Based on 29 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
18243 Forest Rd Ste 4, Lynchburg, VA 24502
Phone: (434) 345-3160
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
christine piercy
Since leaving my last review I decided to try something new so we ordered the Tuscan Chicken Lettuce Wraps, Fried Mozzarella, Stuffed Shells, Pizza and Zeppoli & Gelato and a pizza. The chicken was so dry it literally scratched my mouth and throat. Nothing was “wrapped” there was just a bunch of tomato’s and dry chicken on top of wilted lettuce leaves. The stuffed shells were overcooked and pasty and the cheese filling was a runny tasteless mess. The pizza was lukewarm and dry, it had very little sauce and the dough itself seriously lacked flavor. The Zeppoli’s were hard, like they had been sitting for awhile or microwaved and the Gelato came prepackaged and was half melted because they put it in the same bag as the other food. It seems with this place the food is hit or miss. The only thing that we ate was the Mozzarella sticks and they were pretty good. To spend $55 on food you have to throw away is shameful and I won’t be doing it again!
… more
Chuck Pfeiffer
Reasonably-priced and great quality. My family and I love their pizza. The service is great too. They check our pizzas every time to make sure our order is correct, and the staff and owner are very friendly. We’ll be coming back again and again.
… more
Cameron White
My family and I chose to get the Beefeater pizza and an order of wings. The pizza was perfection with the right amount of toppings and cheese. The crust was exceptional as well. We chose Buffalo sauce for our wings and they were cooked just right. Their wings are big with a lot of meat on them. Be sure to give this place a try!
… more
Tessa Davis (_)
Ordered two pizzas, pan and NY. The pan used packaged sliced Munster? Not shredded. Very off putting to see plastic style slices of cheese, not to mention the evident lack of quality/flavor. The pan was just… Bready. It lacked the height, crunch, and chew you expect from standard pan (done in a cast iron). The NY was decent. The bread was Bready, no real spring or flavor, but okay. The sauce was devoid of seasoning, just tasted like a can of tomato sauce. The cheese was alright, had a good pull/stretch and flavor, also appreciates the cheese was fully on every slice! The servings are huge so you get a lot for your money. Staff was great! Clean environment! But I won’t be returning. Not the pizza style for me. I prefer Vinny’s.
… more
Charlotte Prosser
Lots of surprises here, some not all good. I thought they were so well rated, that this was their 2 nd week. Did I read a friends review? I thought the dough was plain. The toppings all in the center making the pizza crust wet. Half the bottom was burned. Like the oven had heat on one side. There is no Dine in.
… more
Tracy Tomlin
Hands down the best pizza in town! We also had the Ravioli Ruffino and salads that were equally amazing. The ranch dressing is homemade and that is a huge plus for my family. We can’t wait to go back again very soon and be greeted by the super friendly owners! ❤️
… more
Cheryl Brown
Hands down, awesome pizza….exactly what I remembered about Sal’s pizza when it was in Fort Hill Village. A wait that was a little longer than anticipated, but was no problem and worth it…. A new restaurant always needs time to work out the kinks. Owner was on point with greeting customers and checking on the staff to keep things rolling along. Glad they finally opened!
… more
Greg Torode
I went there the other day and got the first pizza. Hung out and chatted with the owners and felt so welcomed by them. Amazing folks and the pizza was on point. I had to eat a piece of course before I got home of course. Will be a forever customer!
… more
Marilyn Delgado
Had better and worse in the lynchburg area. For a similar taste- jojos has a more family atmosphere and for a better taste- sourdough pizza has fresher ingredients. Overall decent pizza for price.
… more
Steve Harmon
I grew up with Michael Vitale so I might be a little bit biased but go ahead and let Vitale Pizza fix you up a pie and you won’t be disappointed. Customer service is great, pizza is buzzin and it’s a local family. I only eat pizza from here now.
… more
… View more