Housed in a converted gas station since 2004, Pizza 51 serves large, made-to-order slices, whole pies and calzones from freshly made, hand-tossed dough. Additional offerings include sandwiches, salads, and frosty beverages. Dine inside for a full view of the open kitchen’s action or catch local sports on the many tv’s while dining al fresco on the large, partially covered patio.
Vibrant haunt in a former garage serving thin-crust pizza, sandwiches & beer, plus an outdoor patio. Based on 838 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5060 Oak St, Kansas City, MO 64112
Phone: (816) 531-1151
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Daniel M
Beautiful outdoor spot for a large slice that takes up most of your plate. The pizza was delicious and just the right amount for me. The beer was the correct temperature. Nothing too special, but done well without unnecessary flare…. Which, I guess, IS something special. Stop by to eat and chat or read a good book. I highly recommend.
… more
Asia H.
My son and I visited this restaurant yesterday and I was blown away by their customer service, quality of food, value for the money, attentiveness and sincere attention to detail. Selby is an absolute gem . I mean it, she was bright, cheery and helpful. Her beautiful spirit just envelops you as soon as you walk in the door . She knows the menu inside and out and made great suggestions that took the meal over the top for me. My son and I got a cheese pizza slice with sundried tomatoes, spinach, onions , jalapeños and cream cheese and a pepperoni slice. I also got a side salad . It was heavenly. The food was so good I began to devour it before I could even get a picture. Sorry about that y’all. The crust is thin so you really get to enjoy the toppings. The slices are HUGE. They cut it for you so you can easily pick it up and enjoy. I highly recommend this spot not only for the bomb a#$ pizza (easily one of the best in town) but for the superb customer service and experience they provide. When you pay them a visit tell Selby I said “hey girl hey” and make sure to tip her – she deserves it. Run don’t walk for some of the best pizza ever. You’re welcome!!!!
… more
Mason Stowers
Super super good pizza! Nice location too! The outdoor seating was spacious and breezy, the staff friendly and attentive! Will definitely visit again!
… more
Howie Dern
I came here in search of KC’s best pizza, and because of the Andy Reid recommendation. I ordered a slice of cheese pizza, a calzone, and an order of toasted ravioli. The t-ravs were sausage, and although the breading was seasoned, it was very underwhelming. My calzone looked beautiful, but that’s where it stopped. The center wasn’t even melted, and the sauce was bland. The cheese pizza was just OK, and nothing to write home about. I’m sure others really enjoy this place, so I’m going to say it was maybe just an off-day.
… more
Cooltrucker 1992
I truely believe that they should have MORE than 5 stars but i digress. I personally prefer making everything from the dough to the sauce from scratch and this not only taste homemade but it taste BETTER than homemade!!(if that was a thing). Every time you take a bite, you not only get the same flavor from the original bite but every bite you take takes you on a journey of different flavors. I could go on and on about the pizza but the other thing you should come here for is the employees/atmosphere. The employees (and owner) will treat you like family as if you’re coming into your own mothers kitchen. Where you get love, conversation, and good food!!! I have plenty more i can say but I not only suggest but URGE you to come try them out today. Ask for the owner because not only is he a wonderful family man and working hard to provide for them but he’ll treat you like he’s your brother or sister. It’s definitely worth a shot. I come from Overland Park Kansas just for the good food and good conversation as well as the family atmosphere. You won’t be disappointed!!!
… more
april harrington
My nephew and I have decided to start trying different pizza places all around KC. We decided Pizza 51 would be our first. It did not disappoint. I had one of the specialty pizzas and he had pepperoni. Sauce to crust ratio was good.
… more
Donald Ramirez
This is one of the coolest pizza places around. It is hard to pick out just one thing to discuss. The service was excellent and I received great recommendations from the cashier. She discussed the specials and answered all my questions. The price was fair.
… more
Roy Napora
Pretty good pizza. Not head-spinning, but certainly worth the price. Friendly staff, and they have somewhat reasonable prices. It really probably would have been close to 4 stars but the very thin paper plates with the ruffles around the edges just took it down a notch. Just buy some regular steel plates or something. The inside needs a little sprucing up but the garden, outside the garage doors, is nice.
… more
J Bern
The pizza was great. We got the cow town pizza. We also sat in a tiny compact booth! It did have a sign matching the rest of the restaurants decor and I appreciate the humor. They got 3 stars because the atmosphere was weird and listening to the employees bicker with each other wasn’t what I wanted to listen to while eating dinner. They also have a 1 free refill rule. I’m thirsty! The metal stand they served our pizza on was also dirty when they put it on our table. I’ll probably order from here again but it will be to go.
… more
Joelle Melling
Great pizza, inadequate seating and shade. Umbrellas in summer would greatly improve the experience so customers aren’t competing for shade. Also, a visual cue or sign so people know to bus their own tables could help clear more indoor seating (you can’t see the tray drop-off from where you order, and if indoor seating is full, you never see it).
… more
… View more