Casual spot offering pizzas & basic Italian fare, plus a huge patio with Lake Mahopac views. Based on 732 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
654 US-6 Suite 1, Mahopac, NY 10541
Phone: (845) 628-4404
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: fourbrothersmahopac.com
Reviews
nicholas yannaco
Tonight was a great dining experience. We were very fortunate to get Michelle as our server. She was attentive, precise and warm. I enjoyed the fresh ravioli and the homemade Russian dressing. The place had an excellent energy. Two thumbs up. We will be back.
… more
Gail Augustine
We’ve eaten here about 4 times over all when we’ve come to visit family here. It’s always been good. Today, I don’t know what happened but we went for lunch and we ordered 2 appetizers they both came out cold and the mozzarella sticks were still frozen inside. The waitress immediately apologized and took both appetizers back and came back with fresh hot ones. They were so good.
… more
Jacqueline Vita
Great food with music and a view! Four Brothers Pizza has the best recipe for a deliciously satisfying meal as well as a picturesque view of Lake Mahopac. And if you happen to dine on weekends you can also enjoy a variety of musical talents. Call ahead and ask when Robbie Rigo is playing so you can enhance your dining experience. He will not disappoint either. This visit we enjoyed a flavorful Bruschetta. Perfectly grilled bread topped with fresh chopped zesty tomatoes, garlic, basil & olive oil. I enjoyed my delicious entree, Chicken Rustico, a delicately sauteed chicken with garlic, hot cherry peppers, sausage, brown gravy & a touch of wine. But the entree that stole the spotlight was a gastronomic feast for both the eyes and stomach. It began with a stunningly sublime presentation of Zuppa di Pesce. There was an abundance of juicy clams, shrimp, calamari, mussels and was complimented by a zesty marinara sauce over el dente linguine. The exquisite taste surpassed its presentation by a narrow margin. And do ask for more toasty bread tho soak up every drop! Four Brothers Pizza has able seating both inside or out and don’t forget to leave room for a “big” dessert!
… more
Ryan Jardine
Wasn’t the most pleasant visit I’ve had in a restaurant in a while. Decided to try out Four Brothers, made reservations although it wasn’t required for a Sunday evening dinner. Was sat in the front section of the restaurant behind a wall, so you are pretty much out of sight from servers and rely on them remembering. To top things off, the water that was served tasted horrible and we asked for another alternative which was bottled water but we were still charged for it which I wouldn’t mind paying if that is what we asked for to begin with. The tap water I had to spit out immediately upon taking a sip, so there’s that. Secondly, the bathroom water was out, so you could wash your hands as im sure anyone would like to do before eating, couldn’t do that, nor could you use the toilet besides using the urinal. My girlfriend walked out of the bathroom when she went in the females bathroom, there was pee in the toilet and couldn’t be flushed.
… more
King NiQs
As soon as I came threw the door the owner greeting me and treated me like I was family. Food is awesome and he also let me know what was the best to get since I was in a rush for work.
… more
Kenny Schaefer
Great food here at for brothers!
… more
Zoey Z
Always wanted to try this place. Came here for dinner last night. Bread was not given to our table. Entrees took over an hour to be served. When they arrived, both entrees were still frozen in the middle. Diners at other tables kept getting up to reach their server. Owner or manager went to certain tables to ask how everything was. Skipped over my table and a couple of other tables that were waiting a long time for service. Service was bad and food was bad. Not going back or recommending this place.
… more
Jackiee
My experience at Four Brothers was not a great one. The service started out okay. Our waiter brought out our appetizer and salads quickly, but then our experience went down from there. We waited a very long time for our entrees which was okay, but then our waiter never checked on us and NEVER refilled our waters! When we asked for napkins and water, our waiter took forever! When our waiter FINALLY came over he was NOT apologetic. Then, we informed the waiter we were frustrated with the service and he gave us an attitude. This is not the first time this has happened to us. The last time we went to your restaurant the service was also extremely slow. Your food is delicious, but the service is awful! We will not be returning.
… more
Kay Cee
Edit: came here for dinner during a snowy day. They were able to sit a party of 5 relatively quick (thank you weather). We ordered multiple appetizers and drinks along with our main meals. Everyone enjoyed and our waiter was wonderful.
… more
Esther Napolitano
Excellent food and service. We had a buffet-style gathering and everything was perfect. Beautiful view of the water, too. We highly recommend them.
… more
… View more