No-frills local chain known for pizza by the slice, plus extra-large pies & specialty toppings. Based on 429 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
315 E Kort St, Rothschild, WI 54474
Phone: (715) 298-4461
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jason Kniess
Good variety of pizza… the pulled pork was delicious, garlic knots were also good. Not overly pricey, good lunch spot.
… more
Derek Bickford
We are here visiting in Wausau staying at the Best Western Hotel. We looked up local pizza places and decided to try Polito’s. This is the worst Pizza I have ever had that cost me $20 I will not recommend Polito’s Pizza ever. I called the manager to describe my experience The Taste and the quality appearance texture and toppings but she said I can’t help you. There is one piece of pepperoni one onion and one green pepper and one mushroom on each slice.. I could have gotten a better pizza from the frozen section at Pick n Save. I do not recommend Polito’s Pizza. They have terrible service and horrible food quality in addition to horrible management. By the way here’s some pictures of a $20 Pizza it’s kind of ridiculous.
… more
Tyler Sternot
Was here on Sunday 3/19/23 around 6:15pm. I had a TERRIBLE experience. The lady working behind the counter was very rude and you could definitely tell she hates her job. She was wearing earbuds the whole time she was helping so I had to repeat myself many times. She walked away before I could even finish my order and when asked if they had a certain kind of pizza she VERY rudely replied NO. Then ran to the cash register and said in a VERY rude tone “you want anything else or no” The employees working seemed to be more worried about the friends they had in the lobby than the other customers in line. There were other customers who walked out behind me shaking their heads. This employee ruined this restaurant for me when other times it has been great. I know how badly these negative google reviews impact business and I have never left one before, but this one is well deserved.
… more
Kimmie Up North
Best pizza around, really good “by the slice” selection! Wish we had a location in Rhinelander
… more
Lori B
Lunch rush so service was fast and easy. Pizza was fresh and delicious. Garlic knots were not very hot maybe an off day ♀️
… more
K
$24 for a burnt 14 inch
… more
Pookie Rosa (Pookie Rosa)
True New York style pizza. Variety of toppings. Always delicious with a snap, crispy crust.
… more
Nathan Schultz
Great place to just grab a extra large slice of pizza for a snack, lunch or dinner. Reasonably priced also
… more
Melissa LaPorte
Not much of a selection when we were there at 6:00 on a Sunday. Girl behind the counter was not friendly at all. Almost all of the tables needed to be wiped down. But the pizza was good.
… more
LC P
I ordered 5 individual pizza pieces and 2 orders of garlic knots through DoorDash. The order came in incomplete and the knots had a TON of butter; the pizza was good. I called Politos ,and the manager did not take care of the situation. I will not blame the worker, however, when a customer says this is my last over ever, an apology would be nice. So getting Politos as I go to Starbucks is not something I will continue doing. The mistake was theirs according to the person who answered the phone. I just wanted a refund or the pizza to be brought to us. They would not refund the account and after making the mistake, I was going to have to drive to rectify their mistake. NOT ACCEPTABLE.
… more
… View more