Based on 141 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
794 Main St, Center Moriches, NY 11934
Phone: (631) 878-4755
Website: http://www.michelangelocentermoriches.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Steven Tringali
Just stopped in to Michelangelo pizza and restaurant today for a quick bite. We were greeted by Kylie being the counter who was very nice and helpful when trying to decide what to order. Doug, the owner was back there as well spooning the dough for his next masterpiece of a pie.
… more
Chris Enright
Easily the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Burnt underneath and unmelted cheese on top on a plain pizza. A stuffed pizza also had the bottom burnt, and the dough inside raw. I don’t know how you could pull that off. A sausage and pepper hero that had 85 percent peppers to 15 percent sausage (a half a sausage on a hero?) I placed this order through slice. When the restaurant was given the opportunity to rectify the situation, they stated that they made everything perfectly and that they do not work for free. This shows no ownership of your criticisms and you will not last long in business, let alone the service industry. I will go to Gerardo’s or Mama Lisa instead, like I should have. They have excellent pizza, but I wanted to try something new. Never again.
… more
George Cerruto
I have to say I’m disappointed tonight. I love the Sicilian pie from them. And always get the garlic knots. Tonight. The sicillian was barely cooked. Cheese not even melted. Just sad. I’m some parts cold.
… more
Nicole Zorn
Food has been going downhill for a while now but I won’t be coming back again. Was just given a completely raw pinwheel. Only cooked part of the dough was the crust.
… more
c wall
Came here with my family for Pasta night. There was 8 of us. They have a cute little dining room in the back of the pizzeria. The girls who helped us were very nice and sweet. The salad had a great presentation & was very fresh. The food was good with good portions. My family had a great dining experience. We recommend it and we will be back.
… more
Michael H
3.4 rating?? I’m surprised. I order a 4 topping large pizza. I got maybe 10 pieces of each topping on the whole pizza. Got like 6 pieces of pineapple on the pizza. It was a topping i paid for n they r that cheap? Paid $27 for this one pizza n it was trash. I will never return and highly DO NOT recommend this place. Go to Carlos on William Floyd parkway.
… more
Cee Dee
I worked at this place and the owner is a piece of work. He owes me a weeks pay of $517 that he refuses to pay because I quit. I was a good worker but the working conditions are terrible. There is no heat nor hot water. So dishes were being washed in ice cold water!!!! With frozen hands. So basically they really weren’t getting clean. There are bugs in that place and needless to say employees don’t wear gloves 99.9% of the time. The food is inconsistent in quality and sometimes they use the previous days pizza. They won’t be in business too much longer. It’s on its way under bc God doesn’t like ugly
… more
Brad Turnow
Since the new ownership has taken over, the place has gotten excellent. Great food and huge selection. Their Sicilian slices are nicely portioned and taste great. Sauce is included with knots!!! Their knots are a meal in themselves. Huge selection of desserts as well. Only about 3-4 tables for lunch so be aware. Love this place and we will be back!
… more
Robert Hogan
I ordered two slices for myself and my girlfriend and we really enjoy the atmosphere and the food and the owner was very pleasant.
… more
Michelle Cancel
Tonight I’m stuck on the side of the highway because my tire was long gone into the woods it went. My husband and brother in law were trying to figure out how they were getting the tire back on and a nice gentleman had stopped to ask if we needed help. He introduced himself and we did like wise. Come to find out he was the owner of my favorite pizza place. After listening lightly to the men introducing themselves and Douglas stating he was the owner I had to but in and tell him that was my favorite pizza place. Quoting “Thursday night pizza”. Their food is amazing. The pizza is always fresh, soft and made to perfection. The employees are always happy and greeting you with smiles and professionalism!!! Will always be my number 1 pizza place!
… more
… View more