Based on 168 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
514 N Illinois Rte 31, McHenry, IL 60050
Phone: (815) 578-1111
Website: http://www.antiochpizzashop.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brian M
We have ordered from them previously for they were the only half way decent pizza place in the area, which isn’t saying much. Over priced for about average food. Last time we ordered a pan pizza, the young, inexperienced driver must have transported it on an angle, for the cheese was sliding off of the top and into the box. Wrote it off as a fluke. Ordered the same cheese pizza two days ago and what you see in the photo is what we got for just over $40 delivered. Same driver brought the pizza over 20 minutes late, pizza was cold, and I mean cold, no apology, and when we opened it, this is what we got. Most of the cheese on the now cold pizza was slid off into the box, grease all over, and it was covered completely in sausage. Due to dietary restrictions we are unable to eat sausage. We ended up throwing it away. When we called, the so called manager offered a gift card, which didn’t even cover the tax, delivery fee, or tip. He blamed the incorrect order on a trainee. We asked for a refund, have asked two more times since in writing and they won’t even reply. Very unprofessional management and poor service here. Now having to dispute the charge on the credit card. Will never order from them again. What a waste of $40 on something we couldn’t even eat. Try at your own risk.
… more
Grant Fifield
I went there in the evening after pulling an on call job during the dinner hour. I loved the price point 2 pizza slices and a large drink cup for $7. Also, I,like just about every other reviewer had the sausage pizza. Chunks of sausage were big, which I like. The pizza itself was not the thinnest I’ve ever had but it was not bad by any stretch of the imagination. Will definitely go again if in the area.
… more
Jolene Hall
Awful and beyond! This place is a hard pass for me and my entire family of 5… I have had pizza from all over the country; Mom and Pop shops, small chain locations, large commercial names. As far as this region we’ve tried everyone, this is hands down and hands up to heaven the worst “pizza” I have ever eaten, that includes frozen from the grocery aisle & public school rectangle pizza… The cheese had no creaminess or flavor, like several melted sticks of string cheese, the sauce was pureed tomato, no spices, more watery liquid than substance, the sausage looked to be quartered slices of link sausage and the pepperoni had very little flavor outside of fat. I’m beyond confused about what I just ate, but I’m pretty certain my body will reject it twice as hard as my tastebuds did. Good God…
… more
Jo jo
No welcome when I entered the store…two young ladies absolutely speechless. After initiating a hello and what I was there for the only word from them was the total. I said have a good night and not one of the two responded. I would be done with your business for that. In addition, the fries came with no silverware on a takeout order and the fries were not cooked all the way and were mushy. The pizza was burnt in the edges and lacked sauce. For real it lacked sauce. Just crust, cheese and sausage.
… more
ban9erang
Ordered an XL double decker and it was undercooked to say the least. I don’t have much to say other than that. You can tell the ingredients are good but when I’m chewing on undercooked dough for $35 you don’t really have much to say.
… more
Nanette Kuretski
We ordered a Chicago Style pizza. The service we received from our phone order to pick up was such a delightful experience. The girls were extremely competent and friendly.
… more
S Madi
Ordered a supreme double decker. Great flavor. Liked how the veggies were sliced.
… more
Corey Barnard
Worst pizza I’ve ever been delivered… the entire outside of my $40 pizza was burnt to a crisp and inedible. The whole outside crust was reduced to flakes that collected in the corner of the box. The, still edible, center of the pizza was swimming in grease and was sopping wet and soggy. Not even the ingredients used were quality, sausage had hard and very chewy spots for unknown reasons. I would never order again and would go out of my way to tell others to do the same. I would rather they told me they destroyed my pizza than to bring me this monstrosity. Very bad look on the company as a whole.
… more
Rebecca Sage
Conveniently, or too conveniently, located near where I work, which makes for an easy stop off for lunch. The $6 “2 slices and a drink” makes for a quick lunch. Pay an extra 50¢ per daily specialty slice, which is a great way to try their specialty pizzas without the commitment of a full pizza.
… more
Michael Bryan
Pizza in the name can throw you off. Of course it’s top of line pizza but the burger is top notch. Could also be strictly an ice cream parlor the way they rotate ice creams. Highly recommended for anytime you want delivery or take out.
… more
… View more