Based on 896 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
102 E Madison St, Lake Mills, WI 53551
Phone: (920) 648-2985
Website: http://www.elmariachiwi.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Melissa Miller
As soon as I walked in… it smells delicious! The atmosphere is light and fun. Wait staff was a bit busy (dining room was full) but they definitely help each other out and make sure you’re not waiting around. And the food… the food was so good!!! It’s literally the best Mexican food we’ve ever had! Absolutely check it out, and check out the quesabirria it’s life changing this is our new favorite Mexican food restaurant for sure! Flavor is phenomenal, presentation is on point and drinks are bomb.. 10/10
… more
Adam Debt
Went here for the first time tonight, we were seated promptly but forgotten about for 15 minutes. Ordered and the food came in a reasonable amount of time. I had a fajitas and the person that brought the food out forgot to bring tortillas. Our server didn’t stop by once to see how we were doing, ask if we needed a refill or if everything was OK. Food was good buy service was less than satisfactory.
… more
Christin Shouse
I understand English may not be someone’s first language, but if you’re going to run a register and take orders you should be able to understand what we’re ordering.
… more
Steve Burek
Stopped here when we were looking at a car. Nice place, and the food was authentic. If we’re out here again we will definitely be back.
… more
Tonya
It’s your average small town Mexican food joint. I think the food/service is good and have never had a bad experience. I love the chimichangas. Prices are decent and staff is friendly. The menu is large so there’s options for everyone. The house margaritas are nice and strong too! You can always go across the street to the park and walk off your shame afterwards. It’s a smaller place, but I definitely recommend trying it.
… more
Jessica Pickel
Prices have gone up, service drastically down. The food quality was sub par, all three of our dinners were poor quality and burnt. Incredibly disappointed in how much this place has gone down in the last year.
… more
KellyAnne Tynan
Went there for dinner with coworkers. They had a child wait our table. Literally. I pointed to the margarita drink special and said this is what I want. Eventually I had two of those. Then my bill showed two full price margaritas. I had to argue with them three times. They said I was given mediums, so the charges were valid, but I told them what they gave me wasn’t my fault. I requested specifically the margarita special. I don’t know what size the glasses are, that’s not my problem. Each drink should have been $4.75. So they took $4.50 off my bill. I said no $4.50 off $18.00 is not what I ordered. Finally the guy grabbed my ticket and redid it. My friend had gotten the $1.00 off margaritas, which they didn’t give her, and she didn’t want to argue with them. But I will try to avoid this place from now on.
… more
Pramod Koli (Pbkoli)
Nice food and great service. We ordered chicken fajitas and qasadilla. The food was amazing. This is located in the heart of lake Mills and can be reached in 25 minutes from Madison. They have options of house margaritas, they were good too. Kids loved the food too. Will visit again
… more
Marla Neumann
Came here based on great reviews from customers and fair prices. We were pleasantly surprised by the look of the restaurant on the inside, as it had a fun feel to it. Enjoyed the Wednesday special half priced margaritas and the burritos were delicious as well.
… more
Peggy Leclaire
The atmosphere is fine. Order was taken quickly. My friend got her meal and mine didn’t come, about 10 minutes went by until the waiter walked by and seen that I didn’t have anything. Brought my burrito out about 5 minutes later and the steak was way over cooked/some burnt, hard, it was like jerky. We ordered a pitcher of raspberry margaritas and they tasted like a slushy, I think they forgot to put the tequila in. Waiter never came back once to ask how are meal was or if we needed anything. $70>
… more
… View more