Based on 46 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2347 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Phone: (716) 836-9758
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5–10 PM |
| Thursday | 5–10 PM |
| Friday | 5–11 PM |
| Saturday | 5–11 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
veronica scordato
The absolute best! PHENOMENAL STAFF! Fantastic PIZZA! Creative Craft Cocktails! Rotating Craft Beers! Incredible atmosphere! Very welcoming! Recommend this place to everyone!
… more
S Burns
My first attempt to get pizza here was a fail. Told a 3 hr wait. Honestly the pizza wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t anything special. Specifically the crust was very basic and lacked flavor. Some dark spots, but likely unavoidable because of the cooking method. I plan on returning to try another pizza. The serving size was small for two adults to share. Would definitely get an appetizer or wings on the side next time.
… more
Kelly Colwell
Seriously, treat yourself & spend a night out here. Where to begin…the bartender’s & wait staff are top notch professionals who know their beer/liquors (shout out to the Thursday night crew!!)
… more
Drew
I might leave my husband for this pizza?
… more
Jackie Slattery
This pizza was ridiculously good. We had the Candyman pie and some meatballs. Loved the dry cider with dinner and had a peanut butter stout after and after the spice of the pizza it was like that one beer was a dessert!
… more
Christina Danley
Ghost kitchen for Caputi’s Pub. Ordering online was easy, and food was ready upon arrival. Staff was polite. I got the Candyman pizza with extra cheese and honey. The pepperoni’s were the nice spicy cupped ones, and the honey was the perfect accompaniment to the spicy chili’s they put on there. For a wood fired pizza it wasn’t bad, but I have had better. The crust was a bit overdone. Overall a good solid pizza.
… more
Rodney Houston
I just happened to be in western New York on vacation. So I asked Google for the best pizza in New York. Candyman pizza came up and it didn’t disappoint! The pizza candyman style was the most awesome pizza I’ve ever had the pleasure to taste. The crust and dough were perfect! The taste….OMG!! The honey and pepper drizzle put this pizza on a whole different level. They also had the best wings! Perfect combination of savory flavor and crunch! Please do yourself a favor and order you a pie candyman style with their barbecue wings! You’ll be glad you did! We need one of these places in the DC area!!
… more
Louiza Case-Drmacich
Such a cool place. Service was great and the pizzas were delicious. The crust was amazing. I got the Candyman pizza and my husband got the meatball pizza. Wonderful experience and will definitely be back again.
… more
Dan Cog
Hands down some of the best pizza in this area. Definitely one of my favorites. We’ve tried every option on the menu and all of them were fantastic. You can tell that the ingredients are fresh and they are cooked to perfection. The staff is also top notch and it’s a real relaxed environment.
… more
Tara Raftovich
Look no further – Candyman has the best pizza in the city! Literally the best dough ever made and absolutely addicted to their creative take on pizza toppings. Delicious appetizers and an extensive drink selection. Great atmosphere and the music is always spot on!
… more
… View more