A local, family-owned and operated restaurant offering amazingly fresh, delicious, and homemade Neapolitan-style pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, salads and more! Our pizzas and sandwiches are unique because we start with a 3-day cold fermented dough that is hand-tossed. We use only the highest quality and freshest ingredients that we prepare fresh daily.We offer a clean and safe dining experience and a full bar that includes 12 taps serving domestic, craft, and local beers along with hard apple cider from our neighbors at Apple Valley Cider. And for all you sport fans, we offer the NFL Sunday Ticket on our five TV’s!
Based on 383 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
103 Broadway unit 11 / 12, Penrose, CO 81240
Phone: (719) 784-7346
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–8:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Aimee Olson
The Hawaiian pizza isn’t your run of the mill Hawaiian. Bacon, chicken, green onions, and flavorful pineapple! I had their on-tap cider which comes from Apple Valley Cider next door. So good!
… more
Ant Hunny
We just learned of a new pizza place in Penrose and were excited to try it out. We ordered a cheese pizza to start with. The crust was in-between thin and hand tossed. It was delicious. Not too done around the edges and not raw in the center of the pizza. While I like a lot of cheese, the amount on our pizza was perfect. It wasn’t drowning in sauce like some places make it. It had a perfect blend of crust, sauce and cheese. We called ahead and ordered it to be picked up and it was ready to go when we arrived. Highly recommend this pizza place.
… more
Candy Marzec
Ashley has been our waitress several times. She gives great service. Wonderful presentation of good food.
… more
Gaynell Pritts
This place did not disappoint! We have been hearing how great the food was so we drove up from Pueblo to give it a try. They were short staffed and we appreciated the sign on the door so we could decide if we we’re willing to wait. Ashley our waitress was amazing! She never stopped running the entire time we were there. We had the Spyce Girls pizza and it was excellent. The crust was perfect and it was extra spicy as advertised. We will definitely be back.
… more
Cathryn Ullrick
I’ve been there alot since they have opened. The food usually is great, services okay it depends who’s working. Most recently however I had to let the waiter know we were ready to order because they never came back after providing drinks. Than once I got part of my food order I had to get up and ask for napkins and silverware. Was checked on and asked for a refill and the waiter took the cup never brought anything back so had to get up and ask for it. Than waiting for a pizza and hour passed nothing. Asked the waiter said they were checking and came back said it would be done soon. Well 2 hours later got the pizza and it was burnt. Over this time period the waiter said that the Manger was out but would be in shortly. When the Manger did come in they never once came to ask about the service or food issues. Then I over heard the waiter tell the cook the pizza tasted better burnt. I’ve never had bad service there like this ever.
… more
null
The food is amazing and I really enjoy the atmosphere. We order in and take out at least monthly as a treat. A must try if you’re in the area, I’m only sad they quit making their sandwiches, they were my favorite.
… more
Newlon Family
Pizza was tasty. Took over an hour for food to come out. Service was lacking. No refills on water till after we finished eating. She took the cups to refill when she delivered our food. I had to get up and go find someone to ask for water and it still took a while. Waitress seemed irritated to serve us. Very expensive dinner.
… more
Dani Jorgensen
Really great place, especially if you’re just driving through and don’t mind a bit of a wait. They definitely have plenty of signs and stuff posted that the food is worth the wait and they are right!! And tons of creative pizza toppings. So good and we come here for drinks with friends.
… more
Nena Schmidt
You won’t find good food like this anywhere else in Penrose. Literally everything on their menu is delicious. I’m impressed with the interior and quality of the food/presentation. This is one of two places we’ll take guests to when they’re visiting us in Penrose. Service has always been awesome, and I consider it kid and family friendly. What takes the prize is they have gluten-free options which is the main reason we frequent here. I took a star off because every time our family has ordered *takeout* and paid more for gluten-free specific items (mainly pizza), things are forgotten (Example: asked for a GF pizza and got breaded chicken topped all over it. This has never happened in-store. Didn’t realize until we got home and couldn’t eat it, but sure spent a pretty penny to look at it). That aside, I highly recommend this spot and truly think it’s a gift to Penrose.
… more
R Debbie Joy
Very disappointed! Our friends raved about this place! Yes they have very unusual pizza selection. We ordered one with chicken, garlic and artichokes. The artichokes were just a few small leaves. The chicken was sparse and I don’t know where the garlic was. Kind of bland tasting. There were 6 of us and everyone got their pizza quickly except us. Weird. Not sure we would go there again.
… more
… View more