Unregular Pizza serves 72h leavened Roman pizzas in a unique fashion. In this pizza shop, you will never ever find the so-called “regular slice”. Even the simplest margherita presents three final toppings that add a flavorful, yet a somehow classic and intense taste: pecorino romano DOP, parmigiano reggiano and homemade garlic infused EVOO. The mouth-watering menu offers a variety of Burrapizzas which feature a whole burrata on one squared slice, here are some examples. The menu includes a variety of lasagnas (one made with Bronte imported pistachios), Sicilian eggplant rollatini (a revisitation of Sicilian staple eggplant parmigiana) and meatballs made with a special guanciale sauce.
The beverage choices are narrowed down to fresh juices.
Cheerful, neon-lit venue offering specialty pizzas & a variety of sandwiches, with vegan options. Based on 833 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
135 4th Ave, New York, NY 10003
Phone: (646) 609-4699
Website:
Social Profile: ![]()
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joe
I think the pizza would be better if it was made to order, like a fresh one of the oven. But the slice doesn’t reheat well. The bottom is super crispy but the top is just room temperature. The flavors are pretty good but it feels like eating leftover pizza.
… more
cristina marin
Great pizza! I really enjoyed it! It’s probably one of the pizza places in Manhattan I’d most recommend! The place is very small, with a small bar were you can it! The variety of pizza and the (square) Roman style pizza makes the place unique! Prices varies from $5-11$ per slice! The burrata pizza is double in price compared to the others, but so yummy and worth it! The truffle mushroom burrapiza and Caccio e Pepe fried pasta were my favorite! Highly recommended!
… more
C B (Chris)
Awesome and delectable! The employees are very friendly. For those looking for gluten free pizza, they have their own crust and can add whichever toppings you like. A must try for everyone. Looking forward to my next visit (tomorrow).
… more
M B
Overall, decent spot. The pizza looks beautiful and the staff has such a positive attitude. I wasnt wowed in the flavor department. I had the White slice which came off as a bit dry due to a lack of enough Ricotta cheese. The truffle oil mushroom sauce was good, but had a bit too much garlic to allow the other flavors to pop.
… more
Marissa Contento
Came for a quick dinner. Got a free drink with a few slices I got with a friend which was nice. I recommend my favorite of the slices, the burrata truffle mushrooms slice!
… more
Andrew Falzon
Great pizza. An unexpected gem near Union Square.
… more
Dustin Fox
The place looks really cool inside, I love the vibe. However, the pizza tasted like a dollar slice for way too much money. I do not recommend the truffle slice as it’s incredibly oily. I also got the deep fried Cacio e pepe which had good flavor, but was still cold inside when served. Really wanted this place to be good, but it did not match the hype or price tag.
… more
Joel Roberts
The presentation of the pizza was stunning – Perfect for social media influencers. However, the flavors were pretty one note. I was hoping the flavors would be outstanding, but in all honesty, I’ve had more enjoyable slices at $2 slice stores. The pizza and fried pasta was fine, but it wasn’t amazing, as I really hoped it would be after hearing all of the hype. For the price, I was disappointed. Maybe it was an off day? Overall, prettier than it was tasty.
… more
diegobatt
Unexpected must in new York city if you like pizza. Fast service, good prices for the quality, yo can get full with two slices. We went for the fried lasagna, and although it was good, I would have prefer another slice of pizza. We spent 13 dollar each and ended up very full
… more
Carolina Chatila
Insanely delicious flavorful pizza slices!! I got both slices with pesto (one chicken one burrata) they were insanely good, also got a side of marinara sauce that I didn’t need to use cuz the slices were so yum also the place is super cute, will be back for sure to try more slices
… more
… View more
