Based on 613 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery
Address:
645 W Church St, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 522-8457
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Erik Frahn
The restaurant was nicely decorated and clean. The service was fair. The food was presented nice, however that’s about the only good thing. The loaded tots were sub standard. The bacon looked and tasted like Hormel imitation bacon bits. There was plenty on the order and cheesey, but did not adhere to the tots. The barbeque chicken pizza was flavorable but the crust was over cooked and almost to hard to chew. The cauliflower crust blt was average taste but also had over cooked the crust and was very difficult to chew. If we do go back, it definitely won’t be for the pizza but to try another item. The price was fair.. under $40 for an app, 2 small pizzas and 1 beverage.
… more
teresa rodriguez
If I could rate this joke of a pizza place any less than 1 star I would. Last night I ordered a regular Hawaiian pizza and when it arrived my husband realized it had onions all over it. I can’t eat onions (I’m allergic) and he doesn’t like them so we tried to call to see what we could do and of course their phones shut down 30 minutes before our pizza was even delivered so we were stuck… Called after they opened at 4pm today… I’d rather go back to before when I couldn’t even speak to anyone, it was like talking to a brick wall. I spoke with at least two women about what we could do and got absolutely nowhere. They said they couldn’t do anything at all while we even kept the pizza to prove it. What a waste of money for nothing. I think one of the ladies was the manager and she was pretty rude and incredibly unhelpful. I’ve never heard of such a place with so much unprofessionalism. And to add on to before the lady on the phone from when I ordered didn’t even bother to mention it came with onions (me or my husband have NEVER heard of a Hawaiian with onions before…) To say the least neither of us will ever be eating Don and Sues again and we will be warning against it to anyone we can. (The pizzas a mess because we were pretty mad about it to say the least.)
… more
Nicole Morgan
We live in the city and trying to have dinner on the weekend gets crazy! So we drove outside the city and randomly got off this exit. Best random drop-in decision for a restaurant ever!!! Great ambiance, great drinks, great food, great service! We can’t wait to go back again as a family with small kids!
… more
Anita Woodruff
Our first time here. We ordered extra sauce on our pizza. As you can see by the picture, it’s a pretty dry, thin pizza. The waitress did take off $1.86 for the extra sauce. My husband got an Italian sub. Just okay.
… more
Levi McGlone
Food was delivered by door dash.
… more
Miranda Hartless
Waitress was awesome, the kitchen staff horrible! They told us an hour wait on food when we got there, completely fine! Ended up waiting almost 2 hours for food, everything was burnt, 5 different subs were incorrect, didn’t even receive 2 of the meals until we were packing up to leave. The waitress was very embarrassed that the kitchen was so short staffed and doing a poor job. She was very very kind about everything.
… more
David Shorey
Have never had a bad experience here. Great food, great atmosphere. You gotta try it first hand.
… more
Renee Thorn
I loved the decor. Our waitress was amazing. The food was delicious.
… more
Jade O’Hara
server was kind of rude, but in a way she seemed like she was having a bad day, so I won’t discredit her. but food was delicious. we order from here almost exclusively in the area because they are so good. we also left a back pillow there and the staff held onto it until we called and picked it up the next day!
… more
Melissa Killoran
Their buffalo chicken pizza is REALLY good! Their sauce isn’t too sweet, most places’ are these days. I love their thin, crispy crust! I will get all my pizzas from them now.
… more
… View more