Old school-stylized counter with thick-cut square pizza by the slice with various toppings. Based on 59 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2000 Ximeno Ave, Long Beach, CA 90815
Phone: (562) 498-1411
Website: http://www.milanasnewyorkpizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Grey Rhino
These square pizzas are unique and you can buy just slices and a full pizza bases on how much you can fit in your stomach. I ordered two slices thinking it would be more than enough, but I was full by eating half slice. The slices are that big and you can chose your own toppings, meat and heat level.
… more
Mary Ngô
Not on the menu, had to ask but got a delicious personal sized gluten free crust pizza. didn’t feel heavy. I am gluten sensitive and my husband is not. they had delicious options for both of us. so grateful.
… more
Thomas Wyatt
Great pizza, expected price. Location has decent parking, easy enough to get to. Would come here again. Pizza was good, dough was good, nice sauce. Got a square that was reheated quickly in the oven. Staff were fine, processed my order quickly.
… more
Tazzzie333
Came here for the first time. The pizza is delicious! I’ve tried many places in the past including pizza in Rome, Italy and let me tell you this place is up there with some of the places in Italy. The quality of the ingridients are superb. The pepperoni, wow so good and the quality of the cheese is excellent. The quality of the crust is mama mia! also excellent! Had so much flavor. Crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Try honey on your pepperoni you’ll thank me later. They have very friendly, helpful staff. Very cute indoor seating, New York style decor. Loved the vibe. I’ll definitely come back soon.
… more
Simon Lau
I was craving for some pizza by the slice tonight. I had seen this new restaurant recently as I live nearby and thought to check it out. Parking is available in the large lot shared by a number of other businesses. The cashier, Angelina, was great in explaining the menu which includes a scilian cheese slice at $4.50 plus 50 cent per topping or 2 slices from the case for $9.45. Other options include build your own, calzones, etc. I opted for two slices and it didnt disappoint! The Pepperoni with Honey was popular and I also got the Brooklyn Meat. They also have a Vegan Square and vegetarian options. The slices are fairly large (maybe about 6″ by 6″) and the crust was good. Before handing me the pizza, they placed the slices into the oven so it came out delicious. I liked the decor which has photos of the owner’s (son and father) family, and they seem very nice.
… more
joor’din valentine
Had my first visit there last night, after weeks of pushing my pizza craving away because I didn’t want to be disappointed with mediocre pizza and I was only sad I didn’t order more pizza to eat at home later.. will not make that mistake next time. The pizza is the best I’ve had in a long time and the place is so cute with a great atmosphere that definitely didn’t feel like we were sitting in a CA parlor with the live view of NYC while we were eating. Wonderful experience in all and even my 1 yr old really enjoyed all the veggies from the top of my slice
… more
Ashley Sugrue
The pizza here is AMAZING!! My favorite was the Pink Square and the Sheepshead Bay pizza but I’m sure they’re all just as delicious! Definitely recommend and will be coming back! This is my new favorite pizza spot! This picture is from the day after when I reheated it in my Ninja Foodi and it was just as delicious.
… more
Celia Ferreira
If you want to transform to NY & eat an amazing slice of heaven, this is it. The homemade sauce from this Brooklyn family, the delicious sausage,and the crust from the stone oven are ALL heaven! This is a hidden gem that are not like the equipment hot oven location. Perfect anytime!
… more
Kate Barnes
Very disappointed. Was really looking forward to trying this pizza. Placed our order online, drove to the location for pickup and the entire restaurant was closed. Not a single light on in the place. My husband waited around for a little bit and someone finally came and opened the doors. They said there was an emergency and they had to close. Could they not also close online ordering at the same time the closed the store? We totally get things happen, there are more important things in life that take priority over pizza but there was no effort to make it up to us or anything. When you have a toddler at home and a sick wife, not the most ideal situation and a total waste of time.
… more
Luke W
I screwed up on my lunch, but hey, even USPS employees screw up! Sweet quiet spot to grab a bite of pie! Cool dude. I definitely recommend, and on my first try. Sure beats Philly’s Best where all the guys behind the counter hassle me. And, I’m not exactly high enough on the pay grade level to be driving to Cerritos all the time to get more expensive food. Quality over price though. I’d love to trade in my car or sell it, so I could eat more pizza here. I’m joking. But would be nice. If only we didn’t have to go to work, and I wouldn’t have to drive a car I literally have had forever. Lol.
… more
… View more