Relaxed joint with thin-crust pizza, sandwiches & basic Italian dishes, plus outdoor seating & beer. Based on 988 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
134 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Phone: (269) 469-0200
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Asli Weil
Stopped here by chance and omg we will be back! Buffalo pizza…outstanding! Cucumber Breeze drink was perfect! 6 kids and 2 adults happy! Place was packed but they handled the rush very well! Indoor, outdoor setting. This place is our new favorite pizza place!
… more
Yumsah’s Website Design
Thin crust pizza was flavourful for the size, though at $7 I was kind of expecting a more fulfilling slice. There was 5 workers by the register and I had to wait an awkward moment while they finished up their talk so I could place my order.
… more
Meranda Burkhardt
The pizza was very good, cooked well. The fries came out cold from the sandwich, not sure what’s up with that. I appreciate them being open on a holiday but pretty much all the servers didn’t look like they wanted to be there at all, had to ask for my check and refill and they were just sitting on their phone. I’m not impressed with this kind of service, especially when you’re being tipped to serve. (yes I did tip.) was $92 for five people to eat.
… more
Aaron Wells
In today’s culinary exploration, we turn our gaze to a modest yet remarkable establishment nestled in the heart of New Buffalo: Villa Nova Pizzeria. In an era where fast food chains dominate and authenticity is often sacrificed at the altar of convenience, this pizzeria stands as a testament to the timeless virtues of quality and tradition.
… more
Valerie Griffin
Service was slow and nit mist friendly, but msybe she was having an off day. The pizza and breaks ticks were amazing. And felt the price was fair
… more
Keri
After waiting 15 minutes for a table we were seated in the blazing sun. Pasta and salad came out quickly; After at least 30 minutes when others had finished eating some of the pizzas came out but two were still missing. One they said was taken by someone else and it took another 15 minutes and was a small instead of the large we ordered. Somehow they had also misunderstood and not ordered the other one. We were told if we still wanted it we would be at the back of the line and have to wait 30 minutes again. So we went and ordered food elsewhere. They wouldn’t do separate checks – just 3 checks for 2 tables. There was even a lengthy wait to use the restrooms. The waitress was stressed and frazzled. Management was nowhere to be seen. We were barely given an apology and still charged a full gratuity. The pizza was good but not worth it.
… more
Laura Levin
Best thin crust pizza I’ve had in a long time! Big chunks of sausage and if you love cheese they take care of ya! I ordered extra cheese and the cheese is real and the pizza was awesome today we have the combination and a calzone… unbelievably amazing
… more
Amy H-R
Absolutely delicious meals! We’ve had pizza before quick is always great but we had pasta dinners tonight and my dad hasn’t stopped talking about how delicious his dinner was. My spaghetti and meatballs was so good! Reasonably priced and great portions. Fresh warm bread with the meals too. Outside dining also a great option. We’ll be back!
… more
Rhonda Lane
This was a pick up as I ended my get away here in New Buffalo! The pizza was DELICIOUS. Just enough sauce, cheese, sausage and mushrooms!! This is now 1 of my top 5. The pizza alone will take me back! Didn’t eat there so I can’t comment on the service. The service that I got was good and the atmosphere of the place seemed nice! Will definitely be going back!
… more
Chris Kirsch
Generally I only compliment on reviews so this is awkward. I was at villa nova on Saturday. It was quite busy/ packed. Despite this, “Manager” Lexy treated me as though I was the only one there. U returned (I live 230 miles away) yesterday. I went to the hostess and asked if I could sit at the bar (technically no need but out of respect for her position). She said yes. I sat one seat from the street. A waitress was attending a table to my right. She passed me shortly after. Long story short, GPS claims I was there for 11+ minutes. After said waitress had gone behind the bar to key in orders I asked if there was a bartender. She said, “no.” I suggested she inform the hostess. After passing me umpteen times and not saying a word. Even if you were there to pick up carry- out this was absurd. I got up and asked the hostess why she confirmed my sitting at the bar to which she replied, “we don’t have a bartender.” I was at villa nova four times last year. Same scenario ironically- Was 50/50 between terrific and ridiculous, literally looking for a hidden- camera show being shot. Shame. Lexy and the amazing waitress on labor day were tremendous. The others, sad.
… more
… View more