Pagano’s Restaurant Menu – New Stanton, PA

Type : Restaurant

Location : New Stanton, PA

Enjoy Old World Italian and American Classics
Pagano’s Restaurant in New Stanton PA brings the finest Italian dishes to your table or event. Our tradition of serving the finest Italian food began in 1955 when we served our first customer on Otterman Street in Greensburg. Since then our passion has been to serve you delicious Italian and American cuisine, and of course provide the highest level of service.

Casual Italian-American eatery dishing a familiar menu of red-sauce eats, pasta classics & pizza. Based on 333 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Pagano's Restaurant 15672

Address:
108 E Byers Ave, New Stanton, PA 15672

Phone: (724) 925-2064

Website: http://www.paganoitalian.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday 8 AM–1:30 AM
Thursday 8 AM–1:30 AM
Friday 8 AM–1:30 AM
Saturday 4 PM–1:30 AM
Sunday Closed
Monday 9 AM–1:30 AM
Tuesday 8 AM–1:30 AM

Menu

House Appetizers
Sausage Stuffed Banana Peppers $6.25
Chicken Fingers $5.95
Bread Sticks $2.50
Bread Sticks (Basket Of 4) $2.95
Calamari Rings $5.75
Breaded Provolone $3.95
Monterey Jack Sticks $4.50
Stuffed Mushrooms $5.75
Hand Breaded Zucchini $4.50
Tempura Mushrooms $3.50
Garlic Toast (3 Slices) $2.95
Pizza Bread Sticks $3.50
Pagano’s Wings $3.75
Specialty Salads
Chef Salad $7.75
Steak Salad $8.75
House Salad $3.75
Sicilian Salad
House dressing only		 $4.95
Char-Grilled Chicken Salad $8.50
Turkey Salad $8.75
Entrees From the Sea
House Breaded Cod Fillet
1/2, baked or fried		 $13.25
Baked Stuffed Flounder $15.50
Shrimp Scampi $17.95
Entrees from the Land
Stuffed Chicken Breast $14.50
Char-Grilled Pork Chops $13.50
Char-Grilled New York Strip Steak $15.50
Baby Beef Liver & Onions $10.95
Stuffed Pork Chop $14.95
Chicken Breast-Char-Grilled $10.75
Chicken Breast-Barbecued $10.95
Veal Milanese
Breaded cutlet, served with a lemon wedge		 $17.25
Sirloin Steak (6 Oz.)
Contified angus beef		 $14.50
Cowboy Steak (16 Oz.)
Contified angus beef		 $21.95
Lunch Menu and More
Burgers
1/2 pounds (pre-cooked weight) of beef on an italian roll		 $4.50
Our Original Hamburger
1/3 pound (pre-cooked weight) of beef on a soft roll		 $3.50
Meatball Sub
5 meatballs in our homemade tomato sauce		 $6.50
Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onion Sub
Hot sausage, sweet peppers, onions in tomato sauce		 $6.75
Turkey Sub
In house roasted turkey breast with lettuce & tomato		 $6.95
Chicken Finger Sub $6.95
Breaded Cod Tail
Our original fish sandwich		 $4.50
The Whaler Sub $7.25
Char-Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Chicken fillet prepared to your taste		 $4.50
Italian Sub
Mortadella, capicolla, salami, lettuce, tomato and a special sicilian condiment		 $5.95
Combination Sandwich
Ham, egg, turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo		 $5.25
Chicken Parm Sub
A sandwich version of the favorite dinner entree		 $7.75
Pit Beef Sub
Our house specialty		 $6.75
Steak Sub
Seasoned julian strips of certified angus beef		 $6.75
Parmigiana Delights
Eggplant $10.75
Chicken Breast Fillets $13.95
Veal Cutlet $15.75
Zucchini $10.50
For Your Pasta
Sauteed Mushroom $2.25
Meatballs (2) $2.25
Char Grilled Chicken Fillet $3.50
Fried Zucchini $3.95
Italian Hot Sausage $4.25
Homemade Pizza
Our Original
Served with our family’s sauce recipe – grated provolone and mozzarella cheeses		 $3.95
Fresh Veggie
Covered with our sauce – a blend of cheeses, sliced mushrooms, onions, green peppers, broccoli, & cauliflower		 $4.50
Seafood Lovers
A blend of cheeses, lump crab, shrimp, clams, diced tomatoes, & romano cheese on top of a light cream sauce		 $7.25
White
Brushed with garlic oil, topped with our cheese blend, diced tomatoes, & romano cheese		 $4.25
House Specials
Hot Meat Loaf Sandwich
Served with either mashed potatoes or fries & covered with gravy		 $5.50
Hot Roast Beef Sandwich
Served with fries or mashed potatoes, beef gravy		 $6.75
Sandi’s Favorite
A cup of wedding soup, house salad, & breadsticks		 $4.50
Chicken Fingers & Fries Basket $8.50
Shrimp Basket $6.75
Sandwich Sides
Bean City Fries $2.75
Fresh-Cut Spiral Fries $2.95
Tempura Onion Rings $3.50
From our Tureens
Homemade Minestrone
Veggies in a tomato, beef broth with just the right amount of pasta, sprinkled with romano cheese		 $2.25
Chili With Beans
Thick & delicious, made in our own kitchen from our recipe & guaranteed		 $2.75
French Onion Soup
With sauteed onion wedges, toasted Italian bread, lots of mozzarella cheese & covered with bubbling provolone		 $4.75
Pasta & Specialty Dishes
Fettuccine Alfredo $12.50
Lasagna $10.95
Pasta Sicilian
Topped with our sicilian sauce for your dining pleasure		 $10.95
Pasta A Farro
Layered pasta filled with ham, peas, salami, beef, romano then topped with sauce & mozzarella cheese		 $10.75
Gnocchi
A soft potato dumpling		 $10.50
Manicotti
Pasta tubes filled with ricotta cheese & topped with sauce & mozzarella cheese		 $11.95
Pasta Con Broccoli
Short pasta, cooked with fresh broccoli florets, served with olive oil, also great with sicilian sauce		 $10.50
Pasta Con Zucchini
A delicious sicilian dish-rina’s favorite-short pasta with either sicilian sauce or olive oil & fresh pan-fried zucchini slices topped with romano cheese		 $11.50
Tortollini Alla Panna
Small pasta cheese filled pies served in a thick white cream sauce-totaly delicious		 $10.50
Linguine Alla Pagaro
Served with a bolognese sauce		 $10.75
Mama Anne’s Homemade Ravioli
Made from mama’s recipe, filled with ricotta cheese or a mixture of ricotta & beef		 $11.75
Veal Marsala
Veal medallions with a seasoned breading, sauteed with garlic and mushrooms, & finished with marsala wine		 $14.50
Spaghetti Alla Casa Pagaro
Large dish of pasta with tomato. Change of sauce or pasta type, additional $1.00 each		 $9.85
Spaghetti & Mushroom’s
A hearty dish of pasta cooked al dente and topped with sauteed mushrooms		 $10.75
Spaghetti Aglio E Olive
Garlic sauteed in olive oil over pasta excellent when you add sauteed mushrooms. a la carte $10.75, full $12.95		 $9.50
Chicken Fettuccini Primavera
Grilled chicken breast with spring veggies in a white sauce		 $13.95
Seafood Pasta
Angel hair pasta topped with lump crab, shrimp, clams & sauteed mushrooms in light creamy red sauce		 $15.25
Scampi Linguine
Bite size in a garlic butter atop imported pasta		 $16.50
Veal Scaloppini
Tender veal pieces, sauteed with marsala wine, mushrooms, apple juice & spices		 $15.25
Chicken Romano
Chicken breast fillets, coated with a seasoned batter, pan fried in olive oil & steamed in a chicken broth		 $12.25
Chicken Marsala
Chicken fillets with seasoned breading, sauteed with the right amount of garlic & mushrooms, marsala wine finishes it!		 $11.75
Quick Lunches
Cup Of Soup, Salad
With breadstick & side of pasta. Choice of Sauce		 $6.75
Bowl Of Pasta E Fagioli
Served with warm italian bread		 $4.50
Eggplant Parm Sandwich On Italian Roll $5.75
Pasta, Meatball, & Garlic Toast $5.50
Garden Salad
With personal pizza-up to three (3) tops		 $5.75
A La Carte Luncheon Favorites
Spaghetti & Meatballs $8.50
Hot Turkey Sandwich $6.25
Dessert alla Pagano
Carrot Cake $3.95
Sherbet $2.25
N.Y. Cheesecake $3.95
Ice Cream $2.25
Spumoni $2.75
Torta Italian $4.95
Sweet Street Cakes & Pies $3.95
Hot & Cold Beverages
Bottomless Regular Or Decaffeinated Coffee $1.95
Bottomless Fountain Beverages $1.95
Bottomless House Iced Tea $1.95
Bottomless Lemonade $1.95
Espresso $3.50
Cappuccino $3.95
Milk $1.75
Juice $2.25
Hot Cocoa $2.25
Chocolate Milk $1.95
Hot Tea $1.95

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ashley “MIDGE” Midgett
Tried this Gem out while parked across the street on break. BEST DECISION EVER! Nice atmosphere and amazing food! I had the lunch special and the minestrone soup was the best I’d ever had! And my pasta… SUPERB! Would highly recommend.

… more

Jennifer Bradley
This place is aweful. Dirty, not a restaurant, not inviting. Nasty steak,tasteless overcooked apps,mushy spaghetti,microwave potato,yucky cheap margarine and not butter. Even the garlic bread was tasteless. Maybe if you are drunk at the bar everything would be ok. Tables are set up with a pool table, other machines. Don’t waste your time. Maybe other things are good but 3 dinners and 3 apps…pretty much tells me everything. And that was $73. Plus a big for sale sign so I think they gave up.

… more

Joanne Barnes
We were staying overnight and needed dinner. We found this place. It seemed like a local go to place , they were understaffed however, the server Kelly was very sweet and nice to our party. I ordered the chicken Marsala with red mashed potatoes and was pleasantly surprised. It was quite tasty. The men ordered pasta and meatballs and were happy with their choice. And the chicken Parmesan ordered by our other friend was (I’m her words) the best she remembered having.

… more

Lisa Caruso
Server was great. I had the quick lunch it was a cup of soup ( ok). Salad ( good). And angelhair pasta with Sicilian sauce.( Really good) my friend had grilled chicken salad. She said thumbs up. Was a bit noisy due to the chairs on the floor. And we were in bar/ lounge area. People were coming and going. We were both a bit uncomfortable , we are both short women. The chairs were high . All in all though…I’d try it again. The angelhair was good with the sauce they make in house.

… more

Judy Lambert Lambert
Don’t understand why businesses in the State of Pennsylvania don’t open until 3 or5, especially Bar’s how do they make any money!!! Stupid!!! Checked this place on internet on Saturday it said it was open, no, came at 2:30 pm it was closed, did not open until 4 the food is not that good, if you want good food go to Latolvia right down the street, there food is amazing and they have a bar also… it’s expensive but worth every dime!! Best Italian food you’ll ever eat!! The chef will come to your table, he’s also the owner, you must go to this place, you won’t be disappointed

… more

BigDog H
Great food and atmosphere and service!

… more

Lesley Sarles
We were staying in the area and looking for a place to grab dinner. So glad we tried this place out. Amazing service. Good food. Fun atmosphere. Definitely would recommend.

… more

Tim Brickner
Great wings! Only $1.50 per wing on Monday nights. And it’s the whole wing…drum, flat, and tip.

… more

Eprrockstar
Had the small pizza and buffalo wings and onion rings( shared of course) but it was amazing and the bar keep was very nice

… more

Stacy
The Salisbury steak dinner was excellent and it’s real steak not processed. Staff was very attentive and food was on time and hot.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch