El Potro Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill Menu – Plainfield, IN

Type : Mexican restaurant

Location : Plainfield, IN

Fajitas, enchiladas & other Mexican dishes pair with margaritas in a festive space with wood booths. Based on 910 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

El Potro Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill 46168

Address:
140 Perry Rd, Plainfield, IN 46168

Phone: (317) 838-9425

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–10 PM

Holiday hours
Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–10:30 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10:30 PM

Menu

Menu
FRIED PICKLES $4.99
MOZZARELLA STICKS $4.99
NACHOS CARBON
Steak, chicken and shrimp on a bed of tortilla chips topped with lettuce, guacamole, pico de gallo and sour cream
$10.99
NACHOS FAJITAS
A bed of chips with seasoned steak or chicken strips with grilled onions, peppers and tomatoes. Finished with a sprinkle of shredded cheese
$9.99
NACHOS SUPREME
Cheese nachos topped with beef, chicken and beans, covered with lettuce, jalapeño, tomatoes, sour cream and guacamole
$9.49
PAPA NACHOS
Grilled chicken, steak and chorizo over a bed of waffle fries with cheese sauce on top
$10.99
NACHO EL POTRO
Cheese nachos topped with beans, chicken, steak, shrimp, chorizo and mushrooms covered with lettuce, tomatoes, guacamole and sour cream
$11.49
NACHOS MONTERREY
Topped with steak, chicken, bacon, chorizo, pico de gallo and jalapeño peppers
$10.99
NACHOS
CHORIQUESO $5.99
BEAN DIP $3.99
GRILLED CHICKEN DIP $5.99
CHICKEN DIP $4.99
BEEF DIP $4.99
SPINACH DIP $4.49
CHEESE DIP $2.99
GUACAMOLE $2.99
GUACAMOLE CASERO
Fresh made! Chunks of avocado mixed with tomato, onion, cilantro, jalapeños, lime and salt
$6.49
SOPA DE POLLO
(Chicken & Rice Soup) Chicken soup with generous strips of chicken, onions, tomatoes, avocado and rice in our seasoned broth. Served with lime wedges
$6.99
TACO SALAD
A crisp flour tortilla with seasoned ground beef or shredded chicken, melted cheese sauce, lettuce, tomato, shredded cheese, guacamole and sour cream
$7.99
MINI TACO SALAD $4.99
GRILLED CHICKEN TOSSED SALAD
Tender strips of marinated chicken breast and lettuce garnished with onions, bell peppers, tomatoes and cheese
$8.49
GRILLED TILAPIA SALAD
Grilled tilapia over lettuce with tomatoes, bell peppers, onions and shredded cheese
$8.99
SHRIMP TACO SALAD
A crisp flour tortilla with shrimp, onions, bell peppers and tomatoes served over lettuce with shredded cheese
$9.99
EL POTRO TACO SALAD
A jumbo tortilla loaded with steak, chicken and shrimp with grilled tomatoes, bell peppers and onions on a bed of lettuce with guacamole, sour cream and tomatoes
$9.99
GUACAMOLE SALAD
Made with guacamole, lettuce and tomato
$3.25
TOSSED SALAD
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, bell peppers and cheese
$2.99
SHRIMP FAJITA QUESADILLA
A mix of shrimp, onions, tomatoes and bell peppers grilled in a jumbo flour tortilla. Served with guacamole, sour cream and pico de gallo
$10.99
QUESADILLA EL POTRO
A jumbo flour tortilla loaded with steak, chicken and chorizo with onions, tomatoes and peppers. Served with lettuce, guacamole, tomatoes and sour cream
$10.99
QUESADILLA HAWAIANA
A jumbo flour tortilla loaded with chicken or steak, pineapple, bacon and mushrooms. Served with lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes
$9.99
FAJITA QUESADILLA
Your choice of steak or grilled chicken cooked with bell pepper, onion and tomato, loaded with cheese into a grilled flour tortilla. Served with rice with lettuce, tomatoes and sour cream
$9.99
QUESADILLA RELLENA
Grilled flour tortilla stuffed with cheese and beans, garnished with lettuce, guacamole, tomato, sour cream, rice and your choice of:
SHRIMP $5.49
GRILLED STEAK $5.49
GRILLED CHICKEN $5.49
GROUND BEEF $4.49
SHREDDED CHICKEN $4.49
CHEESE $2.99
MEXICAN WRAP
A 12″ flour tortilla filled with steak or chicken, rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo and a side of steamed vegetables
$8.99
BURRITO INDIANA
A 12″ flour tortilla filled with grilled steak, chicken, shrimp and beans. Topped with chorizo, melted cheese and pineapple
$10.99
THE BOSS BURRITO
A 12″ flour tortilla filled with steak or chicken, rice, beans, shredded cheese and ranchero sauce. Smothered with melted cheese
$9.99
BURRITO LOCO
Grilled chicken or steak cooked with onions, lettuce, sour cream and guacamole. Served with rice and pico de gallo. Topped with cheese sauce
$10.99
BURRITO SUPREME
Two burritos filled with ground beef or chicken and beans. Topped with cheese, red sauce, lettuce, tomato, special sauce and sour cream
$8.49
BURRITO MEXICANO
A flour tortilla filled with ground beef or shredded chicken topped with cheese, red sauce, lettuce, tomato and sour cream. Served with rice and beans
$8.49
SHRIMP BURRITO
Topped with nacho cheese sauce and served with rice
$8.99
CHEESESTEAK BURRITO
Flour tortilla filled with your choice of steak or chicken cooked with grilled onions with nacho cheese sauce. Served with rice
$8.99
HOT & SPICY BURRITO
With shredded chicken, beef, rice and beans, covered with red sauce, cheese, sour cream and jalapeño
$8.99
BEEF $4.49
BEEF & BEAN $4.49
CHICKEN $4.49
GRILLED STEAK $5.49
GRILLED CHICKEN $5.49
CLASSIC CHIMICHANGAS
Two chimichangas filled with shredded beef or chicken, topped with cheese sauce and served with rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream and pico de gallo
$9.99
SHRIMP CHIMICHANGA
A jumbo flour tortilla stuffed with grilled shrimp, onions, tomatoes and peppers, deep-fried to a golden brown and topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream and pico de gallo
$11.49
FAJITA CHIMICHANGA
A jumbo flour tortilla filled with your choice of steak or grilled chicken cooked with onions, tomatoes and bell peppers, deep-fried and topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream and pico de gallo
$11.49
SHRIMP ENCHILADAS
Grilled shrimp sizzled up with onions, rolled into three corn tortillas, and topped with nacho cheese sauce. Served with rice and beans
$10.99
ENCHILADAS MEXICANAS
Three shredded chicken enchiladas topped with nacho cheese and red or green sauce. Served with rice and beans
$8.99
ENCHILADAS RANCHERAS
Four enchiladas – one cheese, one beef, one chicken and one bean – all topped with red sauce, shredded cheese, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and guacamole
$8.99
ENCHILADAS HAWAIANAS
Three grilled chicken enchiladas topped with nacho cheese sauce, chorizo sausage and pineapple. Served with rice and beans
$9.49
CHIMI CHEESECAKE
Cheesecake wrapped in a tortilla, fried crisp and dusted with cinnamon sugar. Served with vanilla ice cream with chocolate and strawberry syrup
$4.99
FLAN (MEXICAN CUSTARD)
Traditional Mexico City-style creme caramel, baked fresh daily
$2.99
SOPAPILLA
Flour tortilla deep-fried to a golden brown and topped with honey, butter and cinnamon
$2.99
FRIED ICE CREAM $4.99
FRIED BANANA
Served with ice cream
$4.99
CHURROS $4.99
TACOS DE CARNITAS
Filled with pork
$8.99
TACOS DE CHORIZO
Filled with Mexican sausage
$8.99
TACOS DE AZADA
Filled with steak
$8.99
TACOS DE PASTOR
Filled with a mix of steak, chorizo and pineapple in our special sauce
$8.99
TACOS LOCOS
Three tacos filled with steak, chicken and carnitas cooked with onions and special sauce
$8.99
TACOS AL CARBON
Three tacos filled with steak, chicken and shrimp cooked with onions and our special sauce
$8.99
FISH TACOS
Three tacos filled with grilled tilapia, fresh onions, cilantro, cabbage and our special sauce
$8.99
TEXAS FAJITAS
Steak, chicken and shrimp
SHRIMP FAJITAS
SPECIAL EL POTRO FAJITAS
Pork, chorizo, shrimp, chicken and steak
CHICKEN OR STEAK FAJITAS
VALLARTA FAJITAS
Scallops, shrimp, onions and mushrooms
HAWAIANA FAJITAS
Steak or chicken with mushrooms, bacon and pineapple. Topped with shredded cheese
SUPER POTRO
Our delicious T-bone steak with chicken breast and shrimp on a bed of tomatoes and peppers. Served with rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo and tortillas
$18.99
STEAK VAQUERO
T-bone steak cooked with shrimp, onions and mushrooms, topped with cheese and chipotle sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas
$14.99
T-BONE STEAK MEXICANO
Our T-bone steak topped with sautéed tomatoes, onions and jalapeño peppers. Served with Mexican rice, refried beans and tortillas
$12.99
T-BONE STEAK CHARRO
Our delicious T-bone steak topped with bacon and mushrooms. Served with rice, refried beans and flour tortillas
$14.99
JUANITO SPECIAL
Our T-bone steak hot off the grill, topped with shrimp, onions, mushrooms and cheese. Served with rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, pico de gallo, sour cream and tortillas
$16.99
CARNE AZADA
Thinly cut ribeye steak cooked with onions, rice, beans, lettuce, pico de gallo, guacamole and tortillas
$12.99
STEAK RANCHERO
Our T-bone steak with ranchero sauce, rice and beans with flour tortillas
$12.99
CARNITAS EL POTRO
Chunks of pork tenderloin with onions and jalapeño peppers topped with shredded cheese, rice, beans, guacamole salad and tortillas
$10.99
ARROZ CON CARNITAS
Shredded pork on a bed of rice, smothered with white cheese sauce
$9.99
CARNITAS VERDES
Pork with your choice of red or green homemade sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas
$9.99
POLLO ALEGRE
Grilled chicken breast with grilled shrimp and sautéed onions, smothered with white cheese sauce and served with rice, beans and tortillas
$11.49
POLLO EL POTRO
Tender chicken breast topped with bacon and onions, smothered with white cheese sauce and served with rice, beans and tortillas
$11.49
KAREN’S SPECIAL
Juicy grilled chicken strips with grilled shrimp, served on a bed of rice and topped with white cheese sauce
$10.99
ARROZ CON POLLO
Juicy grilled chicken strips covered with cheese sauce and served on a bed of rice
$10.25
POLLO SANTA FE
Grilled chicken breast cooked with onions, mushrooms and pineapple, topped with shredded cheese and served with steamed vegetables
$10.25
POLLO LOCO
Chicken breast cooked with spinach and topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas
$10.25
POLLO CON PIÑA
Chicken strips cooked with pineapple and chorizo sausage, topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas
$11.49
POLLO AZADO
Grilled chicken breast served with rice, beans, guacamole salad and flour tortillas
$10.25
CHORI POLLO
Grilled chicken breast topped with chorizo and cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas
$10.25
ROCKY’S SPECIAL
Chicken grilled strips cooked with mushrooms, onions, rice and shredded cheese
$10.25
FIESTA POLLO
Chicken grilled strips cooked with mushrooms, onions and creamy cheese chipotle sauce. Served with rice and beans
$10.25
CHILAQUILES MEXICANO
Your choice of red or green salsa. Topped with chicken, steak or two eggs, cheese, sour cream and fresh onions
$11.99
CAMARONES POTRO
A tasty combination of grilled shrimp, scallops, onions, spinach, chipotle peppers and cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans and a sour cream salad
$12.99
CAMARONES A LA DIABLA
Succulent shrimp cooked with onion in our spicy red diabla sauce, served with rice, beans and a sour cream salad
$12.99
TILAPIA VALLARTA
Grilled tilapia fillets teamed up with grilled shrimp and topped with mushrooms, onions and chipotle sauce. Served over a bed of rice with tortillas
$12.99
SHRIMP DELIGHT
Deep-fried shrimp served on a bed of lettuce with pico de gallo and rice
$11.99
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
A light and delicious meal of broiled shrimp served in a margarita glass swimming in a spicy tomato broth accented with avocado, onions and cilantro
$12.99
ARROZ CON CAMARONES
Grilled shrimp with onions, mushrooms and chipotle sauce. Served with a sour cream salad, pico de gallo, rice, beans and warm tortillas
$12.99
ONE TACO, TWO ENCHILADAS AND RICE $8.25
ONE TACO, ONE ENCHILADA, RICE AND BEANS $8.25
ONE ENCHILADA, ONE TACO, AND ONE CHILE RELLENO $8.25
ONE TACO, ONE ENCHILADA AND ONE TOSTADA WITH BEEF AND CHEESE $8.25
ONE BEEF, ONE CHEESE ENCHILADA SERVED WITH RICE AND BEANS $8.25
ONE ENCHILADA, ONE CHEESE QUESADILLA AND RICE $8.25
ONE ENCHILADA, ONE CHILE RELLENO, RICE AND BEANS $8.25
ONE ENCHILADA, ONE TAMALE, RICE AND BEANS $8.25
THREE TACOS SERVED WITH RICE AND BEANS $8.25
ONE BURRITO, ONE TACO AND ONE ENCHILADA $8.25
ONE CHILE RELLENO, ONE BEEF & CHEESE TOSTADA AND BEANS $8.25
ONE BURRITO, ONE CHILE RELLENO AND BEANS $8.25
ONE BURRITO, ENCHILADA AND TAMALE $9.25
ONE BURRITO, ONE TACO, RICE AND BEANS $9.25
ONE BURRITO, ONE TACO AND ONE CHILE RELLENO $9.25
ONE BURRITO, ONE TACO AND ONE BEEF & CHEESE TOSTADA $9.25
ONE BURRITO, ONE ENCHILADA AND ONE CHILE RELLENO $9.25
TWO TAMALES, RICE AND BEANS $9.25
ONE QUESADILLA, ONE TACO, RICE AND BEANS $9.25
MAKE YOUR OWN COMBINATION
Choose any three items plus rice and beans
$10.25
VEGGIE FAJITA
Sizzling vegetables including onions, tomatoes, broccoli, bell peppers and mushrooms. Served with rice, beans, salad and tortillas
$9.99
VEGGIE QUESADILLA
Filled with grilled onions, spinach and mushrooms served with a salad, rice and beans
$7.99
CHILES POBLANOS
Two poblano peppers stuffed with cheese, covered with ranchero sauce and served with rice and beans
$9.25
VEGGIE BURRITO
A burrito filled with peppers, onions, tomatoes and mushrooms, topped with nacho cheese, lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes. Served with rice
$7.99
HARD SHELL TACOS
SOFT SHELL TACOS
BEEF ENCHILADAS
Topped with cheese and red sauce
CHICKEN ENCHILADAS
CHEESE ENCHILADAS
BEAN ENCHILADAS
SHREDDED BEEF ENCHILADAS
TAMALE
CHILE POBLANO
CHILE RELLENO
MEXICAN RICE $1.99
CHEESY RICE $3.99
REFRIED BEANS $1.99
CORN OR FLOUR TORTILLAS (3) $0.99
FRENCH FRIES $2.25
PICO DE GALLO $0.99
JALAPEÑO PEPPERS $0.99
DICED TOMATOES $0.99
CHOPPED ONIONS $0.99
AVOCADO $1.99
LETTUCE $0.99
SOUR CREAM $0.99
CHICKEN SANDWICH
Grilled chicken breast with cheese garnished with lettuce, tomato, onions and pickles. Served with fries
$6.99
CHICKEN FINGERS
Lightly breaded and deep-fried golden brown. Served with fries
$6.99
BACON CHEESEBURGER
Ground beef patty topped with crispy bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions and pickles. Served with fries
$6.99
12-OZ. RIBEYE STEAK
A generous cut of ribeye, served with fries
BURRITO
With rice and beans
$4.99
BEEF BURRITO & TACO $4.99
TACO & ENCHILADA $4.99
ENCHILADA
With rice & beans
$4.99
MINI BEEF NACHOS $4.99
CHICKEN FINGERS & FRIES $4.99
CHEESEBURGER
With lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles on the side. Served with fries
$4.99
CHEESE QUESADILLA
Served with fries
$4.99
HOT DOG & FRIES $4.99
CORN DOG & FRIES $4.99
Bar Menu
FLAVORED MARGARITAS
Strawberry • Raspberry • Peach • Mango • Banana • Piña Colada22-oz., 27-oz., 46-oz., 60-oz., pitcher.
TEXAS MARGARITAS
Made with Gold Jose Cuervo Special. Available in 22-oz., 27-oz., 46-oz., 60-oz., pitcher
TRADITIONAL LIME HOUSE MARGARITAS
Taste the tradition in every sip! Available in 22-oz., 27-oz., 46-oz., 60-oz., pitcher
EL POTRO TOP SHELF MARGARITAS
We will be happy to make your margarita with top shelf tequila for an additional charge. Choose reposado or añejo tequila.
SANGRITA
Two great tastes in one drink! Tequila with a splash of sangria
SKINNY MARGARITA
Made with reposado tequila, triple sec, fresh lime and orange juice. Low in calories!
MARGARONA
Double down on this refreshing drink – a beer in a margarita
FRUITY DAIQUIRIS
Strawberry • Raspberry • Peach • Mango • Piña Colada • Banana16-oz., 27-oz., 46-oz.
NON-ALCOHOLIC DAIQUIRI
Try this family-friendly drink in your favorite flavor: Strawberry • Peach • Mango • Piña Colada
DRAFT BEER
12-oz., 22-oz., 32-oz., Pitcher. Ask your server for our selection
BOTTLED IMPORTS
DOMESTIC
WINE
SOFT DRINKS
Coke, Cherry Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Fanta Orange, Root Beer Hi-C Pink Lemonade
ICED TEA
Sweetened or unsweetened
HOT TEA
HOT CHOCOLATE
JUICE
Orange, cranberry, apple, pineapple (No free refills)
MILK OR CHOCOLATE MILK
(No free refills)
MEXICAN SODA
Jarritos (No free refills)
HORCHATA
(No free refills)
Lunch Menu
LUNCH ARROZ CON POLLO $6.99
HUEVOS MEXICANOS $6.25
HUEVOS RANCHEROS $6.25
HUEVOS CON CHORIZO $6.50
HUEVOS DIVORCIADOS $6.25
LUNCH FAJITA
Grilled chicken or steak cooked with onions, peppers and tomatoes, served with rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo and tortillas
$7.50
SHRIMP TACO SALAD
A crisp flour tortilla with shrimp, onions, bell peppers and tomatoes served over lettuce with shredded cheese
$6.99
TACO SALAD
A crisp flour tortilla with seasoned ground beef or shredded chicken, melted cheese sauce, lettuce, tomato, shredded cheese and sour cream
$6.49
SHRIMP DELIGHT
Deep-fried shrimp served on a bed of lettuce with pico de gallo and rice
$6.99
ACAPULCO LUNCH
Steak or chicken rolled in a flour tortilla with onions, topped with cheese sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and sour cream. Served with rice
$6.49
BURRO LA ROQUETA
Tender pork burrito topped with melted cheese sauce and pico de gallo. Served with rice
$6.49
LUNCH CHIMICHANGA
Filled with shredded beef or chicken, deep-fried and topped with cheese sauce and served with rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream and pico de gallo
$6.49
ONE TACO, ONE ENCHILADA AND CHOICE OF RICE OR BEANS $5.50
CHILE RELLENO, TACO, GUACAMOLE SALAD AND BEANS $5.50
BEEF BURRITO, RICE AND BEANS $5.50
ENCHILADA, RICE AND BEANS $5.50
CHILE RELLENO, TACO, RICE AND BEANS $5.50
BURRITO, TACO AND RICE $5.50
FRIED BURRITO, RICE AND BEANS $5.50
CHEESE QUESADILLA AND TWO BEEF TACOS $5.50
BURRITO, TAMALE AND RICE $5.50
TWO TACOS, RICE AND BEANS $5.50
STEAK OR CHICKEN FAJITA QUESADILLA, RICE AND BEANS $6.50
SHRIMP FAJITA QUESADILLA WITH A SOUR CREAM SALAD $6.50
GRILLED CHICKEN & SPINACH QUESADILLA WITH SOUR CREAM SALAD $6.50
SHRIMP ENCHILADA WITH CHEESE SAUCE, RICE AND BEANS $6.50
GRILLED CHICKEN OR STEAK QUESADILLA WITH SOUR CREAM SALAD $6.50
HOT & SPICY BURRITO $6.50
ONE DEEP FRIED PORK TAMAL
COVERED WITH GREEN SAUCE, CHEESE SAUCE, LETTUCE, TOMATO AND SOUR CREAM
$6.50

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ellen Vakhnova
We love this place. Everyone does in our family. We keep coming here. I love veggie nachos and lime margarita. My boys usually try different food. Excellent service, delicious dishes. We enjoy.

… more

Sarah Pomeroy
We loved El Cerrito, so we were skeptical to try El Potro. I wish we had come in sooner! The quesa birria tacos were *amazing*. So much better than the Americanized Mexican food I’m used to at other restaurants in Indiana. Will definitely be back!

… more

Cassandra Mosby
Great food and service! Food came out hot and was very good.

… more

Clarence Payne
First visit, I will be back. This might be my new favorite Mexica Restaurant.

… more

Jenni Rebennack
We went here today for lunch. They did not have my favorite meals on the menu, so I went with a taco salad. Let me tell you, this place was so clean. The server was super attentive and that was by far the best taco salad I’ve ever had. The chips were fresh and the salsa was sooo good. Do yourself a favor and visit this place.

… more

Greg Eakins
This is some pretty decent Mexican/Texmex food. The interior aesthetic is really cool here – all sorts of wood and pictures of horses.

… more

Patricia Proffitt
The food was excellent. A little pricey in my opinion. Loved the wooden interior, tables, and chairs.

… more

Tonie James
First time visit for lunch with my sister. Pleasant waitress was served hot chips and salsa fairly quickly. Food was okay kinda bland need more spice and heat asked for spicier salsa which helped the flavor profile.

… more

Alex Cross
Delicious Mexican food! I have the Hawaiian quesadilla and it was very unique and absolutely wonderful. The decor was nice as well and the different weight staff were helpful. The portion sizes were large and overall I felt it was a good value. I would definitely return!

… more

Kyle Matson
Food here is absolutely amazing! These meals are like $10 each and so well worth it. You’re going to get filled up with servings like these. Flavors are outstanding. They were very busy, but we’re treated like VIPs. Can’t say enough good about this place. Definitely eat here if you’re into Mexican food.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions