Based on 158 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
187 Columbia Turnpike, Florham Park, NJ 07932
Phone: (973) 966-1062
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
G J James
Decent for a quick on the go bite. It’s a roll of the dice as far as quality/taste goes. Sometimes a whole pizza is under-cooked. Taste of most food is okay, but not great, no wow factor. Given how expensive most all eateries are now, taste & quality are thee MOST important factor. Friendly place, but FPP get’s a 2 out of 5 for the taste aspect imo. Just a bit of improvement would set this p[lace apart from all the others indeed!
… more
Liza San Luis
FP Pizza was my go to but the pizza cheese was overcooked in some parts….I ordered chicken fingers and ff but the chicken was so dry and fries were double or triple fried and so dried out they went into the garbage. With the price of food these days it was such a disappointment. One good thing from the order was the meatball parm which was heafty and up to FP Pizza standards. It was a Thursday night so should have been better.
… more
Bevy (Ann Tarantino)
Came by this place by chance today. We had a mediocre meatball parm. The bread was good but the meatballs left something to be desired with no flavor. The guy behind the counter who seemed to be an owner was pretty rude with no personality. No need to go back.
… more
5124Grant
Based on slices of grandma’s pizza. Went based on recommendation of local. Did not disappoint. Would return later to try other menu options
… more
Chris W
Google says it closes at 10pm on Friday, so I called at 8:45pm and no one answered the phone. Showed up at 9:00 pm and their open sign was lit up in the window and we walked in and was yelled at that they were closed. Maybe answer your phone when you’re open so you can have better customer service. Drove 20 minutes out the way to try this pizza place but will never do that again.
… more
Michael Curi
We used to think this was the best pizza in the area. Super thin crust and great flavors. But last night we got 3 pies and a couple slices and the pizza was completely different. Crust was thicker and the edge was a hard and dry texture, like cardboard. Not sure what happened. I am so sad….
… more
Michelle Wadleigh
Small place with some tables. Great pizza and my favorite eggplant parmigiana. Stacked thinly sliced eggplant. Moved out of florham Park about 10 years ago but both my husband and I still drive out of our way to get their egg plant. Family owned and operated. There’s always soccer on the television. Nice clean place with an old world feel.
… more
Arch
Stopped in here for a quick pie while out for business. The pizza was AMAZING. It really had that classic New York style taste and look to it. Wasn’t too saucy or cheese, the crust was a nice middle ground of doughy and crispy without being burnt. Pizza was done pretty quick too. The interior is small so not many could eat in here but I would absolutely order out from here more often if I lived close enough for delivery.
… more
luscious click
August 2022- Not quite sure how this place has such high ratings… actually never mind I know why.. but ordered a chicken fettuccine Alfredo and it was THE BLANDEST THING I EVER TASTED!!! Talk about no seasoning what so ever and the Alfredo sauce was so watery that the driver that delivered said some of the sauce spilled out and it was all over the box and container. I had to clean the container for a bit before i could eat. The chicken wasn’t even seasoned as well… at least put a little garlic and onion powder. I literally ended up cutting my break short and drove out to the nearest store ro get seasoning because it was inedible. Paid over $12 for the pasta and the container wasn’t full as well… very BLAND
… more
Donald Zawisha Sr
Plain slice sauce was salty to me.
… more
… View more