Pizzas, subs & other Italian fare served at this counter-serve New York-style storefront. Based on 511 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
Commen Plaza, 13851 S John Young Pkwy Ste 106 In Hunters Creek, Orlando, FL 32837
Phone: (407) 251-1595
Website: http://sliceofnypizza.net/
Hours
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rose Toro
This is a great place to get pizza. I love the food, it’s made fresh and tastes great! The owners are very nice and treat their customers well. I highly recommend
… more
Samantha Alicea
Been here one time pizza was decent decided to give it another try and waited outside until they opened come to find out they don’t have pizza ready. Most other pizza spots I been to in Orlando they have pizza out displayed and ready regardless if they just opened or not. You guys open at 12 which is lunch time and should be more prepared
… more
Kimberly Black
We came here for lunch one day while we were on vaycay. We had just left the chocolate museum and it was pouring rain. It was a small place and not bust but, had good rating. They had 5 cheap lunch specials so, we got those. The lady up front was helpful with the questions we had. The pizza took a little longer to come out than I wanted guess cause I was starving! The pizza was a good size and it was as you can see delicious looking pizza. I LOVE a good greasy slice of pizza. If we ever come back to orlando we will stop in again.
… more
J. D.
Small pizza shop. Was in the area and stopped in for bite. Prize is good but unfortunately overall we were not very impressed. Food looked great but the taste wasn’t. My Sicilian pizza was partially cold. Seemed like it was pre made and thrown into the oven upon order, and they didn’t let it cook all the way. Restaurant itself seemed unkept. Unfortunately we won’t be back.
… more
JR Cessna
Pizza presentation is good. Crisp is nice. Dough is a bit too thick for my liking but definitely not unpleasant. The cheese is good, not too oily but too salty. The sauce however is very forgetful. Unfortunately, it just very mediocre. The location is a hole in the wall but it’s ok for a neighborhood spot.
… more
Todd B
Worst pizza I have ever eaten! The only possible way they have any good reviews if they write them for themselves or know the people who are writing them because this pizza is absolutely terrible!
… more
Me B
We love A Slice Of NY Pizza. My favorite is the lasagna. Lasagna with the house salad, house dressing, and one of Slices famous Pinwheels is one of my favorite meals anywhere. You get a lot for your money and the owners and staff are wonderful people that always make you feel welcomed. I highly recommend Slice Of MY Pizza.
… more
Luis Siu
Great pizza! Incredible size and taste. Also put some wings to that order
… more
Joseph Marmolejo
Today by far was the most embarrassing and worst experience I’ve encountered. Ordered a pie for my family for takeout half cheese and half chicken. When I open box to check pizza 3 slices had chicken and 5 cheese. I ask chef or owner and he said am I complaining about that and touch my pizza. I think I should receive food how I and my 8month pregnant wife requested it but he cursed at me in Spanish and told me to take a refund after years of supporting this business. Then stared me down till I was scared and walked away. What a nightmare and it’s disappointing but I will be taking my family elsewhere and I suggest you do also. This was done in front of their clients.
… more
Beckie Smock
Such delicious pizza and very accommodating! Super nice service on the phone and inside. Thank you!!!
… more
… View more