Based on 35 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout
Address:
16428 US-72, Rogersville, AL 35652
Phone: (256) 800-6262
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
| Sunday | 3–7 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Daniel Wessels
I passed by Mama Shelly’s Pizza every single day and never noticed it. I was looking for something else which I thought was in the same mall, I saw a large pizza sign. I happen to be a little hungry. I called my wife and asked if she was interested in trying a new pizza place, to us anyways, she agreed. The size of the pizza is immaculate. So what’s your spending, makes it worth it. I ordered a large pepperoni for myself which turns into lunch for the next couple days, and I ordered a small for my wife. We both agreed this will be our new pizza joint. I don’t think I caught the owner’s name but he took my order and was very helpful. He gave me a little backstory on the pizza place itself and his life which I appreciate. It’s a stop in grab your pizza and go joint and I believe his daughter has a little candy sale in the front as well. If you’re in the area I would suggest it over your three other choices in Rogersville. Be about helping small business.
… more
Sam Ashby
We are visiting from out of town and were trying to find a place to eat. I had the Tiger Supreme personal pizza and my wife had the chicken pickle pizza with the cauliflower crust. My stepdaughter got the same but with regular crust. We were very satisfied with the results and definitely would recommend them to anyone stopping through!
… more
James Rogers
I asked him to make a calzone for me it was not on the menu. It was absolutely delicious! The wings and the cheesy bread were awesome as well! My new pizza restaurant in rogersville!
… more
Ha Ha
Pizza was excellent! Med supreme xtra cheese. Pricy. Not crazy about the $1.00 fee to use credit card. Will think twice before returning.
… more
RON LEWIS
Pretty good, just a small place and food was good , was a little disappointed with the price of it but after getting it home and tasted it I was okay with what I spent
… more
Pamela Bennefield
We stopped by here randomly the other day. Normally, we get a large and have maybe one piece left. The gentleman did warn me their large was huge. We had plenty and then plenty of leftovers (better in the airfryer). We got a sausage, pepperoni and mushroom. There was great distribution of ingredients. The cheese was awesome! He had told me the mushrooms were accidentally cut smaller than normal so if we came back they may not be. We all loved them small. All in all a great place and we will definitely be back.
… more
Kimberly Gosser
Best pizza in the local area hands down! The large is LARGE and so cheesy and good! The sauerkraut pizza is amazing, especially with the butter sauce! We have eaten here frequently, kind folks and clean restaurant! We tell everyone we can to check it out!
… more
Matt Grose
By far the best pizza I have ever ate. The appearance of it when first open the box looks like something out of a magazine from Chicago or NY, and then when you taste it, it has the most flavor in a pizza you can get. Butcher’s special and Maui are amazing! Definitely will be ordering constantly!
… more
Suzanne L Metcalf
Wish it was more of a dine in restaurant. The pizza was great. I would go back. It is kind of a long drive for take-out.
… more
Amanda Barksdale
Checked out this place for National Pizza Day today. I can’t figure out how to share a picture to this post but just trust me when I say this is the largest large pizza I’ve ever gotten. It was huge and it was delicious. I walked in with my six year old while they were cutting and boxing our pizza and they offered to cut smaller slices when they saw I had a child with me.
… more
… View more