Chain pizzeria serving traditional pies & pastas in a no-frills setting. Based on 54 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
Address:
45 E Main St, Westfield, NY 14787
Phone: (716) 326-7827
Reviews
J S
Been coming here for about 6 months now, I don’t even live in this state, but I sure as hell will drive here for this incredible place of deliciousness! I have only ordered pizza from here, so I can only comment on that end, and it is by far the best pizza within driving distance from my house(30 min each way). I eat here multiple times a week and won’t stop anytime soon!
… more
scott wood
Quick friendly service. They took time to come out speak with us about our trip up here. The meatball sub was perfect!!!! Great flavor and the perfect amount of sauce to give it moistness without turning it into a soup sandwich. Waffle fries tasted like Ralleys fries and Arbys curly fries has a baby. Wife loved the new York style pizza and our daughter really enjoyed the beef soft tacos. Prices are very fair also. Would highly recommend for a quick bite while shopping on main street.
… more
Pixie the Bug
This place used to be amazing, but we visited for the first time in years and it really went downhill.
… more
Michelle Newman
I love it here. They never disappoint me. I recommend anything here. The BLT pizza is delicious. We get it every time we’re in town. Definitely recommend this place.
… more
Jared Alonge
A staple of the town, everyone around here knows Jimmy’s pizza. It’s an American/pizzeria establishment, local owned, not a chain so you get real ingredients in the food. It’s mostly for takeout or delivery (in the Westfield area) however there is also a dining area with a 6 tables (no public restroom). The prices are reasonable and on average with even the corporate owned fast food establishments (many of the 12″ subs start at about $6, which is on par with subway in terms of price but has far superior quality than a subway would) I’d suggest the deli sandwiches or submarines, each variation is great, and you can customize almost everything to personal taste. Wings come in a variety of sauces and are offered with special discounts for some of the daily specials. They pair great with the pizzas, which are obviously homemade dough/sauce/everything and the reliability of your favorite menu item tasting perfect is what will keep you coming back for more.
… more
Rp rp
They take NO Pride in their work at all , things are ALWAYS Sloppily Put Together ,Seems you always have to Finish Putting your own Toppings on things. The wings are so salty you need a gallon of water to Force them down. They are WAY Overpriced And the Girl who answers the Phone Has NO Personality at all She is as Dry As Dust. It’s Like ” Yeah, Jimmy’s Pizza..! What do you Want”…? I Really wish some of the other shops and restaurants in the area would get their shyt together and start delivering at least on Some Days of the week. jimmy’s is the ONLY Place in the entire town that does and they know it. this seems to give them the right to charge what they want and serve up whatever Slop For the day they wish. And you either Like it or go without or Eat out. It’s a shame we have so many food shops in town But only ONE Delivers And Kiss BBQ Is Not even worth the time mentioning because Their food is NOT BBQ ,The man has a $750,000 Trailer grill and can’t even roast a hot dog right.
… more
Broadway Joe
Visiting Westfield on business from Pittsburgh, and was looking for somewhere with good wings and a quality cheesesteak to go with a good case of . Needless to say, Jimmy’s came thru (plus they deliver,which was super clutch). Wings were , and the cheesesteak was also . Will definitely order from there again on my next visit, and for that, Jimmy’s gets the 10 beer salute (which is the highest honor on my grading scale) Cheers yinz guys!
… more
Robert Charney
Passing thru Westfield, NY on way home to PA. stopped and dined in for a tuna sub and cheesy fries, that hit the spot. Friendly staff. For a Wednesday eve, that places phone would not stop ringing for takeout orders. Steady flow of takeout customers picking up orders IF I GET BACK THERE SOMETIME IN FUTURE, I WILL KNOW WHERE TO STOP FOR GOOD FOOD!
… more
alena ramirez
Love their food! Torpedo pizza is amazing!!! They also have ox tail roast subs . They put bacon on the Hawaiian pizza and good wings.
… more
Leviathan
This place is pretty bad, got wings and pizza that feel and taste like they are store bought from walmart. Plus one of the wings were ripped open like they checked it with there fingers to see if it was cooked, which it was still not 100 percent cooked.i do not recomend
… more
… View more