Tiny, takeout-focused pick offering traditional & creative pies, plus sandwiches & pasta. Based on 215 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
923 S Walter Reed Dr, Arlington, VA 22204
Phone: (703) 920-9110
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Anthony Cortina
I’m not sure they actually make Sicilian–style pizza… at least not the type that anyone who has lived in or grew up in the tri-state area remembers.
… more
Salim Alchurbaji
I live 3 minutes away (1.1 miles) from Sicilian Pizza. We ordered a large margarita pizza at 9:34pm and received a notification by GrubHub that the order would arrive between 10:30-10:40pm. At 9:57pm we opted to call the restaurant to see if we could pickup the order instead and ask about the status of the order. The woman who answered the phone told us that the order was with her driver, that he was making a delivery first but then would be on his way with our pizza arriving in 10 mins. I commented that “we live like 2 mins away so you’d think the driver would come this way first”. The women then responded by saying she would cancel the order and abruptly hung up. We were confused by how she could cancel the order if it was already with the driver and he was enroute. We also got another text from GrubHub that the order was on the way at 10:01pm. At 10:40pm the pizza has still not arrived so we called the restaurant back. The same woman answered the phone again — when I gave her the address and inquired about the status of the order she said “I canceled your order. You laughed at my driver and I don’t like that. You’re a liar you don’t live 2 mins away. you can order from Dominos I don’t need your money!” And again slammed the phone shut on me. I’m utterly shocked and perplexed by this most unprofessional of customer service experiences. It also dawned on me that it would be implausible for her to cancel the order if the pizza was truly enroute with the driver. So…speaking of liars….I advise this establishment to make serious improvements to the treatment of their customers. This woman is likely the owner or manager, otherwise I’d be even more shocked that she would be so boldly rude and abrasive.
… more
Seb Rothering
From Illinois visiting the DC area and my girlfriend is Sicilian so we thought we’d give this a try. We were not disappointed even a little bit. I’ve only had a couple other places pizza wise but this was the best by far!
… more
G D
Edible but overrated. To the person that said this is the best pizza that you’ve ever had… you may need to get out more. No sauce, crust a little soggy kinda spongey. Topings come in at a generous amount but underrated as far as flavor. 25 bucks for a large that’s about the size of most places mediums. Super sweet delivery driver. All in all… Wouldn’t do it again.
… more
Chelsea Rankin
We’ve ordered from here before and loved it. This time was not the best. We ordered the Sicilian Pizza which is supposed to be square but it wasn’t. Not that big of deal for us. The thing that sucked was instead of proscuitto they used country ham. It was terrible. It was soooo salty. There’s a big difference between the two. The cheesy bread is delicious. The Arlington Pizza was awesome. They also have an option to build your own calzone with sauce options like pesto, alfredo and garlic sauce which we love. Just do yourself a favor and don’t order anything with proscuitto unless you want salty country ham.
… more
Leo Godinez
I love going to this place since it’s so close from my job and the food is fantastic! The manager is so nice and polite and always treats me well! Prices are good so definitely check it out!
… more
Alex Neubert
We were in the neighborhood looking for a dinner option and saw this was highly rated. Lucked out with easy parking out front, got the large Sicilian and it was excellent and a good value.
… more
Angela Urick
I don’t usually do reviews. However, after my experience with a lady at Sicilian Pizza, I felt like I had to. Today I ordered pizza using the Slice app. It got to me in only half the estimated delivery time, which was great. However, the pizza was raw in the middle. Nothing but dough. And it had too much sauce, which was not that great. So I contacted support through Slice to let them know the pizza was half raw. They promptly refunded my money, which I did not ask for. As I was completing my chat with them, a lady from the restaurant called and left me a message that I “was not allowed to be my customer anymore”. She didn’t even ask what the problem was or if she could resolve the issue. Are you serious? What horrible customer service.
… more
M Tauf
Pizza was really good I got the spicy chicken. Seemed like there was extra cheese which I didn’t mind. Service was friendly too
… more
Stephen Fowler
Ordered a prosciutto pie today. First time trying this place. Order arrived very quickly and hot. Crust on the pizza was very good, thin crust with light charring. Toppings were excellent and fresh. Will order from these folks again!
… more
… View more