Casual pick for pies, cheesesteaks, salads & Italian classics in family-friendly environs with BYOB. Based on 500 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2260 Country Club Rd #107, St Paul, TX 75098
Phone: (972) 941-8167
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Drew Ribar
I saw this place was rated 4.5 stars, and I heard the name before, so I was excited to try this place out. The guy on the phone was enthusiastic and was nice when I came in to pick up the pizza. When I got home, the pizza looked great. Unfortunately, as I picked it up and took a bite, it started to fall apart, and the taste was pretty bland. A highly rated pizza joint should never have glue for cheese that falls off the crust, I’d rather eat little caesars. Only gave this a 2 star because the customer service was good, other than that the pizza was just sad. Garlic knots were OK, but bland. I’m really disappointed.
… more
AJ Forbes
I want to like this place because it’s in a small town and I like giving it back but I just can not. I ordered a Stromboli last night, and it wasn’t edible. The dough wasn’t even cooked…I had to put it in the oven to finish it, but it was ruined by then. I’ve ordered from them in the past, but I tried once again despite my husband’s negative issues. I won’t even go into how unclean the place is, especially the kitchen. The bread is not fresh either! I will never eat here again! I don’t like doing bad reviews, but I’ve given this place 2 years, and I’m still severely disappointed.
… more
M. Reza Zarrinnam
We are new to Lucas and Goodfellas pizza is just down the street.
… more
Ron Alexander
The owner/chef greets as you enter and makes you welcome. The pizza is totally handmade with the freshest ingredients and baked to perfection. The Goodfella’s salad is a delicious meal unto itself: fresh greens, cheese cubes, salami cubes, olives, pepperocinis, tomato slices, ham cubes, with your choice of dressings. Pride in their work and attention to quality is very apparent. A cozy neighborhood dining room and great staff!
… more
Torinoshi Yagi (Tori)
Okay, the customer service is absolutely perfect. The first thing they will say when you order on the phone is, “Goodfellas!” They say it so energetically and wholesomely that it will catch you off guard, and put a smile on your face.
… more
Michael Walenciak
One of our absolute favorite places and the best pizza in Collin County. Big, delicious pizza and great service. The knots are amazing too. Even though we’ve come here for years we’ve never tried calamari here before today, it was extremely delicious. The calzones are giant as well!
… more
Pawandeep Singh
When ordering online I had asked for well done, and when went to pick up the order it was still in oven due to place been busy. But vegetarian pizza was left in bit too long and burnt so owner went out of his way and made extra vegetarian pizza (had to wait at least 20mins there) which i think they took out but early and was little sloppy. But overall, pizza tasted good and they are good people!
… more
kez
great pizza! want to come back to try more soon. i had a takeout order and within 20 minutes it was ready.
… more
Eli Max
It reminded me of the pizzerias back in NY. Best pizza / garlic knots in the area. Owner was really nice food was great.
… more
Lisa
Pizza, spinach pin wheels and spaghetti were delicious. Owner and staff are always very welcoming when you walk in. I have been going there for years.
… more
… View more