Chicago-style deep-dish & New York thin-crust pizza plus pasta in a casual, family-friendly space. Based on 938 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4441 W Metairie Ave, Metairie, LA 70001
Phone: (504) 454-5885
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brooks Williamson
We love That’s Amore!
… more
Becky in NOLA
This restaurant is surprisingly larger on the inside than it appears from outside. The atmosphere is warm and inviting. There are plenty of tables to accomodate large parties. The staff is wonderful, nice and attentive. The ongoing debate for here is New York or Chicago style pizza. We had both. We ordered 2 pizzas, the pizza beignets,cheese sticks & a side italian salad. The food is delicious. The NY pizza is a little pricey. The beignets were light fluffy fried dough with a little cheese and sauce inside. The Chicago really made a statement. Lots of cheese. It will fill you up fast! Also, know that the Chicago pizza takes about 45 minutes to prepare & bake. The sauce is homemade. Not sure which one I preferred. We will return to eat here again. I want to try the ice cream next time.
… more
Tom Hibbs
My kids and I absolutely love a well done Chicago Deep Dish pizza and I’ve been looking for really good option in the GNO and I’ve found it! Youngest and I went by tonight and I’m a new fan of That’s Amore! The staff was attentive and super nice. We understand the deep dish takes 45 minutes to prep and cook so we immediately hit up the hostess with our order. She gave the thumbs up and passed the order to the waitress immediately who made a quick check and sent to the line. The pizza was amazing. Tons of REAL quality cheese, the best tomatoes in the sauce (seriously, right in the middle between Roma and San Marzano and super fresh), perfect crust, and delicious toppings. Don’t sleep on this one, folks. Bring your appetite. Also, one of the best tasting and coldest Jucifers I’ve had in a while. We will be back!
… more
Court Cronin
Food was good and the atmosphere was nice. Service was a little slow. The pizza was good and flavorful. They have a lot of good looking items on the menu. The parking lot is small and took a couple passes before a spot opened up. I would go back here. We had a New York style pizza. They also have a Chicago deep dish that looked good. Check it out.
… more
Hanna Bee
One of my favorite spots, the crew is awesome and the owner is cool. It’s definitely a family friendly place. The food is delicious
… more
Ktouch
Italian oysters, hot sausage po boys, and Supreme Pizza were all awesome! Service was great! Zoey and Joel took excellent care of us!
… more
DeadSpider
Stopped in for the first time. Pretty good food. Service was great. Was not too impressed with the waitress who took our order and whatnot but the other ladies who kept checking in on us were great. Also the young man was doing an amazing job as well.
… more
Travis Deck
We were looking for a new Pizza place, as we have just moved to New Orleans. We were pleasantly surprised by That’s Amore. This place is great. The Deep Dish Chicago is very good and has a great sauce. Service was great the manager stopped by and made sure we were happy and satisfied … all and all we have a new pizza place and will be back again and again.
… more
Claude Louis
So this is my first Chicago style deep dish pizza, so I’ll have to say–what an experience! Firstly, the staff, cleanliness, and atmosphere of the restaurant were great! The owner (whose name I can’t remember) actually visited the table to check on everything and I’m always impressed when the top visits the bottom. And, while the great debate of whether the Chicago style or New York style is better is still in the air, everything I had here tasted amazing.
… more
michelle collins
Absolutely AMAZING!! The Chicago style pizza was great! Pizza fries and fried pickles were delicious with huge servings and the staff was friendly. Lauren was an amazing server. A++++
… more
… View more