Gaetano’s is the King of Steaks. West Berlin and the surrounding area has fallen in love with our Cheese Steaks, Chicken Cheese Steaks, Pizza, and Hoagies. Order takeout today and we know you’ll be able to discover a new favorite.
Gaetano’s has its own bakery that supplies fresh rolls DAILY – only the freshest high-quality ingredients are used.
We make our own Mozzarella Wedges, Chicken Tenders with Panko Bread Crumbs, Wings, Hot Sauce, Marinara, Pizza Sauce, and Dough on-premises.
Basic mainstay in a strip mall offering cheesesteaks, pizza, subs & more, plus takeout & delivery. Based on 275 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
437 NJ-73, West Berlin, NJ 08091
Phone: (856) 753-1919
Website:
Hours
| Tuesday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday |
10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Md Mahin
“Gaetano’s in West Berlin is a culinary delight! From the inviting ambiance to the flavorful dishes, every moment was a pleasure. Attentive service and a memorable dining experience. Highly recommended!”
… more
Mike
Their pizza is ok.(nothing stellar but its better than 7/11. Their clam strips are also alright ,and their hoagies arent bad. Their burgers however, leave much to be desired. A bun with a patty and cheese is all you get for 26$ with a 4$ tip. Honestly McDonald’s gives you more for half the price.
… more
Ramon Daniel Rosario
We’re new to the area and looking for a place for good subs high and low this place is by far the best in the area hands down worth every single dollar. One of the best chicken parm sandwiches ever
… more
Alisyn S
Excellent cheese steaks and salads. I had a featured steak that contained steak, cheese, sweet peppers, and pepperoni. I was fantastic @
… more
Dennell
Always a favorite place to stop while in the area. I got the 11in sub and it was absolute greatness! Wait time was minimal and they had an awesome staff. I will definitely come back here to try more things on the menu.
… more
Russell Clark
Been a few years since I have had one of their Cheese Steaks, the “Mr G”… never fails to hit the mark!!! I was fortunate enough to be in the area today but would be worth the drive just to get the steak sandwich… will definitely be back to get more!!!
… more
Sekema Gentles
I have been coming here from PA since 2015. Lisa David and Alex are the best. Food is always cooked to perfection. Love this place.
… more
Ryan Stradling
The King of Steaks is back! I used to come here when I first moved in the area a few years ago but had to stop after so many bad experiences with the food. The previous owner really ran the restaurant into the ground. Forget him though as the new owner, Dom, is an awesome dude whose top priorities are quality and satisfaction. Best buffalo chicken around by a longshot. The quality and portions are back up to par with the Gaetano’s name you’ve come to know and love. The prices might seem a little steep up front if you are used to ordering from a lower quality place where one order just fills you up enough. Just wait until you actually taste the amazing food and see how much you get for that price (multiple meals out of one order). It blows my mind how Dom provides high quality meats, in overstuffed portions, and keeps the price where it’s at with how expensive everything else is getting. The service and friendly atmosphere knocks it out of the park. Can’t recommend this place enough. Try out their buffalo chicken stromboli with the grilled chicken. It’s a life changer.
… more
S. Roberts
This was a must …. Visiting my hometown I had to make a trip to this spot…. It was worth every bite. They even have there own ginger soda that is awesome! It’s a must try if you love a ginger drink.
… more
Robert Ely
First off .. Very friendly staff made coming in worth it to sit down.
… more
… View more
