Based on 227 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
499-27 Sunrise Hwy, Patchogue, NY 11772
Phone: (631) 447-1133
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ec Borges
Pizza is my favorite food, so I am always on the lookout for new places to go to. I tried a few of their specialty slices, and they are pretty good. This one is close to home, so I go there a lot just for their shrimp slices. By far, their shrimp pizza is the best around. My favorite is the vodka pesto shrimp. If you like seafood, this is the place to go for shrimp pizza. The service was good, and the atmosphere was ok. Maybe it needs a little updated decor. It is not a fancy restaurant, just “The pizzaria next door”. It looks clean, and it smells really good inside. I have met the owner and he is very nice. It is difficult for me to give a 5 star bcs every Pizzaria is better at a certain type of pizza. Overall, it was a great place to go. I always have a pleasant time in there. They also came up with a very cool idea for the tip jar, which I included a picture of. You deserve the tip just for the effort.
… more
Madelyn C
Wow. You may think why rate a simple slice of pizza?! Let me share. I had a simple cheese pizza slice. The crust was perfect. Not bland not salty, not too cheesy, not too saucy, not too thick, not too thin, not overkill. The sauce was not bland, not salty nor watered down. Each bite was tasty. You can taste each ingredient in each bite. Not everyone can make pizza these days and many short change the ingredients where it loses its taste and quality. No wonder it’s called Nonna’s Pizzeria. Only Nonna can get this sauce perfect. Thank you Nonna. The girls that work there were super nice. If you’re in this shopping center or anywhere near, you gotta come by and check it out. Next time, I’ll order a pasta dish. Was worth the round trip hour and 10 minute drive for me for sure. Ciao Italia ☺️ Blessings…
… more
Roberta Delio
I love Nonna’s!! Food is so good!! Best part is the staff! I bring my Buddy there and they have gotten to know him . He has his own table (like the Godfather lol) and I want to give a shout out to Paulette who serves my buddy warm, not burning hot pizza!! She always remembers 🙂 I’m very grateful!!! Thank you. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
… more
Barry Kadane
I normally go to Valentina’s across the street but not anymore. I had the Dinner Dish Chicken Guiseppe and a shrimp specialty slice and it was by far the best dish i have ever tasted. Even there pizza was way above par with Generous Toppings with the shrimp. This is my new spot for Italian Dinners and Pizza.
… more
Jay Abra
My wife and I ordered delivery on Uber Eats. I got a meatball hero and she got the penne a la vodka. The food came hot and was very tasty. It totaled 31.86 before tip. We would order from again.
… more
Milly Millz
The garlic knots are perfect, with the right amount of garlic. The pizza is delicious too. Will be coming back.
… more
Christina Cordivari
We used to love this place and we were regulars. We wanted to order for my sons birthday for all of our friends and family. We were told to call the morning of when they open at 11am. The website also says they open at 11am. When we called 11:05, someone (probably the owner) answered and said “WE DONT OPEN TILL 11:30, DONT CALL TILL THEN” and hung up without letting me get a word in. I proceeded to call back to let them know of the big order we wanted to place to be ready for pick up at 12 and he continued to answer the phone and hang up. I’ve never experienced such terrible customer service. Luckily, valentinos across the street was open, and went above and beyond in our expectations, price, and hospitality. We are never going back to Nonnas considering they almost ruined my sons first birthday party. Please save yourself and go to Valentino’s!!! So much better.
… more
Thomas Murphy
Best slice in town. Sauce is great, slight sweetness. perfect amount of cheese, not overly salty. Dough has perfect taste and an almost fluffy texture. 9.5/10! They even went out of their way to accommodate me and my guests! Thanks guys!
… more
Sean Coffey
I wish they had half stars… Because a 5 in my head is perfect… And very few of us ever attain perfection.
… more
M M
They sold me progresso can soup and charged me close to $7 for it! NEVER AGAIN! and the older counter guy is so cocky and rude.
… more
… View more