Joe Cristiano’s Pizza is your neighborhood pizzeria! What does that mean to us? Well for starters – exceptional food, service, and value.
We work hard every day to not be your ordinary pizza restaurant. Our team works hard to go above and beyond in every way that matters to you, our customer. Premium pizza is our priority, so we use only the finest and freshest ingredients available. But we don’t stop at just pizza. Guests also rave about our wings, pastas, and hot subs! Our diverse menu is sure to have something to suit your cravings, and all at a great value, too.
We understand that you have many choices when it comes to feeding your family or friends so at Joe Cristiano’s Pizza we always do our best to be your pizzeria of choice!
No-frills outlet dishing classic & creative pies along with a variety of Italian basics & desserts. Based on 261 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1225 NY-9G, Hyde Park, NY 12538
Phone: (845) 229-8125
Website: https://www.joecristianospizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday |
11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday |
11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
12–8 PM |
| Monday |
11:30 AM–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Andy S.
Lyle is an exquisite and manager who can make a succulent pizza. Who ever makes meals most week nights is also a superb chef, everything is cooked perfect. My only complaint is that this location is incredibly hot. I can tell by the way the employees are sweating. Would appreciate seeing your staff treated better.
… more
Two Spoons
Overall – Low profile presence but great quality pie
… more
hayley piper
Excellent pizza and wings. Ordering online let’s you customize your order, I like my pizza crust soft and my wings extra crispy!
… more
Danielle C.
I tried this place again today. It was done and hot by the time I arrived for pick up. Staff was friendly and the pizza was hot. Wish we had more onions on the pizza but overall very happy with it.
… more
Marc Montross
Pizza slices were delicious and they only took a few minutes for christianos to heat get them ready for me plus between 2 and 4 they are half off on Fridays.
… more
Dani Massaro
My side salad was missing, the eggplant in my eggplant parmesan was mushy and all of the breading fell completely off, and they gave my husband a grilled chicken wrap completely soaked in balsamic dressing, which the fries they put in the same container as the wrap were also totally soaked in. We threw most of it in the garbage. I’m giving them 2 stars because the spaghetti and sauce tasted good. But for $30, I’ll be going somewhere else next time.
… more
Bobbi-Jo Pappalardo
Best Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza I have had in a long time. Very flavorful and the crust is a perfect crisp. Thank you.
… more
Lee Cohen
That’s supposed to be eggplant parm. It’s mush. I ordered online, it said it would be ready in 20 min, was done in 30. I waited for 10 minutes and did not see one person way their hands. You make the call, but this will be the last time I order from here
… more
Jessica lasher
If your looking for great meaty wings and the different types of sauces for them this is the place to be! Everytime I have ordered from here I’ve never been disappointed, I order the garlic butter wings and you can eat hot, cold the same day or next, they always taste delicious as well as their pizza, and very friendly staff
… more
Adam Rush
Pizza is pretty good but you need to specifically ask for tomato sauce on buffalo/bbq/cbr pizzas. Kind of annoying that they don’t do it automatically.
… more
… View more
