Classic & creative pizzas, subs & calzones fill the menu at this easygoing Italian chain. Based on 27 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery
Address:
10901 NE 23rd St, Nicoma Park, OK 73141
Phone: (405) 987-0533
Website: http://www.simplesimonspizza.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chris Zoski
Went to the Sunday lunch buffet. Can’t believe I drove 25min for this disappointment. Nothing new went out onto the buffet in the 30+min I was there, and some of the pizzas looked like a person who’d been out in the sun for far too long. (Lacked any form of shininess like it was fresh, very dull looking) Don’t get the buffet if it’s set to close in ~45min unless you like old pizza that’s burnt/crunchy & nothing new put out. Have been to other Simple Simon’s buffets (and other pizza buffets) run better than this one looks to be. Don’t have to completely reload the buffet but dear god remove the pizzas that look dull and unappetizing at the least.
… more
T. Johnson
Been to this location 3 or 4 times now since it has opened. Always extremely helpful staff and management, everyone is extremely helpful and ready to fix any issues. One time I ordered too much pizza – was my fault completely and would have been understandable for management to say so. But instead I was able to cancel the second pizza and got a coupon for a free one. Another time we needed no garlic on the crust due to dietary issues. This is always followed and pizza come out perfect. Have had buffet too. It always has fresh, variety of salad options and have always had lot of different pizzas too. When asked to make a certain kind, the staff did it and made sure to keep bringing out other types too. Great place! Oh and bathrooms were nice and clean too.
… more
David Arciniega
Good pizza, better calzones and Stromboli’s in my opinion. For the price you really can’t go wrong. Really friendly staff as well.
… more
Christy Wimer
Amazing service and food has been top notch every time I’ve been here. The buffet has always been fresh and stocked. My kids love the Calizones and it’s a nice, inviting dining area. Would highly recommend for buffet or grabbing pizza on the way home. Their wings are some of my absolute favorites.
… more
Jackie Johnson
Usually, it is a very good selection of pizza and the salad bar is great. But we went in there around 7:15 the salad bar needed to be restocked. There was no tea,no pizza on the buffet. Very disappointing. When ask for tea they said it’s too late.
… more
Jim Tidmore
First time at here and it was great food and great service! Wish there was more booths and a bit more comfortable seating, but that won’t stop us dining in or having delivered! highly recommend, this is Nicoma Park with a really good pizza place!
… more
Jason Green
Great addition to Nicoma Park. Excellent pizza and sandwiches. Buffet is great, and service is excellent! If you are needing pizzas for delivery, they handle that as well, with a large delivery area.
… more
Billy Billings
Food was not that great. A bit under cooked, service was helpful. Fun game room. Better pizza establishments available.
… more
Brent Shade
Decided to try this place for the first time. Ordered 2 pizzeria style pizzas and got 2 thin crust pizzas. The garlic bread sticks were very bland, not a hint of garlic and somehow even the cheese on them had no flavor. Very odd! I likely won’t be ordering from here again
… more
Heather Andrews
Great pizza, great owners. Some of these reviews are sad, you can tell there’s no pleasing some. Love this place
… more
… View more