ovengold Turkey, melted pepper jack cheese, jalapeños and homemade Russian dressing.		 $9.99
Italian Philly Hero
Roast beef, sauteed onions and peppers, melted mozzarella and marinara sauce on garlic bread.		 $9.99
Meatball Parm Hero
Our homemade meatballs and marinara sauce with melted mozzarella.		 $9.99
Grilled Chicken Heroes
Papa Georgio
Grilled chicken with melted mozzarella, roasted red peppers and balsamic vinaigrette.		 $9.99
Mama Georgio
Grilled chicken with melted mozzarella, roasted red peppers and pesto mayo.		 $9.99
Vincenzo
Grilled chicken, crisp bacon, melted American cheese, tomato and ranch dressing.		 $9.99
Spicy Chicken
Grilled chicken, melted pepper jack cheese, jalapeños and smokey BBQ sauce.		 $9.99
Alamo
Grilled chicken, melted cheddar cheese, bacon and spicy mayo.		 $9.99
Lighthouse
Grilled chicken, melted Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard.		 $9.99
Chicken Philly
Grilled chicken with melted mozzarella, sauteed onions & green peppers.		 $9.99
Wraps
Greek Wrap
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion, feta cheese and Greek dressing.		 $9.99
Texas Ranch Wrap
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, hot sauce and ranch dressing.		 $9.99
Islander Wrap
Grilled chicken with homemade russian dressing, pickles, onions and lettuce.		 $9.99
Chick N Berry Wrap
Grilled chicken, cranberries, walnuts, Gorgonzola crumbles, lettuce, and lite raspberry vinaigrette.		 $9.99
JJay Wrap
Hot Roast Beef, Bacon, macaroni & cheese and spicy mayo		 $10.99
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing.		 $9.99
California Club
Everroast Chicken, Bacon, Avocado, Lettuce, Tomato & Ranch Dressing.		 $10.49
Honeycomb Wrap
Honey Maple Turkey, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, pickles and honey mustard		 $9.99
Stratford Wrap
Roast beef, Swiss, lettuce, tomato and onion with Dijon horseradish sauce.		 $9.99
Turkey Club Wrap
Oven gold turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon and mayo.		 $9.99
Veggie Wrap
Roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion, carrots, cucumber, salt, pepper, oregano, oil and vinegar.		 $8.99
Wellington Wrap
Oven Gold turkey, pepper jack cheese, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar.		 $9.99
Create Your Own
Create Your Own $9.25
Salads
American Chef Salad
Romaine lettuce, tightly rolled up and chopped ham, turkey and roast beef with American cheese, red onion and your choice of dressing. (served on the side)		 $14.99
Apple Walnut Salad
Romaine lettuce, apple, walnuts and dried cranberry with crumbled Gorgonzola cheese (Dressing served on the side)		 $14.99
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, shaved Parmesan and Caesar dressing.
(Dressing served on the side)		 $12.99
Cobb Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, hard-boiled egg, black olive and bits of bacon with shredded cheddar cheese and your choice of dressing.		 $14.99
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion, Kalamata olives, & feta cheese. Served with Greek dressing. (Dressing served on the side)		 $14.99
House Garden Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, shredded carrots and red onion with your choice of dressing.
(Dressing served on the side)		 $9.99
Italian Chef Salad
Romaine lettuce, chopped Boar’s Head – salami, pepperoni, ham cappy, pepper ham and provolone with tomato, red onion, salt, pepper, oregano and your choice of dressing. (Dressing served on the side)		 $14.99
Southwest Avocado Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomato, black beans, corn and avocado with shredded cheddar cheese and Southwest ranch dressing.
(Dressing served on the side)		 $14.99
Macaroni & Cheese items
Fried Macaroni & Cheese Bites
Served with spicy ketchup		 $9.99
Sliced Full Boar’s Head Pickle
Sliced Full Boar’s Head Pickle
Full Boar’s Head Pickle cut into 4’s		 $3.99
Side Salads -Pot, Mac, & Slaw
Potato Salad $1.99
Homemade Coleslaw $1.99
Tuna Salad
Small approx 1/4 lb
Medium approx 1/2 lb
Large approx 1 lb		 $3.99
Classic Chicken Salad
Small approx 1/4 lb
Medium approx 1/2 lb
Large approx 1 lb		 $3.99
Homemade Macaroni Salad $1.99
Chips
Deep River Chips – Zesty Jalapeño $2.69
Deep River Chips – Sea Salt $2.69
Deep River Chips – BBQ $2.69
Lay’s $2.69
Doritos $2.69
Fritos $2.69
Small Bag Of Funyons $2.69
Deep River Salt & Vinegar $2.69
Deep River Sweet Maui Onion $2.49
Deep River Salt & Cracked Pepper $2.69
Sun Chips – Harvest Cheddar $2.69
Deep River Rosemary & Olive Oil $2.69
Deep River Sour Cream Onion
Krinkle Cut		 $2.49
Flaming Hot Cheetos $2.69
Beverages
Pure Leaf Tea $3.25
20 Oz. Soda/Water Products $2.99
2 Liter Soda $4.99
Snapple $3.25
Fountain Drinks $2.25
Peace Tea $3.25
Extra Dressing OTS
Brown Gravy OTS $1.00
Marinara OTS $1.00
Mayo OTS $1.00
Mustard OTS $1.00
Hot Sauce OTS $1.00
Honey Mustard OTS $1.00
Sweet BBQ OTS $1.00
Smokey BBQ OTS $1.00
Dijon Horseradish OTS $1.00
Pesto Mayo OTS $1.00
Spicy Mayo OTS $1.00
Ketchup OTS $1.00
Ranch Dressing OTS $1.00
Russian Dressing OTS $1.00
Lite Raspberry Vinaigrette OTS $1.00
Balsamic Vinaigrette OTS $1.00
Southwest Ranch Dressing OTS $1.00
Dessert
Tates – 7oz $6.99
Catering
8 Wrap Platter
8 Assorted Wraps cut in 1/2 placed on a platter. Mayo and mustard served on the side.

2 x Turkey & Cheese with lettuce and tomato
2 x Ham & Cheese with lettuce and tomato
2 x Roast Beef & Cheese with lettuce and tomato
1 x American with Lettuce and tomato
1 x Italian with Lettuce and Tomato

 $79.92
4 Hero Platter – American & Italian
4 Heroes cut into 4’s – Total 16 slices. Served with mayo, mustard and oil and vinegar on the side

2 x Italians with lettuce & Tomato
2 x Americans with lettuce & Tomato

 $59.96
4 Assorted Hero Platter
4 Assorted Heroes cut into 4’s placed onto a platter – 16 slices served with mayo and mustard on the side

1 x Turkey & Cheese with lettuce and tomato
1 x Ham & Cheese with lettuce and tomato
1 x Roast Beef & Cheese with lettuce and tomato
1 x Honey Maple Turkey & Cheese with lettuce and tomato

 $59.96

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Brian Carter
We used Hometown Heroes catering for my daughter’s first birthday party and they were amazing! We ordered chicken fingers and French fries for the kids, salads, and the chicken cutlet hero with mozzarella and roasted red peppers. When I arrived five minutes early, they had the order ready to go and the staff helped me load everything into my car. Everyone loved the food and we’ll be sure to use them again for events in the future!

… more

Nick Lo
Soo happy i was given a blue cheese hero today with 2 pieces of chicken. Place is going down hill.

… more

Bridey Launonen
great heroes & good portion sizes. we go all the time and definitely will be back. favorite thing is the loaded waffle fries

… more

colin kogan
Ordered a 6 foot Italian hero because I was too lazy to grill at my bbq. The family loved the sandwich and everybody got to take home left overs. It was still tasty the next day after I re-toasted the bread . I will def be returning .

… more

David Schlagheck
Go Here!! Try It!! Thats the best suggestion!

… more

Tamara Bonet
My husband and i found this shop on Instagram (we’re foodies). We both love trying different places, but this was on another level. We drove almost 2 hours and it was totally worth it. I had the Mac Attack, which is basically chicken cutlet w/ macaroni and cheese on a hero. I had to bring it home because i couldn’t finish it. My husband had their new sandwich (Jay Jay). It was fresh, filling, and delicious. Definitely recommend!!

… more

Jackie V
The subs are HUGE and delicious! Toasted bread on hot heroes adds nice crunch. Very flavorful. Offer pickup and delivery. Very friendly staff and clean facility.

… more

Mike Roden
Hometown catered our party and had the best price around. The heroes were delicious & salads. The place is new looking & immaculately clean, which is not common for delis.

… more

Wade Wilson
Takeout order – no napkins in the bag or etc. Counter help was standard, do their job accurately and the food was prepared in a timely fashion. The Philly (Cheese steak) had fresh ingredients and tasted fine – but, there’s better and not just in Philadelphia. The Manhattan (Roast Beef) was where the these Heroes hit a home run!! The gravy and sandwich flavors hit the sweet spot! I would certainly try them again!

… more

Tom S
Great spot for awesome heros. Stopped in for a little lunch on the go. The staff was super friendly, showed me the regulars and specials and answered the questions I had.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch