Based on 191 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2258 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209
Phone: (614) 817-1099
Website: http://www.newfangledkitchen.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–5 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ryan Finke
If you get a meatloaf sandwich, get ready for some serious meat. Great portions for the price. We got a portabella mushroom sandwich too (no meatloaf) and it was also very good.
… more
Patty Coss
We love this place! It’s a must-stop every time we head north to Ohio.
… more
James Fox
Love this place. I had “The Fang” and my wife had the “Bella Donna”. Both sandwiches were incredible. Never thought a meatloaf sandwich could be that good. The sandwiches here punch way above their weight. Bravo to Newfangled Kitchen for providing fresh ingredients, tons of flavor, and great service. Can’t wait to try more on their menu.
… more
Rachel Livingston
I always have a great experience when I get take out from here. The sandwiches are great, they really don’t skimp on anything, which has become a rare thing lately. And everything at such a reasonable price point. They seem to use really great quality ingredients. The food is very consistent, great every time. I usually get the Turkey Rueben, I can’t remember the name atm but it’s so good!! I also love the dill potato salad. Probably one of the best potato salads out there. I recently tried the tuna melt which was amazing!
… more
Marshawn Ford
The reviews were RIGHT surprisingly never heard of this joint till browsing uber eats and it might be the best sandwich joint I’ve had in columbus don’t know when I’ll try their meatloaf sandwiches but this sandwich was full of fresh ingredients and made amazing and gets you FULL actually taste like real fresh food and not fast food definitely my new go too
… more
Steve Bertman
This place has become a goto quick meal for me and the family. Reasonably priced, the sandwiches are very filling, and the salads are generous as well. If you like your spicier selection, try Lucifer’s hammer. The service here has always been friendly and they have been very accommodating with custom orders. I am very happy to have them as a local food option.
… more
Scott Doran
An unfortunate decision to try Newfangled Kitchen today. I ordered a sandwich and asked for a glass of water. Was told they don’t want to provide a glass of water but I was welcome to buy an overpriced plastic bottle of water. I suggested that it would be preferable not to use a plastic bottle and I just wanted a glass. I was then quickly refused service and told to leave by one of the grumpy owners. I did. Just one of the weirdest interactions I have ever had with a restaurant.
… more
Skylar Shane
Just got takeout and wow. So good.
… more
Mike Holewinski
Incredibly delicious sandwiches! Tried your sandwiches as an option for a family birthday celebration. Huge portions, most of us were full after half a sandwich! Shared bites with each other, not a mediocre sandwich in the bunch! Loved “The Fang”, we’ll definitely be back for more. Thank you!
… more
Julia C
Super tasty meatloaf sandwiches! The fang is like a cheeseburger but with meatloaf as the patty and the swiss shrooms sandwich was our favorite tho with double melted cheese and rye toasted.
… more
… View more