Looking for the best pizza in Columbus? Rejoice, you aficionados of all things pizza pie – the seemingly endless search is finally over. From thin crust to deep dish to gluten-free options and beyond, we’ve got you covered. We at Cottage Inn Pizza pride ourselves on serving the downtown Columbus community with superior products using only the finest ingredients available. Not to mention, we’re always listening to our customers to provide the best possible service around. The result? Decadent, delicious, delivery-ready gourmet pizza. Located on North High Street, between West Norwich Avenue and West Lane Avenue makes it easy to enjoy fast and fresh after any Ohio State University Buckeyes game. And we deliver on campus!
Long-running Midwestern chain serving deep-dish & thin-crust pizzas, plus subs, salads & more. Based on 389 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2167 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201
Phone: (614) 564-9292
Website:
Hours
| Wednesday |
10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday |
10 AM–12 AM |
| Friday |
10 AM–2:30 AM |
| Saturday |
10 AM–2:30 AM |
| Sunday |
10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
| Tuesday |
10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Deb Sharrer
Highly disappointed. First time ordering maybe last. Ordered pizza sub with pepperoni, pizza ham and light sauce. Sub was burnt, dripping with sauce, nothing but ham and tasted terrible! Also ordered the apple pizza it too was burnt. Very disappointing!! If I could give it negative stars I would.
… more
Bobbie Daugherty
This was the WORST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD!! This was my 1st and last time to have this pie. I paid 30 bucks for pizza and salad and soda. The salad was 9.00 for a salad my 5 year old would eat alone. The pizza was burnt. The only thing they didn’t ruin was the Pepsi. I’ve had better pizza in a school lunch!
… more
Rochelle Stapp
They have one of the best gluten free pizzas. I personally think that are worth the price and the cost is the same as other local pizza restaurants.
… more
Rocky Ray
I recommend the deep dish. It’s very good. There’s enough toppings to balance it out. If you like pickles, try the Cuban. Really tasty!
… more
Ahmet Karaagac
I never heard this place before i thought it was local but it is franchise but local owner. Very quick, hand made, great taste and like helping local owned businesses and usually service is better than managed by the managers. This location service was great and the guy who served us was actually the owner. While ordering can see where they make the pizza as well and place was spotless very clean location. Now I go here at least once a week. I recomend at least try once and you will be hooked.
… more
Vincent Lam
It is open until late night, and serves friendly with great food.
… more
Jennifer Henthorn
First time ordering. Aside from the fact there was on average 1 pepperoni and 2 pineapple pieces per slice… It tasted good. Not the best crust, pretty bland. It was the lack of toppings that didn’t make it ”gourmet” for me
… more
shawn brink
Great pizza 4toppings 2 sodas 20$. Tues special. Great service
… more
NeCee Glenn
The young girl was friendly and decent pizza. However, the guy Manager was extremely unwelcoming.
… more
Ryan Finke
Great pizza by the slice! $3.75 for 2 slices of pepperoni. Was some of the best pizza I’ve had in Columbus!
… more
… View more
